TABLE 1.
Cognitive Domain | Author/Ref | Age(s) Tested | Task Description | Sleep bout(s) considered | Experimental Manipulation? | Immediatea Post-Sleep Benefit? | Next-Day Benefit? | Extended (>24 hour) Benefit? |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Declarative Memory | Seehagen et al. [13] | 6 & 12mo | Deferred imitation | Nap & Overnight | Nap vs. No Nap vs. Baseline | Yes | Yes | |
Friedrich et al. [14] | 9–16mo | New word learning (specific exemplars) | Nap | Nap vs. No Nap | Yes | |||
Friedrich et al. [17] | 14–17mo | Episodic memory (old vs. new objects) | Nap | Nap vs. No Nap | Yes | |||
Horvath et al. [15] | 16mo | Object-word pair associations | Nap | Nap vs. No Nap | Yes | |||
Kurdziel et al. [7] | 36–67mo | Visuospatial recall | Nap & Overnight | Nap vs. No Nap | Yes | Yes | ||
Lokhandwala et al. [18] | 36–71 mo | Episodic recall (storybook paradigm) | Nap & Overnight | Nap vs. No Nap | Yes | Yes | ||
Williams & Horst [19] | 3.5y | New word learning (storybook paradigm) | Nap, Overnight, 1wk later | Nap vs. No Nap | Yes | Yes | Yes | |
Spanò et al. [39] | 41–84mo | Word learning | Nap & Overnight | Nap vs. No Nap | Yes | Yes | ||
Henderson et al. [21] | 7–12y | Word learning, visuospatial recall | Overnight, 1wk later | AM vs. PM learning | Yesb, but no comparison after sleep across groups | Yes (relative to own prior timepoint) | Yes (relative to own prior timepoint) | |
Peiffer et al. [42] | 7–12y, adults | Definition learning | Overnight | AM vs. PM learning groups | Yes, for children only | |||
Wilhelm et al. [41] | 8–11y, adults | Declarative recall of motor sequences | Overnight | Nocturnal sleep vs. Daytime wake | Yes | |||
James et al. [23] | 8–12y | New word learning (picture-naming, stem-completion, object-location) | Overnight | Nocturnal sleep vs. Daytime wake | Yes (night condition improved > day from 0–12hr) | Yesc (day condition improved > night from 12–24hr) | Yes (night condition improved > day relative to own baselines) | |
Backhaus et al. [20] | 9–12y | Word pair associations | Overnight | AM vs. PM learning | Yes, but no comparison after sleep across conditions | Yesd (relative to own baseline) | ||
Voderholzer et al. [29] | 13–17y | Word pair associations | Overnight (multiple days) | Sleep restriction (5,6,7,8,9 hours) | No differences | |||
Kopasz et al. [28] | 14–16y | Word pair associations | Overnight (multiple days) | Sleep restriction (4 hours vs. 9 hours) | No differences | |||
Hahn et al. [43] | 14–18y | Word pair associations | Overnight | Wake (AM learning) vs. Sleep (PM learning) | Yes | |||
Cousins et al. [30] | 15–18y | Picture Encoding | Overnight (multiple days) | Sleep restriction (5 hours vs. 9 hours) | Yes | |||
Lau et al.[25] | 15–18y | Word pair associations, story recall, list learning | Nap | Nap vs. No Nap | Yese | |||
Holz et al. [27] | 16–17y | Word pair associations | Overnight | Afternoon vs. Evening Learning | No | No differences | ||
Gais et al. [24] | 17y | Novel word learning | Overnight | Multiple sleep-delay | Yes | Yes | Yes | |
Leong et al. [26] | 17y | Semantic categorization | Overnight | Wake vs. Sleep | Yes | |||
Procedural Memory | Fagen & Rovee-Collier [46] | 3 mo | Operant foot kicking | Not specified (total sleep time across 8 hours interval) | Observational (correlation btwn sleep duration and recall) | Yes | ||
Berger & Scher [47] | 9–16mo | Tunnel task | Nap | Nap vs. No Nap | Yes | |||
Desrochers et al. [48] | 33–71mo | Serial reaction time | Nap & Overnight | Nap vs. No Nap | No differences | Yes | ||
Wilhelm et al. [49] | 4–6y | Motor sequence learning | Nap | Nap vs. No Nap × Standard vs. Extended training | Yesf | |||
Wilhelm et al. [22] | 6–8y | Finger sequence tapping | Overnight | Nocturnal sleep vs. Daytime wake | No | |||
Fischer et al. [51] | 7–11y | Serial reaction time | Overnight | Nocturnal sleep vs. Daytime wake | No | |||
Henderson et al. [21] | 7–12y | Serial reaction time | Overnight, 1wk later | AM vs. PM Learning | No differences | No differences | No differences | |
Prehn-Kristensen et al. [50] | 10–13y | Mirror tracing | Overnight | Nocturnal sleep vs. Daytime wake | No differences | |||
Holz et al. [27] | 16–17y | Finger sequence tapping | Overnight | Afternoon vs. Evening Learning | Yes | Yes | ||
Generalization | Friedrich et al. [96] | 6–8mo | Object-label generalization | Nap | Short vs. Long nap | Yesg | ||
Simon et al. [97] | 6.5mo | Declarative retention of statistical learning | Nap | Nap vs. No Nap | Yes (block-specific) | |||
Friedrich et al. [14] | 9–16mo | Object-label generalization | Nap | Nap vs. No Nap | Yes | |||
Konrad et al., [66] | 12mo | Generalization of deferred imitation | Nap | Nap vs. No Nap | Yes | |||
Gómez et al. [64] | 15mo | Artificial language | Nap | Nap vs. No Nap | Yes | |||
Hupbach et al. [65] | 15mo | Artificial language | Nap & Overnight | Nap vs. No Nap | Yes | |||
Horváth et al. [98] | 16mo | Object-label generalization | Nap | Nap vs. No Nap | Yes | |||
Werchan & Gomez [69] | 2.5y | Noun learning | Nap | Nap vs. No Nap | No | |||
Werchan et al. [71] | 29–36mo | Noun learning | Nap & Overnight | Nap/Overnight vs. No-Nap/Overnight vs. Nap Only | Unclear (no No-Nap Only group) | Yes | ||
Sandoval et al. [70] | 3y | Verb learning | Nap & Overnight | Nap vs. No Nap | Yes | |||
Emotional Cognition | Mindell et al. [77] | 3–18mo | Social Emotional Assessment | Overall sleep patterns | Observational: Assessments at 6, 12, and 18mo | Yes | ||
Berger et al. [80] | 2.5–3y | Emotion-eliciting task | Nap | Nap vs. No Nap | Yes | |||
Kurdziel et al. [78] | 34–64mo | Emotional memory | Nap & Overnight | Nap vs. No Nap | No differences | Yes | ||
Cremone et al. [79] | 3–5y | Dot Probe (Emotional Attention Bias) | Nap | Nap vs. No Nap | Yes | |||
Bolinger et al. [81] | 8–11y | Emotional/Neutral pictures | Overnight | Nocturnal sleep vs. Daytime wake | Yes | |||
Vriend et al. [84] | 8–12y | Affective response task (ART) | Overnight | Sleep restriction and extension | Yes | |||
Prehn-Kri stensen et al. [89] | 9–12y | Emotional picture recognition | Overnight | Nocturnal sleep vs. Daytime wake | Yesh | |||
Prehn-Kri stensen et al. [50] | 10–13y | Emotional recognition task | Overnight | Nocturnal sleep vs. Daytime wake | Yes | |||
Baum et al. [85] | 14–17y | Mood and emotion regulation assessments | Overnight | Sleep restriction | Yes | |||
Short & Louca [86] | 14–18y | Profile of Mood States | Overnight | Baseline vs. total sleep deprivation | Yes |
Indicative of a sleep benefit
No sleep benefit or detriment
Indicative of sleep detriment
“Immediate” refers to recall ≤4hours after the first sleep bout. I.e., following a nap in nap+overnight protocols, in the morning following overnight protocols
A group effect was observed for the explicit word learning task, and group × timepoint interactions for both declarative tasks
Only for picture-naming reaction time; no differences for picture-naming accuracy, stem-completion, or object-location tasks
While memory did not increase further after the wake interval, the boost resulting from overnight sleep remained
Nap benefited story word-pair recall, but not for list learning
With extended training
short naps promoted surface-level associations; long nap promoted more semantically-based associations.
Typically developing children benefited from sleep, while those with ADHD did not.