Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2022 Jun 1.
Published in final edited form as: Sleep Med Rev. 2021 Mar 13;57:101472. doi: 10.1016/j.smrv.2021.101472

TABLE 1.

Developmental studies assessing relations between sleep and cognition (ordered by age tested).

Cognitive Domain Author/Ref Age(s) Tested Task Description Sleep bout(s) considered Experimental Manipulation? Immediatea Post-Sleep Benefit? Next-Day Benefit? Extended (>24 hour) Benefit?
Declarative Memory Seehagen et al. [13] 6 & 12mo Deferred imitation Nap & Overnight Nap vs. No Nap vs. Baseline Yes Yes
Friedrich et al. [14] 9–16mo New word learning (specific exemplars) Nap Nap vs. No Nap Yes
Friedrich et al. [17] 14–17mo Episodic memory (old vs. new objects) Nap Nap vs. No Nap Yes
Horvath et al. [15] 16mo Object-word pair associations Nap Nap vs. No Nap Yes
Kurdziel et al. [7] 36–67mo Visuospatial recall Nap & Overnight Nap vs. No Nap Yes Yes
Lokhandwala et al. [18] 36–71 mo Episodic recall (storybook paradigm) Nap & Overnight Nap vs. No Nap Yes Yes
Williams & Horst [19] 3.5y New word learning (storybook paradigm) Nap, Overnight, 1wk later Nap vs. No Nap Yes Yes Yes
Spanò et al. [39] 41–84mo Word learning Nap & Overnight Nap vs. No Nap Yes Yes
Henderson et al. [21] 7–12y Word learning, visuospatial recall Overnight, 1wk later AM vs. PM learning Yesb, but no comparison after sleep across groups Yes (relative to own prior timepoint) Yes (relative to own prior timepoint)
Peiffer et al. [42] 7–12y, adults Definition learning Overnight AM vs. PM learning groups Yes, for children only
Wilhelm et al. [41] 8–11y, adults Declarative recall of motor sequences Overnight Nocturnal sleep vs. Daytime wake Yes
James et al. [23] 8–12y New word learning (picture-naming, stem-completion, object-location) Overnight Nocturnal sleep vs. Daytime wake Yes (night condition improved > day from 0–12hr) Yesc (day condition improved > night from 12–24hr) Yes (night condition improved > day relative to own baselines)
Backhaus et al. [20] 9–12y Word pair associations Overnight AM vs. PM learning Yes, but no comparison after sleep across conditions Yesd (relative to own baseline)
Voderholzer et al. [29] 13–17y Word pair associations Overnight (multiple days) Sleep restriction (5,6,7,8,9 hours) No differences
Kopasz et al. [28] 14–16y Word pair associations Overnight (multiple days) Sleep restriction (4 hours vs. 9 hours) No differences
Hahn et al. [43] 14–18y Word pair associations Overnight Wake (AM learning) vs. Sleep (PM learning) Yes
Cousins et al. [30] 15–18y Picture Encoding Overnight (multiple days) Sleep restriction (5 hours vs. 9 hours) Yes
Lau et al.[25] 15–18y Word pair associations, story recall, list learning Nap Nap vs. No Nap Yese
Holz et al. [27] 16–17y Word pair associations Overnight Afternoon vs. Evening Learning No No differences
Gais et al. [24] 17y Novel word learning Overnight Multiple sleep-delay Yes Yes Yes
Leong et al. [26] 17y Semantic categorization Overnight Wake vs. Sleep Yes
Procedural Memory Fagen & Rovee-Collier [46] 3 mo Operant foot kicking Not specified (total sleep time across 8 hours interval) Observational (correlation btwn sleep duration and recall) Yes
Berger & Scher [47] 9–16mo Tunnel task Nap Nap vs. No Nap Yes
Desrochers et al. [48] 33–71mo Serial reaction time Nap & Overnight Nap vs. No Nap No differences Yes
Wilhelm et al. [49] 4–6y Motor sequence learning Nap Nap vs. No Nap × Standard vs. Extended training Yesf
Wilhelm et al. [22] 6–8y Finger sequence tapping Overnight Nocturnal sleep vs. Daytime wake No
Fischer et al. [51] 7–11y Serial reaction time Overnight Nocturnal sleep vs. Daytime wake No
Henderson et al. [21] 7–12y Serial reaction time Overnight, 1wk later AM vs. PM Learning No differences No differences No differences
Prehn-Kristensen et al. [50] 10–13y Mirror tracing Overnight Nocturnal sleep vs. Daytime wake No differences
Holz et al. [27] 16–17y Finger sequence tapping Overnight Afternoon vs. Evening Learning Yes Yes
Generalization Friedrich et al. [96] 6–8mo Object-label generalization Nap Short vs. Long nap Yesg
Simon et al. [97] 6.5mo Declarative retention of statistical learning Nap Nap vs. No Nap Yes (block-specific)
Friedrich et al. [14] 9–16mo Object-label generalization Nap Nap vs. No Nap Yes
Konrad et al., [66] 12mo Generalization of deferred imitation Nap Nap vs. No Nap Yes
Gómez et al. [64] 15mo Artificial language Nap Nap vs. No Nap Yes
Hupbach et al. [65] 15mo Artificial language Nap & Overnight Nap vs. No Nap Yes
Horváth et al. [98] 16mo Object-label generalization Nap Nap vs. No Nap Yes
Werchan & Gomez [69] 2.5y Noun learning Nap Nap vs. No Nap No
Werchan et al. [71] 29–36mo Noun learning Nap & Overnight Nap/Overnight vs. No-Nap/Overnight vs. Nap Only Unclear (no No-Nap Only group) Yes
Sandoval et al. [70] 3y Verb learning Nap & Overnight Nap vs. No Nap Yes
Emotional Cognition Mindell et al. [77] 3–18mo Social Emotional Assessment Overall sleep patterns Observational: Assessments at 6, 12, and 18mo Yes
Berger et al. [80] 2.5–3y Emotion-eliciting task Nap Nap vs. No Nap Yes
Kurdziel et al. [78] 34–64mo Emotional memory Nap & Overnight Nap vs. No Nap No differences Yes
Cremone et al. [79] 3–5y Dot Probe (Emotional Attention Bias) Nap Nap vs. No Nap Yes
Bolinger et al. [81] 8–11y Emotional/Neutral pictures Overnight Nocturnal sleep vs. Daytime wake Yes
Vriend et al. [84] 8–12y Affective response task (ART) Overnight Sleep restriction and extension Yes
Prehn-Kri stensen et al. [89] 9–12y Emotional picture recognition Overnight Nocturnal sleep vs. Daytime wake Yesh
Prehn-Kri stensen et al. [50] 10–13y Emotional recognition task Overnight Nocturnal sleep vs. Daytime wake Yes
Baum et al. [85] 14–17y Mood and emotion regulation assessments Overnight Sleep restriction Yes
Short & Louca [86] 14–18y Profile of Mood States Overnight Baseline vs. total sleep deprivation Yes

Indicative of a sleep benefit

No sleep benefit or detriment

Indicative of sleep detriment

a

“Immediate” refers to recall ≤4hours after the first sleep bout. I.e., following a nap in nap+overnight protocols, in the morning following overnight protocols

b

A group effect was observed for the explicit word learning task, and group × timepoint interactions for both declarative tasks

c

Only for picture-naming reaction time; no differences for picture-naming accuracy, stem-completion, or object-location tasks

d

While memory did not increase further after the wake interval, the boost resulting from overnight sleep remained

e

Nap benefited story word-pair recall, but not for list learning

f

With extended training

g

short naps promoted surface-level associations; long nap promoted more semantically-based associations.

h

Typically developing children benefited from sleep, while those with ADHD did not.