Table 2.
Characteristics of included studies.
Study Reference | Country | Design/Method | Population | Sample Size | Sample Characteristics | Analysis | Research Question |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Ahlstedt Karlsson et al. (2019) [33] | Sweden | Focus group | Women treated with Tamoxifen after breast cancer surgery | 25 | Median age: 62 years (range 42–80); 92% Married/co-habiting, 8% Single; 40% Retired; 60% Employed full or part time | Content analysis | To explore women's experiences with HT |
Bedi (2018) [26] | USA | Focus group | Hormone receptor-positive breast cancer survivors under age 64 who had been prescribed ET since 2000; 50% on Tamoxifen, 41% on Aromatase Inhibitors, and 9% had switched. | 22 | Median age: 52 years when first prescribed ET (Range: 37–63 years); 64% Caucasian, 23% African American, and 14% Other Race; 18% High School Diploma, 14% Associate Degree, 41% Bachelors' Degree, 18% Post-Baccalaureate Degree, And 9% Preferred Not to Answer | Grounded theory | To understand from the survivor perspective which modifiable factors could have the greatest impact on the likelihood of HT continuation |
Bluethmann et al. (2017) [34] | USA | Mixed method - interview | Breast cancer survivors who were prescribed adjuvant hormone therapy (i.e., Tamoxifen or AI). | 27 | Mean Age: 57 Years (Range = 49–86 Years); 27 Non-Hispanic White, 1 Non-Hispanic Black, 2 Hispanic; 22 Married, 8 Other; 4 High School Diploma, 5 Some College Or Technical School, 15 Bachelor's Degree, 6 Graduate Degree | Grounded theory | To describe survivors' reported appraisal and management of medication-related side effects and deconstruct survivors' decisions to initiate, discontinue, or maintain adjuvant hormone therapy. |
Brauer et al. (2016) [38] | USA | Interview | Early-stage breast cancer, age 65 years and older taking AI | 27 | Mean age: 73.3 years (range 66–91); 4 Divorced, 1 Never married, 12 Married or living as married, 9 Widowed, 1 Separated; | Grounded theory | To explore how survivors of breast cancer made decisions about persisting with AIs, including specific challenges as well as attempts to manage them. |
7 High school diploma, 2 Some College, 9 Bachelor's Degree, 3 Some Graduate School, 6 Graduate Degree | |||||||
Brett et al. (2018) [27] | UK | Interview | Women who had been prescribed adjuvant hormone therapy, 19 Tamoxifen, 4 AI and 9 switched, 2–4 years following their diagnosis of breast cancer. | 32 | Adherers | Framework analysis | Identify the factors that influence whether women adhere to or do not adhere to adjuvant hormone therapy |
median age: 59 (Range 37–77) | |||||||
15 (79%) Married, 1 (5%) Single, 3 (16%) Separated - Widow; | |||||||
1 (5%) O′ O” level, GCSE, or equivalent, 16 (84%) College or university degree, 2 (11%) Postgraduate qualification; | |||||||
Non-adherers | |||||||
median age: 64 (Range 53–76); | |||||||
10 (77%) Married, 2 (15%) Single, 1 (8%) Separated; | |||||||
9 (69%) College or university degree, 4 (31%) Postgraduate qualification | |||||||
Cahir et al. (2015) [39] | Ireland | Interview | Women with stage I-III breast cancer prescribed adjuvant hormonal therapy purposively sampled by their medication taking behaviour at two cancer centres. | 31 | Mean age 51 years (SD ± 10); | Thematic analysis | To investigate influences on adjuvant hormonal therapy Medication Taking Behaviour in women with stage I–III breast cancer. |
7 Single, 24 Married/cohabiting; | |||||||
Employed: 16 Yes, 15 No | |||||||
Cheng et al. (2017) [28] | China | Interview | Breast cancer survivors (<5 years after diagnosis) | 19 | Mean age: 54 years (range 41–65 years); 95% of the participants were unemployed or retired | Content analysis | Reveal Breast Cancer Survivor's views and experiences of self-management in extended survivorship |
Harrow et al. (2014) [29] | UK | Interview | Women who had been prescribed tamoxifen or aromatase inhibitors (anastrozole or letrozole) and had been taking this medication for 1–5 years | 30 | Ages: <50 years 2 (7%), 50–64 years 15 (50%), ≥65 years 12 (40%), age unknown 1 (3%); | Constant comparison method applied within the framework approach | Women's experiences of taking adjuvant hormone therapy; their understandings and reasons for taking or not taking medication and the factors which influenced adherence or non-adherence and the information and support they received or desired. |
3 (10%) premenopausal, 7 (23%), perimenopausal, 17 (57%), postmenopausal, 3 (10%) unknown | |||||||
Humphries et al. (2018) [35] | Canada | Interviews and focus groups | Women aged 18 years or older, diagnosed with hormone receptor-positive breast cancer, had a first adjuvant hormone therapy prescription for early breast cancer within the last two years and sufficient fluency in French. 19 Tamoxifen, 3 Letrozole, and 21 Anastrozole | 43 | Ages: ≤49: 6, 50–59: 17, 60–69: 10, ≥70: 10; | Thematic Analysis | Identify women's attitudinal, normative, and control beliefs regarding adjuvant hormone therapy adherence that could be targeted by an intervention offered in the community pharmacy setting. |
2 Primary school, 8 Secondary school, 14 College, 19 University | |||||||
Iacorossi et al. (2018) [36] | Italy | Interview | Women aged between 44 and 75 years, diagnosed with breast cancer, who were being treated with endocrine therapy mainly Tamoxifen. | 27 | Median Age: 52 years, mean: 55.9 years, (range: 44–75 years); | Framework Analysis | To explore the experiences of adherence to hormone therapy in women with breast cancer. |
5 Single, 15 Married, 5 Divorced, 2 Widowed | |||||||
Lambert et al. (2018) [37] | Canada | Interview | Women diagnosed with HR + stage I to III breast cancer, without a prior cancer diagnosis, recurrence of breast cancer, or secondary cancer diagnosis (excluding non-melanoma skin cancer), who had completed primary cancer treatment, were fluent in English, aged 18–79 years at diagnosis, and prescribed Adjuvant Hormone Therapy. | 22 | Ages: 45–60 years 11 (50%), 60–79 years 11 (50%) | Thematic Analysis | To explore breast cancer survivors' experiences and perspectives of adjuvant hormone therapy use to describe how personal, social, and structural factors influence adjuvant hormone therapy persistence. |
Mao et al. (2013) [25] | USA | Mixed method – online forum posts | Posts collected from breast cancer message boards between February 2002 and May 2010. | 12 different breast cancer message boards | Data on sample not collected. | Content Analysis | To evaluate the volume and frequency of AI-associated side effects reported on internet message boards. |
Moon et al. (2017) [30] | UK | Interview | Breast cancer survivors who had been prescribed tamoxifen | 32 | Mean age: 55 years (range: 36 to 77, SD = 10.6); 16 Post-Menopausal, 5 Pre-Menopausal, 5 Perimenopausal, 6 Unsure; 24 White, 5 Black British, 2 Asian/Asian British, 1 Mixed | Thematic Analysis | To elicit abroad understanding of women's lived experiences of tamoxifen, their motivation to adhere to treatment and identify reasons for non-adherence and non-persistence, in their own words. |
Pieters et al. (2019) [40] | USA | Interview | Women aged at least 65 years old, started an AI for loco-regional (Stage I, II or III) breast cancer 4–36 months prior to enrolment and were in charge of taking their own medications. | 54 | Mean age: 73.3 years (range = 66–91); | Thematic Analysis | To describe and compare how women treated for primary early-stage breast cancer either persisting or not persisting with an AI received, interpreted, and acted upon AI-related information. |
44 White, 3 Latina, 3 Japanese, 2 Chinese, 1 Korean, 1 African American; 24 Married, 2 Never married, 16 Widowed, 10 Divorced, 2 Separated; | |||||||
9 High School Graduate, 7 Some College, 19 College Graduate, 5 Some Graduate School, 14 Graduated Grad School; Household Income: 14: $21k-$40,999, 8: $41k-60,999, 13: $61k-80,999, 5: $81k-100,999, 12: >$101k | |||||||
Van Londen et al. (2014) [31] | USA | Focus group | Breast cancer survivors, aged 50 years or older, with Adjuvant Hormone Therapy-related symptoms | 14 | Mean age: 58.8 years (SD: 6.7); 100% Caucasian; 79% Married; 21% Employed, 79% Not Working (retired, disabled, not able to find a job) | Thematic Analysis | To explore survivors' recollection of the conversation with the medical oncologist about starting Adjuvant Hormone Therapy, experiences with Adjuvant Hormone Therapy-related symptoms, Adjuvant Hormone Therapy-related symptom management, challenges to taking Adjuvant Hormone Therapy, and views about how Adjuvant Hormone Therapy-related symptoms might be better managed. |
Wells et al. (2016) [32] | USA | Interview | Underserved breast cancer survivors at a comprehensive cancer centre in the south eastern United States. | 25 | Mean age: 59.92 (Range 46–71 years; SD = 6.82); | Content Analysis | To evaluate the barriers and facilitators to taking anti-hormonal medications among medically and historically underserved breast cancer survivors within the first five years post chemotherapy, radiation, and/or definitive surgery. |
(15 = no, 10 = yes) Hispanic/Latina, 13 White, 7 African American, 1 Asian, 4 other; 4 Single, 8 Married, 11 Separated, 2 Widowed; | |||||||
11 Not Currently Employed, 8 Part-Time, 6 Full-Time |