Skip to main content
. 2021 May 28;9(5):e27965. doi: 10.2196/27965

Table 6.

Themes, subthemes, and quotes by participants.

Main theme and subthemes Participant quotes
Content

Learning “I enjoyed learning about new forms of interaction and their applications.” (Participant #3)
“I appreciated tips given during the course, since they were very interesting and also useful for learning new skills.” (Participant #10)

Reflection “Reported topics were all interesting and quick to address. I spent very little time with the chatbot but I think I got some food for thought.” (Participant #1)

Multimedia “I liked the guided meditation videos.” (Participant #5)
“I really liked the relaxation videos.” (Participant #7)
“It was nice to have the possibility to access videos and not just texts, that can be boring.” (Participant #8)
“I enjoyed the guided meditation videos.” (Participant #13)
“What I liked most were the mindfulness and motivational videos.” (Participant #16)
“Videos were long and I often tended to quit them before the end.” (Participant #3)
“Videos often recommended walking or covering distances, which made it difficult to perform the task for people like me who live in a small indoor place (I often did not have the possibility or desire to move outdoors).” (Participant #9)
“What I liked less was the videos. They were interesting, but I think they should be improved in terms of graphics and visuals in order to be engaging for users.” (Participant #10)

Routine “Unfortunately receiving videos for me had become a pleasant habit, so when it went over it looked like a sudden interruption to me.” (Participant #16)

Mindfulness “Breathing tips, calm tone of voice put me in a good mood, dialogues were motivating and relaxing.” (Participant #9)
“I find the bot an excellent first opportunity to practice mindfulness, especially for those who - like me - can never find the time to stop and breathe and have never tried anything like this before.” (Participant #13)

Motivation “Low incentive.” (Participant #2)
“It didn’t appeal to me so much, so I struggled to be constant.” (Participant #15)

Originality “The originality of the exercises, in my opinion, it is very important to foster a change in people to help them.” (Participant #6)

Repetitiveness “In my opinion, questions should vary over time: ‘how are you’ should be asked in a more nuanced way, otherwise it sounds repetitive. I suggest, if possible, to vary the dialogues with the user, especially the welcoming messages.” (Participant #16)
User experience

Sense of reality “First of all, I appreciated the continuity of the short course with the chatbot, the interactions were well thought out and articulated, it felt like chatting with a real person.” (Participant #1)

Interaction “I would have liked to have more dialogues with the chatbot and less external interaction (YouTube video).” (Participant #1)
“I would prefer to interact and chat whenever I wish, and not only on fixed days.” (Participant #8)
“The interaction with Atena should be more personalized based on the user’s answers, sometimes the answering options did not take into account the different nuances of mood.” (Participant #9)
“Interactions could only take place on the days agreed upon at the outset.” (Participant #13)

Flexibility “I really liked being able to have flexibility in the scheduling.” (Participant #2)
Tasks

Notification “Notifications reminding people to take the test.” (Participant #4)
“I feel satisfied. My only remark is about the notifications in the dialogue flow, which tended to be overlooked.” (Participant #4)
“Not having time when the message arrived and then forgetting to do the exercises.” (Participant #5)
“Atena sent me notifications when it was not suitable for me (despite my choosing of scheduling options) and then I forgot to do the activity.” (Participant #7)
“It would be nice to specify at the very beginning when an activity requires places larger than a room or also to be outdoors.” (Participant #9)
“I often didn’t have time to watch videos at the scheduled time, then I forgot to resume them because there was no reminder.” (Participant #15)

Availability “I can watch videos again whenever I like.” (Participant #11)
“The scheduling options, in my opinion, should be more restrictive, or maybe deadlines could be set for some tasks.” (Participant #6)
“The videos made it difficult for me to find enough time to watch them.” (Participant #12)