Skip to main content
. 2021 May 25;7(5):e07038. doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2021.e07038

Table 4b.

Average and standard deviation of RMSE and AIC parameters from the exponential, the Bradford and Schijven (2002), Vadas et al. (2004), and Guber et al. (2013) Models fitted to the effluent data under different manure fraction and boundary conditions (i.e., 0.5-mm and Time-variable max values).

C0 = 0.5-mm
0.25-mm
0.5-mm
1.0-mm
2.0-mm
Model RMSE AIC RMSE AIC RMSE AIC RMSE AIC
Exponential 14.174 (±0.462) 153.188 (±1.884) 23.518 (±17.090) 178.148 (±38.595) 10.827 (±0.447) 139.253 (±2.406) 25.224 (±0.968) 188.314 (±2.215)
Bradford and Schijven (2002)
Vadas et al. (2004) 2.608 (±0.075) 57.650 (±1.651) 2.290 (±2.635) 35.596 (±62.510) 1.552 (±0.199) 28.629 (±7.485) 3.698 (±0.155) 79.257 (±2.423)
Guber et al. (2013)
0.974 (±0.053)
2.365 (±3.083)
1.055 (±0.022)
9.055 (±1.234)
1.554 (±0.199)
31.208 (±7.478)
1.477 (±0.142)
28.375 (±5.732)
C0 = Time-var max 0.25-mm 0.5-mm 1.0-mm 2.0-mm
Model
RMSE
AIC
RMSE
AIC
RMSE
AIC
RMSE
AIC
Exponential 8.359 (±0.399) 124.242 (±2.734) 9.151 (±1.770) 128.855 (±10.715) 6.803 (±0.264) 112.309 (±2.267) 5.423 (±0.240) 99.147 (±2.550)
Bradford and Schijven (2002) 6.875 115.260
Vadas et al. (2004) 1.365 (±0.039) 21.483 (±1.655) 1.176 (±0.311) 11.288 (±16.880) 0.631 (±0.059) -23.453 (±5.625) 0.892 (±0.037) -3.243 (±2.423)
Guber et al. (2013) 0.552 (±0.057) -28.703 (±5.816) 0.621 (±0.174) -23.132 (±15.365) 0.631 (±0.062) -20.960 (±5.837) 0.356 (±0.034) -54.124 (±5.732)