Table 5.
Tool | Time | RAM (MB) | |
---|---|---|---|
Yeast | |||
ABySS unitig | 00:00:11:03 | 2283 | |
ABySS full | 00:00:20:01 | 2283 | |
Mapping | 00:00:00:05 | 540 | |
LazyB | 00:00:00:30 | 136 | |
A+m+ LazyB | 00:00:11:38 | 2283 | |
Canu | 00:10:23:55 | 2617 | |
Wtdbg2 | 00:00:13:08 | 698 | |
HASLR | 00:00:06:44 | 4922 | |
DBG2OL | 00:00:31:46 | 1141 | |
Wengan | 00:00:06:45 | 4400 | |
A+Wengan | 00:00:26:46 | 4400 | |
Mapping | 00:00:00:15 | 1544 | |
LazyB | 00:00:01:46 | 362 | |
A+m+ LazyB | 00:00:13:04 | 2283 | |
Canu | 00:13:44:16 | 6779 | |
Wtdbg2 | 00:00:29:28 | 1142 | |
HASLR | 00:00:08:09 | 4922 | |
DBG2OL | 00:00:51:13 | 1264 | |
Wengan | 00:00:14:29 | 4421 | |
A+Wengan | 00:00:34:30 | 4421 | |
Fruit fly | |||
ABySS untig | 00:02:32:39 | 25344 | |
ABySS full | 00:04:56:03 | 25346 | |
Mapping | 00:00:02:43 | 6433 | |
LazyB | 00:00:08:33 | 613 | |
A+m+ LazyB | 00:02:43:55 | 25344 | |
Canu | 02:13:51:39 | 7531 | |
Wtdbg2 | 00:01:37:41 | 3395 | |
HASLR | 00:01:30:33 | 5531 | |
DBG2OL | 00:07:58:22 | 6151 | |
Wengan | 00:01:41:26 | 5394 | |
A+Wengan | 00:06:10:29 | 25346 | |
Mapping | 00:00:06:11 | 9491 | |
LazyB | 00:00:11:57 | 2241 | |
A+m+ LazyB | 00:02:50:47 | 25344 | |
Canu | 07:04:08:28 | 7541 | |
Wtdbg2 | 00:04:02:43 | 5024 | |
HASLR | 00:01:43:21 | 5553 | |
DBG2OL | 02:07:32:01 | 17171 | |
Wengan | 00:02:28:51 | 5323 | |
A+Wengan | 00:07:24:54 | 25346 |
Step (1) is often not needed as short-read assemblies are available for many organisms
Similarly, Wengan requires a full ABySS assembly as a its basis. Resources are only compared for yeast and fruit fly, because Canu cannot be run for human in acceptable time and resource-constraints on our equipment. As all tools except LazyB and DBG2OL are parallelized, running times are given as the sum of time spent by all CPUs. Therefore, computational effort is measured rather than wallclock time. ABySS greatly dominates the LazyB pipeline and to a lesser degree also Wengan. Nevertheless, LazyB is faster by a factor of compared to Canu, compared to DBG2OL, and to Wengan