Skip to main content
. 2021 Jun 1;75:168–185. doi: 10.1016/j.inffus.2021.05.015

Table 5.

Classification results of each model on our dataset. “M” means ×106. Batch time means the runtime of each batch in the model testing.

Method Modality Accuracy Precision Sensitivity Specificity F1-score AUC Parameters (a.k.a., model size) Batch time
CAAD [35] XR 0.7394 0.7430 0.7659 0.7791 0.7543 0.7488 138.3M 2.06 s
COVID-CAPS [82] XR 0.7413 0.7450 0.7689 0.7844 0.7568 0.7540 23M 2.09 s
COVID-DA [83] XR 0.7446 0.7471 0.7692 0.7844 0.7580 0.7593 33M 2.32 s
COVID-ResNet [84] XR 0.7466 0.7497 0.7747 0.7856 0.7620 0.7702 60.2M 2.31 s
DCSL [85] XR 0.7486 0.7510 0.7777 0.7870 0.7641 0.7709 125M 2.54 s

COVNet [86] CT 0.7518 0.7512 0.7805 0.7880 0.7656 0.7812 130.8M 2.18 s
AnoDet [87] CT 0.7552 0.7518 0.7853 0.7907 0.7682 0.7843 125.8M 2.19 s
DLS [88] CT 0.7607 0.7535 0.7878 0.7958 0.7703 0.7878 179.1M 2.18 s
DeCovNet [89] CT 0.7613 0.7573 0.7947 0.8022 0.7755 0.7885 93M 2.12 s
DLQCTM [90] CT 0.7663 0.7648 0.7989 0.8081 0.7815 0.7896 103M 2.26 s

DenseNet-161[91] UL 0.7029 0.7229 0.7394 0.7517 0.7311 0.7285 18.8M 2.12 s
ResNet-34[70] UL 0.7154 0.7288 0.7514 0.7553 0.7400 0.7287 63.6M 0.80 s
VGG-19[66] UL 0.7214 0.7367 0.7525 0.7605 0.7445 0.7307 144M 2.82 s
ResNet-18[70] UL 0.7278 0.7395 0.7575 0.7708 0.7484 0.7434 33.3M 0.56 s
VGG-16[66] UL 0.7365 0.7420 0.7633 0.7777 0.7525 0.7474 140M 2.48 s

DGLM [92] XRCTUL 0.8070 0.7842 0.8322 0.8591 0.8075 0.8067 130.2M 2.08 s
LM3FT [93] XRCTUL 0.8110 0.7984 0.8323 0.8676 0.8150 0.8120 126M 2.16 s
MMCL [94] XRCTUL 0.8120 0.8010 0.8351 0.8682 0.8177 0.8154 129.3M 2.34 s
MEC [95] XRCTUL 0.8122 0.8079 0.8370 0.8716 0.8222 0.8186 131.7M 2.22 s
GMMF [96] XRCTUL 0.8127 0.8082 0.8378 0.8741 0.8227 0.8202 130.3M 2.53 s

Ours w/o knowledge XRCTUL 0.8160 0.8108 0.8378 0.8741 0.8413 0.8234 71.2M 1.74 s
Ours w/o TSAM XRCTUL 0.8308 0.8121 0.8494 0.8898 0.8491 0.8293 70M 1.12 s
Ours w/o knowledge XRCTULT 0.8389 0.8293 0.8297 0.8292 0.8292 0.8319 73M 1.77 s
Ours w/o TSAM XRCTULT 0.8679 0.8688 0.8641 0.8909 0.8664 0.8675 72M 1.14 s

Ours XRCTUL 0.9371 0.9209 0.8884 0.9805 0.9498 0.9171 75.6M 1.12 s
Ours XRCTULT 0.9810 0.9889 0.9861 0.9859 0.9875 0.9908 76.4M 1.14 s