Hafdi 2020.
Study characteristics | ||
Methods | Design: retrospective cohort Setting: community Country: Netherlands Duration of follow‐up (mean): 6.7 years Covariates controlled for: age, sex, history of cardiovascular disease or stroke (or both), education, MMSE at baseline, and Geriatric Depression Scale at baseline |
|
Participants | Participants numbers: 3526 Population type: older adults Sex: 54% women (1919) Age (mean): 74 years |
|
Prognostic factors | Anticholinergic burden measurement method: ACB scale | |
Outcomes | Outcomes assessed: dementia Outcome ascertainment dementia: consensus diagnosis based on multidisciplinary evaluation Diagnostic criteria dementia: DSM‐IV |
|
Source of funding | Dutch Ministry of Health, Welfare and Sport; the Dutch Innovation Fund of Collaborative Health Insurances; and the Netherlands Organisation for Health Research and Development | |
Notes | ||
Item | Authors' judgement | Support for judgement |
Study participation | Yes | Reported age, sex, and comorbidities. Minor issue with slightly restricted age population. |
Study attrition | Unclear | No comparison between completers vs non‐completers/missing data. |
Prognostic factor measurement | Unclear | 2 methods (self‐report cross‐checked with electronic records). Repeated measurement at 2 years – though only once and this study ran for 8 years; no mention of whether anticholinergic scores changed and lack of detail on the question so could not be certain if asked about non‐prescribed drugs. No measure of adherence or dosage. On basis of these issues assigned unclear risk of bias. |
Outcome measurement | Unclear | No blinding but anticholinergic burden assignment conducted after cognitive diagnosis established. |
Study confounding | Yes | Age, sex, and comorbidities all measured. |
Reverse causation | Unclear | Anticholinergic burden measurement taken 2 years before dementia assessment and excluded those who developed dementia in first 2 years after taking anticholinergics. |
Statistical analysis and reporting | Unclear | No protocol or assumptions. |