Kashyap 2014.
Study characteristics | ||
Methods | Design: retrospective cohort Setting: community Country: Canada Duration of follow‐up: 1 year Covariates controlled for: None. |
|
Participants | Participants numbers: 102 Population type: older adults Sex: 84% women (86) Age (mean): 72 years |
|
Prognostic factors | Anticholinergic burden measurement method: DBI‐ach scale; ACB scale; ADS scale; ARS scale | |
Outcomes | Outcomes assessed: MCI; cognitive decline Outcome ascertainment MCI: independent clinical assessment via expert Outcome ascertainment cognitive decline: neuropsychological tests and an MoCA Diagnostic criteria MCI: DSM‐5 criteria for a mild neurocognitive disorder. Diagnostic criteria cognitive decline: 3 different ways: worsening in the raw neuropsychological test scores for each test; a change in scores on each test that exceeded an expected cut‐off based on the test–retest reliable change index; and a change in scores on each test that persisted when regression to the mean, practice effects, and age were accounted for using the standardised regression‐based measure method |
|
Source of funding | Canadian Institutes of Health Research | |
Notes | ||
Item | Authors' judgement | Support for judgement |
Study participation | Unclear | Report on age and sex but did not report which comorbidities they measured. |
Study attrition | Unclear | No comparison with missing data. Did not describe the proportion or potential impact of loss to follow‐up. |
Prognostic factor measurement | Yes | Established by patient self‐report. Validated by nurse checking medication box. Recorded frequency, adherence, and dosage. |
Outcome measurement | Unclear | There was blinding to the mild neurocognitive disorder diagnosis but not to the change in cognition evaluation; retrospective anticholinergic burden determination. |
Study confounding | No | Only conducted univariate analysis. No confounders adjusted for. |
Reverse causation | No | No time restriction on anticholinergic burden measurement (anticholinergic burden measured at baseline then again at 12 months – combined measures and used 'increase in anticholinergic burden' as the independent variable. |
Statistical analysis and reporting | No | No multivariate analysis conducted. |