Skip to main content
. 2021 May 5;2021(5):CD013540. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013540.pub2

Kashyap 2014.

Study characteristics
Methods Design: retrospective cohort
Setting: community
Country: Canada
Duration of follow‐up: 1 year
Covariates controlled for: None.
Participants Participants numbers: 102
Population type: older adults
Sex: 84% women (86)
Age (mean): 72 years
Prognostic factors Anticholinergic burden measurement method: DBI‐ach scale; ACB scale; ADS scale; ARS scale
Outcomes Outcomes assessed: MCI; cognitive decline
Outcome ascertainment MCI: independent clinical assessment via expert
Outcome ascertainment cognitive decline: neuropsychological tests and an MoCA
Diagnostic criteria MCI: DSM‐5 criteria for a mild neurocognitive disorder.
Diagnostic criteria cognitive decline: 3 different ways: worsening in the raw neuropsychological test scores for each test; a change in scores on each test that exceeded an expected cut‐off based on the test–retest reliable change index; and a change in scores on each test that persisted when regression to the mean, practice effects, and age were accounted for using the standardised regression‐based measure method
Source of funding Canadian Institutes of Health Research
Notes  
 
Item Authors' judgement Support for judgement
Study participation Unclear Report on age and sex but did not report which comorbidities they measured.
Study attrition Unclear No comparison with missing data. Did not describe the proportion or potential impact of loss to follow‐up.
Prognostic factor measurement Yes Established by patient self‐report. Validated by nurse checking medication box. Recorded frequency, adherence, and dosage.
Outcome measurement Unclear There was blinding to the mild neurocognitive disorder diagnosis but not to the change in cognition evaluation; retrospective anticholinergic burden determination.
Study confounding No Only conducted univariate analysis. No confounders adjusted for.
Reverse causation No No time restriction on anticholinergic burden measurement (anticholinergic burden measured at baseline then again at 12 months – combined measures and used 'increase in anticholinergic burden' as the independent variable.
Statistical analysis and reporting No No multivariate analysis conducted.