Skip to main content
. 2021 May 5;2021(5):CD013540. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013540.pub2

Low 2009.

Study characteristics
Methods Design: retrospective cohort
Setting: community
Country: Australia
Duration of follow‐up: 4 years
Covariates controlled for: age, gender, education, depression, and self‐rated health
Participants Participants numbers: 2058
Population type: 'young old'
Sex: 48% women (992)
Age (mean): 62 years
Prognostic factors Anticholinergic burden measurement method: ADS scale
Outcomes Outcomes assessed: cognitive decline; MCI
Outcome ascertainment MCI: independent clinical assessment via expert
Outcome ascertainment cognitive decline: a neuropsychological assessment
Diagnostic criteria MCI: Jack 1999 criteria
Diagnostic criteria cognitive decline: scores on cognitive testing
Source of funding National Health and Medical Research Council grants
Notes  
 
Item Authors' judgement Support for judgement
Study participation Unclear Sample was restricted to 'young old' (aged 60–64 years) and had high mean education (14 years).
Study attrition Unclear 87% of participants followed up. Comparison of lost to follow‐up vs followed up participants conducted but showed people lost to follow‐up were more likely to be on anticholinergic medicine.
Prognostic factor measurement Unclear Anticholinergic drug use reported at baseline and 4‐year follow‐up.
Used self‐reported medication use but only 1 method employed. No measurement of frequency, duration, or dose.
Outcome measurement No No blinding to anticholinergic burden during clinical diagnosis, but anticholinergic burden likely measured retrospectively. MCI was defined according to dated criteria (Jack 1999 rather than Peterson). MMSE used to assess cognition but study had high education mean and displays a ceiling effect.
Study confounding Unclear Controlled for age, sex, and comorbidities that cover both physical and psychiatric domains. However, minimal comorbidities.
Reverse causation No Excluded people with dementia at baseline but did not seem to be any formal restriction in anticholinergic drug use and time of outcome assessment at 4 years.
Statistical analysis and reporting No No protocol and no assumptions checked. Also analysis for MCI outcome was underpowered as only 38 MCI cases at follow‐up.