Table 2.
Study, year [ref.] | Overall survival | Efficacy (based on CT) | Adverse effect (bleeding/pneumothorax/radiation lung injury) |
---|---|---|---|
Jiakai Li, 2013 [11] | 1-y: 95.8% 2-y: 78% 3-y: 55% Median survival time: 38 months (8-46) |
At the end of follow-up period: CR: 8 PR: 10 SD: 4 PD: 6 |
4/3/0 |
Bin Huo, 2017 [12] | 1-y: 100% 2-y: 91.7% 3-y: 72.9% |
y LC: 100% y LC: 95.2% y LC: 95.2% |
8/10/2 |
Jingkui Yang, 2014 [13] | 1-y: 95.8% 2-y: 81.3% 5-y: 56.3% |
1-y LC: 85% (based on PET-CT) |
8/12/0 |
Mingyao Ke, 2011 [14] | 1-y: 60% 2-y: 54% 3-y: 50% 4-y: 33% |
1-y LC: 69% 2-y LC: 58% 3-y LC: 36% 4-y LC: 11% |
1/4/1 |
Jingkui Yang, 2014 [20] | 1-y: 94.4% 2-y: 72.7% 3-y: 66.7% 5-y: 55.6% |
6 months after implantation: CR: 7, PR: 9, SD: 2, PD: 0 | 3/6/0 |
Hua Cheng, 2019 [21] | 1-y: 96.1% 2-y: 80.7% 3-y: 69.2% |
6 months after implantation: CR: 10, PR: 12, SD: 4, PD: 0 1-y LC: 84.6% |
4/3/0 |
Wei Fu, 2019 [22] | T: 1-y: 100% 2-y: 92% C: 1-y: 91.67% 2-y: 66.67% |
T: short-term efficacy: CR: 4, PR: 12, SD: 9, PD: 0 y LC: 100%, 2-y LC: 92% C: short-term efficacy: CR: 2, PR: 12, SD: 10, PD: 0 y LC: 95.83%, 2-y LC: 62.50% |
1/2/0 |
Jianguo Yang, 2018 [23] | N.A. | T: short-term efficacy: CR: 10, PR: 17, SD: 2, PD: 5 C: short-term efficacy: CR: 8, PR: 10, SD: 2, PD: 13 |
1/2/0 |
Xianghua Lin, 2016 [24] | N.A. | T: 6 months after implantation: CR: 4, PR: 14, SD: 2, PD: 0 C: 6 months after implantation: CR: 1, PR: 10, SD: 4, PD: 4 |
4/3/0 |
T – treatment group, C – control group, CR – complete response, PR – partial response, SD – stable disease, PD – progressive disease, LC – local control, y – year, N.A. – not available