Table 1.
Overview of the main clinical studies considering the corticosteroid therapy in patients with SARS-COV-2 infection
Study | Saple size and COVID-19 severity | Corticosteroid regimen | Primary endpoint of efficacy/effect | Effect on viral clearance | Effect on mortality | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Coral et al | [40] | 85, severe COVID pneumonia | Methylprednisolone 40 mg twice daily for 3 days followed by 20 mg twice daily for 3 days | The need for ICU, noninvasive ventilation-reduced | Not considered | risk ratio in intention to treat analysis 0.55 and 0.61 in those patients over 75 years of age |
Fadel et al | [41] | 213 severe non critically ill COVID-19 pneumonia | Methylprednisolone 0.5–1 mg/kg/daily for 3 days | Care escalation (progression to critically ill, need for mechanical ventilation, mortality)-reduced | Not considered | Reduced mortality rates 26.3% with standard of care versus 13.6% in corticosteroid group |
The Writing Committee for the REMAP-CAP Investigators |
[42] | 137,146,101 | Hydrocortisone 50 or 100 mg every 6 day for 7 days, hydrocortisone 50 mg every 6 hours (for confirmed shock), no corticosteroid | Number of organ support free days in the ICU over the first 21 days | In favor of corticosteroids, trial early terminated |
Mortality rates respectively 30%, 26%, and 33% for each of the three regimens |
Recovery Collaborative Group |
[45] | 6452(2104 in dexamethasone group) various severities (COVID-19 requiring hospitalization | Dexamethasone 6 mg/daily up to 10 days | Mortality rate within the first 28 days from randomization-reduced | Not considered | Mortality rate 25.7% in control group and 22.9 with dexamethasone P < 0.001 |
Li Q et al | [50] | 475 non-severe COVID 19 | Methylprednisolone 20–40 mg/daily for a maximum of 5 days | Progression to severe disease or death – more likely if corticosteroids were used | Significantly prolonged (18 versus 11 days) | 1.8% in corticosteroid group, 0% in no corticosteroid group, p = 0.3 |
Xu et al | [51] | 113 non-severe COVID 19 | Corticosteroids, various regimens | Not designed to measure efficacy | Significantly prolonged in patients under corticosteroids |
|
Li TZ et al | [52] | 101 various severitied hospitalized COVID-19 | Corticosteroids, various regimens | Not designed to measure efficacy | Significantly prolonged in patients under corticosteroids (OR = 6.3) | Overall 3,3 (0 for those with viral shedding lasting less than 11 days, respectively 6.5% for those with a viral shedding lasting more than 11 days |
Tomazzini et al | [46] | 299 moderate to severe SARS-COV2(151 in dexamethasone arm, 148 in control arm | Dexametasone intravenous 20 mg/daily for 5 days followed by 10 mg the following 5 days or up to ICU discharge | Number of ventilator free days at 28 day from admission-increased | Not considered | All cause mortality rate at 8 days was 56.3% in the dexamethasone group and 61.5% in the control group (p = 0.8) |
Salton et al | [53] | 173 severe COVID-19 pneumonia | Methylprednisolone- loading dose of 80 mg intravenous bolus, followed by daily infused identical doses at least 8 days, could be further prolonged based on severity | Care escalation due to disease progression (ICU, mechanical ventilation) or death-significantly reduced | Not considered | Mortality rates 7.2% in corticosteroid group compared to 23.3% in the standard of care group, (p = 0.005) |