Table 2. Stability of reference gene expression under different experimental conditions calculated by four different analytical tools.
Experimental conditions | Reference genes | ΔCt | Bestkeeper | NormFinder | geNorm | Recommendation | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Stability | Rank | Stability | Rank | Stability | Rank | Stability | Rank | |||
Development stage | Actin1 | 0.628 | 3 | 0.337 | 2 | 0.259 | 4 | 0.528 | 5 | TBP |
Actin2 | 0.706 | 6 | 0.343 | 3 | 0.364 | 6 | 0.554 | 6 | ||
EF-1α | 0.641 | 4 | 0.230 | 1 | 0.306 | 5 | 0.420 | 3 | ||
GAPDH | 0.970 | 8 | 0.845 | 8 | 0.608 | 8 | 0.700 | 8 | ||
α-TUB | 0.837 | 7 | 0.469 | 6 | 0.511 | 7 | 0.611 | 7 | RPL19 | |
RPL19 | 0.588 | 2 | 0.408 | 4 | 0.188 | 1 | 0.336 | 1 | ||
RPL32 | 0.647 | 5 | 0.536 | 7 | 0.257 | 3 | 0.498 | 4 | ||
TBP | 0.585 | 1 | 0.432 | 5 | 0.191 | 2 | 0.336 | 1 | ||
Tissue | Actin1 | 1.157 | 7 | 0.567 | 5 | 0.744 | 7 | 0.694 | 5 | EF-1α |
Actin2 | 1.134 | 6 | 0.456 | 4 | 0.723 | 6 | 0.860 | 6 | ||
EF-1α | 0.782 | 1 | 0.405 | 3 | 0.197 | 1 | 0.180 | 1 | ||
GAPDH | 1.204 | 8 | 1.091 | 8 | 0.795 | 8 | 1.006 | 8 | ||
α-TUB | 1.023 | 5 | 0.889 | 7 | 0.596 | 5 | 0.942 | 7 | RPL32 | |
RPL19 | 0.930 | 3 | 0.091 | 1 | 0.348 | 3 | 0.600 | 4 | ||
RPL32 | 0.863 | 2 | 0.356 | 2 | 0.260 | 2 | 0.458 | 3 | ||
TBP | 0.969 | 4 | 0.829 | 6 | 0.496 | 4 | 0.180 | 1 | ||
Temperature | Actin1 | 0.904 | 6 | 0.983 | 6 | 0.450 | 6 | 0.603 | 5 | RPL32 |
Actin2 | 0.882 | 4 | 0.988 | 7 | 0.424 | 5 | 0.576 | 4 | ||
EF-1α | 0.896 | 5 | 0.611 | 3 | 0.411 | 4 | 0.661 | 6 | ||
GAPDH | 1.398 | 8 | 1.575 | 8 | 0.894 | 8 | 0.922 | 8 | TBP | |
α-TUB | 0.795 | 3 | 0.664 | 5 | 0.303 | 3 | 0.464 | 3 | ||
RPL19 | 1.084 | 7 | 0.288 | 1 | 0.647 | 7 | 0.763 | 7 | ||
RPL32 | 0.692 | 1 | 0.601 | 2 | 0.022 | 1 | 0.354 | 1 | ||
TBP | 0.722 | 2 | 0.655 | 4 | 0.137 | 2 | 0.354 | 1 | ||
Insecticide | Actin1 | 1.479 | 8 | 1.177 | 7 | 0.939 | 8 | 1.034 | 8 | RPL19 |
Actin2 | 0.996 | 5 | 0.812 | 6 | 0.445 | 4 | 0.767 | 6 | ||
EF-1α | 0.990 | 4 | 0.362 | 2 | 0.532 | 6 | 0.394 | 1 | ||
GAPDH | 1.154 | 7 | 1.181 | 8 | 0.615 | 7 | 0.886 | 7 | ||
α-TUB | 0.885 | 3 | 0.691 | 5 | 0.314 | 2 | 0.700 | 5 | RPL32 | |
RPL19 | 0.876 | 1 | 0.482 | 3 | 0.359 | 3 | 0.394 | 1 | ||
RPL32 | 0.884 | 2 | 0.535 | 4 | 0.281 | 1 | 0.655 | 4 | ||
TBP | 1.009 | 6 | 0.331 | 1 | 0.510 | 5 | 0.591 | 3 |