TABLE I.
Comparison of “conventional” methods for mechanobiology. Viscoelastic property signifies the quantity typically extracted from experiments although other rheological functions can also be calculated. Force range for all techniques except FRET probes shows the force that the probe is capable of exerting but for FRET is the measurement range. Dynamic time scale indicates the typical time scale of the relaxation process that is probed.
Technique | Main viscoelastic property | Force range | Dynamic time scale | Linear dimension of the probed region | Meas. through-put (cell/h) | Reference |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
AFM | Young modulus Y = E(ω → 0) | 10 pN–10 μN | ms–s | 10 nm–5 μm | 5–10 | 2 and 96 |
Parallel plate rheology | Elastic modulus E(ω) | 10 pN–10 μN | ms–s | Whole cell | 5–10 | 2 |
Rotating plate rheology | Shear modulus G(ω) | Limited by the adhesive properties of cells | ms–s | Whole cell | <106 (5–6 h needed to prepare cells) | 2 and 97 |
Micropipete aspiration | Stretch modulus of envelope, strength of cell-to-cell and cell-to-substrate attachments | 0.1 nN–1 μN | ms–min | >1 μm | 5–10 | 20 |
Magnetic tweezers | Shear modulus G(ω) | 0.1–100 pN | ms–min | 1–10 μm | 1000 | 2, 21, 98 and 99 |
Particle tracking rheology | Diffusion coefficient →G(ω) | N/A | ms–h | 0.01–1 μm | 10–100 | 2 and 22 |
FRET probes | Force, stress | 1–100 pN | ms–min | 1 nm to whole cell | 10–100 | 24 |
Brillouin scattering | Spatial distribution of longitudinal modulus M(x, y) | N/A | ns | >250 nm | 10–100 | 25 and 26 |
Optical stretchers | Creep function J(t) | <100 pN | ms–s | Whole cell | 100 | 2 and 27 |
Laser ablation | Creep function J(t) | N/A | ms–s | >250 nm | 5–10 | 29 |