Study | Reason for exclusion |
---|---|
An 2009 | No outcomes of interest |
An 2012 | Diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Arentz 2014 | Review |
Arentz 2017a | PCOS with and without infertility |
Arentz 2017b | This is conference data and duplicates the published article |
Bablis 2006 | Case report |
Bai 2011 | Non‐randomised controlled trial (RCT) |
Bao 2009 | No outcomes of interest; polycystic ovarian syndrome (PCOS) with or without infertility in this study |
Bao 2014 | No Chinese herbal medicine (CHM) intervention |
Bei 2010 | Non‐RCT, which the primary study authors confirmed |
Cai 2006 | Adolescent PCOS without infertility; no outcomes of interest |
Cai 2011 | Quasi‐RCT, which the primary study authors confirmed |
Cai 2012 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Cai 2014 | Not a RCT |
Cao 2010 | Non‐RCT, which the primary study authors confirmed |
Cao 2012 | Non‐RCT, which the primary study authors confirmed |
Chan CC 2006 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Chan LY 2006 | Non‐CHM intervention |
Chen 2005 | PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Chen 2007 | Intervention with acupuncture but without herbal medicine |
Chen 2008 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Chen 2009 | Intervention with acupuncture but without herbal medicine |
Chen 2013 | Non‐PCOS participants |
Chen 2015 | Participants had no wish to conceive |
Chen 2016 | Non‐CHM intervention |
Chen 2017 | Quasi‐RCT |
Cheng 2009 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Cheng 2014 | Non‐CHM intervention |
Cheng 2015 | Participants had no wish to conceive |
Chen H 2010 | No outcomes of interest |
Chen JL 2006 | PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Chen JX 2017 | Diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Chen L 2006 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria; quasi‐RCT |
Chen LS 2012 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria; quasi‐RCT |
Chen N 2012 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Chen PL 2011 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Chen QZ 2014 | Quasi‐RCT |
Chen R 2014 | Non‐CHM intervention |
Chen RJ 2012 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Chen RR 2011 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Chen WY 2012 | Quasi‐RCT |
Chen XF 2011 | Quasi‐RCT |
Chen XF 2017 | Diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Chen XH 2010 | No outcomes of interest |
Chen Y 2014 | Not a RCT |
ChiCTR1800016219 | no interventions of interest |
ChiCTR1800016792 | no interventions of interest |
ChiCTR1800018597 | No outcomes of interest |
ChiCTR‐IOR‐16008557 | PCOS with and without infertility; PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
ChiCTR‐IOR‐16008557 a | Duplicate with ChiCTR‐IOR‐16008557, and PCOS with and without infertility; PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
ChiCTR‐IPR‐16009166 | PCOS with and without infertility |
Chou 2018 | Quasi‐RCT |
Chu 2013 | Non‐PCOS participants |
Craig 2015 | Non‐CHM intervention |
Cui 2012 | PCOS with or without infertility; no outcomes of interest |
Cui 2017 | Non‐CHM intervention |
Dang 2012 | Non‐RCT, which the primary authors confirmed |
Deng 2008 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria; quasi‐RCT |
Deng 2016 | Quasi‐RCT |
Deng 2018 | Diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Deveci 2015 | Non‐CHM intervention |
Ding 2015 | Unrelated study |
Dong 2009 | No outcomes of interest |
Dong 2010 | No outcomes of interest |
Du 2012 | PCOS with or without infertility; no outcomes of interest |
Du 2013 | Participants had no wish to conceive |
Fan 2017 | No outcomes of interest |
Fang 2004 | No outcomes of interest |
Feng 2009a | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Feng 2009b | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Feng J 2011 | Quasi‐RCT |
Feng X 2011 | Non‐RCT confirmed by primary authors |
Fu 2012 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria; PCOS with or without infertility in this study; no outcomes of interest |
Fu BJ 2019 | No outcomes of interest |
Fu JR 2019 | Diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Gao 2009 | Intervention with acupuncture but without herbal medicine |
Gao XL 2011 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria; quasi‐RCT |
Gao YH 2011 | PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Ghavi 2015 | With or without subfertility |
Gong 2012 | PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Grant 2010 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Gu 2015 | Participants had no wish to conceive |
Guo 2008 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Guo 2009 | PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Guo AP 2011 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria; quasi‐RCT |
Guo SX 2011 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Haidari 2020 | PCOS with and without infertility; participants had no wish to conceive; no outcomes of interest |
Haj‐Husein 2016 | Women with or without subfertility |
Han 2008 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria; quasi‐RCT |
Han 2011 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria; quasi‐RCT |
Han 2015 | Not a RCT |
Han M 2013 | Participants had no wish to conceive |
Han SX 2013 | Not a RCT |
Hao 2012 | Quasi‐RCT, which the primary authors confirmed |
Harman 2001 | Non‐PCOS |
Hassanzadeh Bashtian 2013 | Participants had no wish to conceive |
He 2009 | PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
He 2010 | Quasi‐RCT |
He 2014 | Quasi‐RCT |
Heshmati 2020 | PCOS with and without infertility; participants had no wish to conceive; no outcomes of interest |
Hou 2000 | No outcomes of interest |
Hu 2009a | Intervention with acupuncture but without herbal medicine; PCOS with and without infertility |
Hu 2009b | Intervention with acupuncture but without herbal medicine |
Hu 2014 | Participants had no wish to conceive |
Hua 2003 | Case control study |
Huang 2004 | Quasi‐RCT confirmed by primary authors |
Huang 2007 | PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Huang 2008 | Review |
Huang 2010 | Quasi‐RCT |
Huang DL 2011 | No outcomes of interest |
Huang L 2012 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Huang LH 2011 | No outcomes of interest |
Huang LY 2006 | Non‐RCT confirmed by primary authors |
Huang XT 2012 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Huang YL 2019 | Diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Huang YY 2006 | PCOS without infertility; quasi‐RCT; no outcomes of interest |
Huang YZ 2019 | Quasi‐RCT |
Hung 2016 | Cohort study |
Huo 2008 | Unrelated |
IRCT2017082016911N4 | No outcomes of interest |
Jalilian 2013 | Non‐CHM intervention |
Jamilian 2020 | PCOS with and without infertility; participants had no wish to conceive; no outcomes of interest |
Jia, 2019 | Quasi‐RCT; PCOS with and without infertility |
Jia 2004 | Diagnosis inconsistent with Rotterdam; quasi‐RCT |
Jia 2008 | Concurrent control study |
Jia 2010 | PCOS with or without infertility; PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Jia CM 2012 | No outcomes of interest |
Jian 2011 | No outcomes of interest |
Jiang 2007 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria; quasi‐RCT |
Jiang 2014 | Non‐PCOS participants |
Jiang 2015 | Non‐CHM intervention |
Jiang JH 2011 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Jiang MF 2011 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Jia WH 2012 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria; quasi‐RCT; no outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Jin 2017 | Quasi‐RCT |
Jin CL 2014 | Non‐CHM intervention |
Jing 2017 | No outcomes of interest |
Jin JH 2016 | Participants had no wish to conceive |
Jin XT 2014 | Quasi‐RCT |
Johnson 2015 | Non‐CHM intervention |
Kang 2012 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Kawakami 2011 | Unrelated |
Kitagawa 2015 | Non‐PCOS participants |
Kort 2014 | With or without subfertility |
Kuang 2012 | Quasi‐RCT, which the primary authors confirmed |
Kuang 2013 | Non‐CHM intervention |
Kuang 2015 | Non‐CHM intervention |
Kuek 2011 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Lai 2006 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility; PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Lai 2011 | Quasi‐RCT |
Lai 2014a | Participants had no wish to conceive |
Lai 2014b | Participants had no wish to conceive |
Lai 2014c | Participants had no wish to conceive |
Lai 2015a | Review |
Lai 2015b | Participants had no wish to conceive |
Lai 2015c | Participants had no wish to conceive |
Lai 2015d | Participants had no wish to conceive |
Lai 2017 | Participants had no wish to conceive |
León‐Gonzalez 2014 | Unrelated |
Li 2000 | PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Li 2002 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Li 2005 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria; quasi‐RCT |
Li 2009 | Duplication |
Li 2011a | Participants had no wish to conceive |
Li 2011b | PCOS with or without infertility; no outcomes of interest |
Li 2015 | Non‐CHM intervention |
Li 2018a | Diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Li 2018b | PCOS with and without infertility |
Li 2019a | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Li 2019b | Quasi‐RCT; patients with and without infertility |
Lian 2008 | Quasi‐RCT |
Lian 2012 | Quasi‐RCT |
Liang 2011 | Quasi‐RCT |
Liang 2017 | Diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Liang 2019 | PCOS with and without infertility;Participants had no wish to conceive;No outcomes of interest |
Liang HY 2018 | Quasi‐RCT |
Liang XQ 2018 | Diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Liao 2014 | Non‐CHM intervention |
Li B 2010 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility; PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Li C 2011 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility; PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Li FY 2010 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Li FY 2011 | PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Li HC 2011 | No outcomes of interest |
Li HX 2011 | No outcomes of interest |
Li HX 2012 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Li J 2012 | No outcomes of interest |
Li JY 2017 | No outcomes of interest |
Li K 2017 | Non‐CHM intervention |
Li L 2009 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Lim 2011 | Review |
Li M 2016 | With and without PCOS |
Lin 2005 | Non‐RCT, which the primary authors confirmed |
Lin 2011 | We were unable to contact the study authors for the detailed information about the laparoscopic surgery method |
Li N 2013 | Non‐CHM intervention |
Lin 2017 | PCOS with and without infertility |
Lin 2017a | PCOS with and without infertility;No outcomes of interest |
Lin BQ 2013 | Participants had no wish to conceive |
Lin H 2013 | Participants had no wish to conceive |
Lin HM 2009 | Non‐RCT, which was confirmed by the author |
Lin HM 2013 | Participants had no wish to conceive |
Lin Y 2009 | Quasi‐RCT |
Li Q 2016 | Participants had no wish to conceive |
Li SP 2011 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Li SZ 2010 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Liu 2007 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria; quasi‐RCT |
Liu 2008 | Unrelated |
Liu 2009 | Diagnosis inconsistent with Rotterdam; quasi‐RCT |
Liu 2017 | No outcomes of interest |
Liu 2018 | Diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria;PCOS with and without infertility |
Liu B 2017 | Quasi‐RCT |
Liu CN 2017 | PCOS with and without infertility |
Liu DP 2011 | Quasi‐RCT |
Liu GY 2010 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Liu HL 2011 | Quasi‐RCT; no outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Liu HX 2016 | Quasi‐RCT |
Liu JJ 2016 | Quasi‐RCT |
Liu Q 2014 | Participants had no wish to conceive |
Liu RX 2010 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Liu XL 2014 | Participants had no wish to conceive |
Liu XX 2010 | Non‐RCT, which the primary study authors confirmed |
Liu XX 2012 | No outcomes of interest |
Liu Y 2013 | Quasi‐RCT |
Liu YH 2010 | Quasi‐RCT |
Liu YP 2012 | No outcomes of interest |
Liu YQ 2012 | No outcomes of interest |
Li XB 2011 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Li XH 2011 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Li XL 2009 | PCOS without infertility |
Li XP 2011 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Li XW 2009 | No outcomes of interest |
Li XY 2017 | Quasi‐RCT |
Li Y 2013 | Participants had no wish to conceive; protocol |
Li YL 2011 | No outcomes of interest |
Li ZZ 2010 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Lu 2010 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Lu 2012 | Diagnosis inconsistent with Rotterdam; quasi‐RCT |
Lu 2018 | Diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Luo, 2019 | Quasi‐RCT |
Luo 2010 | No outcomes of interest |
Luo 2014 | Not a RCT |
Luo 2018 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Luo 2019 | PCOS with and without infertility ;No outcomes of interest |
Lv 2007 | Intervention with acupuncture but without herbal medicine |
Lv 2009 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Lv 2010 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Ma 2009 | Quasi‐RCT |
Ma 2010 | No outcomes of interest |
Ma 2017 | Diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Ma 2018 | Quasi‐RCT |
Madder 2013 | Review |
Mao 2003 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria; quasi‐RCT |
Mao XG 2011 | No outcomes of interest |
Mao XH 2011 | Non‐RCT, which the primary authors confirmed |
Mei 2010 | PCOS with or without infertility |
Men 2017 | All interventions were CHM, while no this review intrested intervention |
Meng 2011 | No outcomes of interest; part of the study was about animals |
Miao 2012 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria; quasi‐RCT; PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Ming‐Wei 2011 | Non‐PCOS participants |
Mohammad Hosseinzadeh 2016 | Non‐CHM intervention |
Moradan 2012 | Review |
Mosalanejad 2015 | Not a RCT |
Motoo 2014 | SR |
Musumeci 2006 | Review |
Naeimi 2020 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
NCT01116167 | this protocol has completed and duplicated with the published article |
NCT03264638 | this protocol has completed and duplicated with the published article; PCOS with and without infertility |
Nie 2018 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
O'Brien 2010 | Unrelated |
Pan 2010 | No outcomes of interest |
Pan 2012 | No outcomes of interest |
Pastore 2011 | Non‐CHM intervention |
Pazyar 2012 | Unrelated study |
Pei 2012 | PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Peng 2012 | No outcomes of interest |
Qiao 2012 | Quasi‐RCT |
Qin 2016 | PCOS with and without infertility |
Qiu 2006 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Qu 2015 | Unrelated |
Qv 2011 | PCOS with or without infertility |
Ran 2008 | Case control study |
Ran MX 2007 | No outcomes of interest |
Ran XM 2007 | Case control study |
Rao 2012 | No PCOS |
Rashidi 2013 | Non CHM intervention |
Ren, 2019 | Quasi‐RCT |
Ren 2002a | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria; quasi‐RCT |
Ren 2002b | Duplication |
Ren 2006 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Ren 2008 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Ren 2011 | PCOS with or without infertility |
Ren 2013 | No PCOS |
Ren 2014 | SR |
Ren 2019 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Ried 2015 | SR |
Ruan 2016 | Quasi‐RCT |
Sadrefozalayi 2014 | Animals |
Salah 2013 | Non‐CHM intervention |
See 2011 | SR |
Shah 2016 | Non‐CHM intervention |
Shao 2004 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Shao 2006 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Shen 2008 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Shen 2013 | Participants were not subfertile |
Sheng 2010 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Sheng 2018 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Shi 2009a | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Shi 2009b | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Shi 2011 | PCOS with or without infertility; PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Shi 2016 | Quasi‐RCT |
Shi 2017 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Shi F 2010 | No outcomes of interest |
Shi LJ 2010 | PCOS with or without infertility |
Shu 2012 | No outcomes of interest |
Si 2016 | Participants had no wish to conceive |
Sohaei 2019 | PCOS with and without infertility;Participants had no wish to conceive; No outcomes of interest |
Song 2010 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Song 2011 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria; no outcomes of interest |
Stone 2009 | Case report |
Su 2012 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Sui 2011 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria; no outcomes of interest |
Sun 2011 | PCOS with or without infertility |
Sun 2012 | PCOS with or without infertility; quasi‐RCT |
Sun 2014 | No CHM intervention |
Sun C 2010 | PCOS with or without infertility |
Sun FX 2016 | Diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Sun J 2009 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria; quasi‐RCT |
Sun L 2016 | Diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Sun W 2010 | Intervention with acupuncture but without herbal medicine |
Sun Y 2009 | No outcomes of interest |
Talaat 2018 | PCOS with and without infertility; No outcomes of interest |
Tan 2005 | Diagnosis inconsistent with Rotterdam; quasi‐RCT |
Tan 2012 | SR |
Tang 2012 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Tao 2003 | Diagnosis inconsistent with Rotterdam; PCOS with or without infertility |
Tao 2006 | Concurrent control study |
Tao 2008 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Tao 2009 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Tao 2010 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Tao 2011 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Tao 2017 | Diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Tian 2017 | PCOS with and without infertility |
Tong 2017 | Quasi‐RCT |
Ulbricht 2016 | SR |
Ushiroyama 2001 | Diagnosis inconsistent with Rotterdam, participants including PCOS and non‐PCOS |
Ushiroyama 2006 | Diagnosis inconsistent with Rotterdam |
Vajda 2013 | Not a RCT |
van Oppen 2015 | Non‐PCOS |
Wan 2012 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Wang 2006a | PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Wang 2006b | Quasi‐RCT |
Wang 2011a | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Wang 2011b | No outcomes of interest |
Wang 2013 | No CHM intervention |
Wang 2017 | Conference paper; No CHM intervention |
Wang 2019 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria;PCOS with and without infertility |
Wang CX 2016 | Diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Wang JL 2009 | Intervention with acupuncture but without herbal medicine |
Wang LL 2016 | No CHM intervention |
Wang NS 2011 | PCOS with or without infertility |
Wang Q 2010 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Wang Q 2011 | Quasi‐RCT |
Wang Q 2012 | PCOS with or without infertility |
Wang QH 2012 | PCOS with or without infertility; quasi‐RCT |
Wang YH 2005 | Before‐and‐after study |
Wang YH 2010 | PCOS with or without infertility; quasi‐RCT |
Wang YL 2005 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria; quasi‐RCT |
Wei 2008 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Wei 2018 | Quasi‐RCT |
Wei CL 2011 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Wei XX 2011 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria; PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Wei YQ 2011 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility; diagnosis inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Wong 2017 | PCOS with and without infertility |
Wu 2008 | PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Wu 2011 | PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Wu 2016 | No CHM, berberine is a purified chemical |
Wu 2017 | Quasi‐RCT |
Wu 2019 | PCOS with and without infertility |
Wu CC 2012 | Non‐CHM intervention |
Wu D 2012 | PCOS with or without infertility; no outcomes of interest |
Wu MY 2010 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Wuttke 2015 | Non‐PCOS participants |
Wu XY 2010 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Wu Y 2013 | Non‐PCOS participants |
Wu YY 2013 | No CHM intervention |
Xia 2004 | No outcomes of interest |
Xia 2007 | Quasi‐RCT |
Xia 2011 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Xiao 2014 | No CHM intervention |
Xie 2005 | Diagnosis inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Xie 2010 | PCOS with or without infertility |
Xie 2012 | PCOS with or without infertility |
Xin, 2019 | Quasi‐RCT |
Xiong 2012 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Xiong 2018 | Quasi‐RCT |
Xu, 2019 | Diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Xu 2009 | PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Xu 2012 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Xu 2018 | Quasi‐RCT |
Xu 2019 | Diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Xu BH 2016 | Participants had no wish to conceive |
Xu DW 2010 | No outcomes of interest |
Xue 2004 | Diagnosis inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria; quasi‐RCT |
Xu HO 2008 | Diagnosis inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria; quasi‐RCT |
Xu JH 2008 | PCOS with or without infertility |
Xu QZ 2016 | PCOS with and without infertility |
Xu RQ 2017 | PCOS with and without infertility |
Xu SQ 2010 | PCOS with or without infertility |
Xu ZZ 2017 | No outcomes of interest |
Yan 2003 | Duplication |
Yan 2005 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Yan 2012 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria; quasi‐RCT |
Yang 2005 | Intervention with acupuncture but without herbal medicine |
Yang 2008 | Animal study |
Yang 2011 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria; PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Yang 2015 | No CHM intervention |
Yang 2017a | No outcomes of interest |
Yang 2017b | This dissertation was duplicated with the published article |
Yang D 2014 | No CHM intervention |
Yang GM 2010 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Yang H 2014 | Participants had no wish to conceive |
Yang JB 2010 | No outcomes of interest; quasi‐RCT |
Yang LF 2017 | Diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Yang P 2010 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria; no outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Yang Y 2016 | PCOS with and without infertility |
Yang YQ 2016 | Diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Yao 2011 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Yao XY 2012 | Quasi‐RCT; no outcomes of interest |
Yao Y 2012 | PCOS with or without infertility |
Ye 2004 | PCOS with or without infertility; diagnosis inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Ye 2010 | PCOS with or without infertility; no outcomes of interest |
Ye 2015 | Participants had no wish to conceive |
Ye 2017 | No outcomes of interest |
Ye 2018 | PCOS with and without infertility;No outcomes of interest |
Ye HJ 2012 | No outcomes of interest |
Ye YY 2012 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria; no outcomes of interest; quasi‐RCT |
Yi 2012 | PCOS with or without infertility |
Yi 2017 | Diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria;PCOS with and without infertility |
Yin 2007 | Laparoscopic ovary wedgeshaped resection was used in this study |
Ying L 2016 | PCOS with and without infertility |
Ying Z 2016 | Participants had no wish to conceive |
Yu 2013 | With or without subfertility |
Yu 2015 | Participants had no wish to conceive |
Yu 2018 | No outcomes of interest |
Yu 2019 | Diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria;patients with and without infertility |
Yuan 2011 | No outcomes of interest |
Yuan 2016 | Quasi‐RCT |
Yuan 2018 | No outcomes of interest |
Yv 2011 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Zeng 2007 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria; quasi‐RCT |
Zeng 2012 | No interventions of interest |
Zhang 2007a | Duplication |
Zhang 2009 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Zhang 2011a | Not a RCT |
Zhang 2011b | No outcomes of interest |
Zhang 2015a | With or without subfertility |
Zhang 2015b | Participants had no wish to conceive |
Zhang 2015c | Animals |
Zhang 2016 | Diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Zhang 2019a | Diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Zhang 2019b | Diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria;patients with and without infertility |
Zhang FC 2007 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Zhang H 2007b | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Zhang H 2010 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria; no outcomes of interest |
Zhang H 2014 | Participants had no wish to conceive |
Zhang HH 2011 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Zhang HM 2011 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Zhang J 2011 | Non‐RCT, which the primary authors confirmed |
Zhang JH 2018 | Quasi‐RCT |
Zhang JJ 2012 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Zhang JX 2015 | Participants had no wish to conceive |
Zhang L 2010 | No outcomes of interest |
Zhang LM 2003 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility;diagnosis inconsistent with Rotterdam;quasi‐RCT |
Zhang LX 2012 | PCOS with or without infertility; no outcomes of interest |
Zhang M 2010 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Zhang MM 2003 | Concurrent control study |
Zhang Q 2010 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Zhang SM 2018 | No outcomes of interest |
Zhang T 2010 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria; no outcomes of interest |
Zhang TH 2011 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Zhang TY 2012 | No outcomes of interest; quasi‐RCT |
Zhang XY 2014 | Participants had no wish to conceive |
Zhang Y 2007 | PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Zhang YH 2012 | PCOS with or without infertility; no outcomes of interest |
Zhao 2006a | Intervention without herbal medicine |
Zhao 2006b | Intervention without herbal medicine |
Zhao 2007 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Zhao 2009 | Concurrent control study; PCOS with or without infertility |
Zhao 2014 | No interventions of interest |
Zhao 2016 | Participants had no wish to conceive |
Zhao 2019 | Diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Zhao CP 2006 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Zhao H 2008 | Duplication |
Zhao HB 2008 | Quasi‐RCT |
Zhao J 2010 | No outcomes of interest |
Zhao XL 2010 | Non‐RCT confirmed by primary authors |
Zhao Y 2008 | Intervention without herbal medicine |
Zheng 2011 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Zheng 2011a | PCOS with or without infertility |
Zheng 2011b | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Zheng 2014a | Quasi‐RCT |
Zheng 2014b | Participants had no wish to conceive |
Zheng 2018 | Diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Zheng GJ 2011 | PCOS with or without infertility |
Zheng SJ 2015 | Quasi‐RCT |
Zheng XH 2015 | Participants had no wish to conceive |
Zhi 2012 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Zhong 2006 | PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Zhong 2008 | PCOS with or without infertility |
Zhong 2012 | Non‐RCT, which the primary study authors confirmed |
Zhong 2016 | Diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Zhong XC 2009 | PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Zhong XL2009 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility in this study |
Zhou 1996 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Zhou 2010a | PCOS with or without infertility |
Zhou 2010b | Non‐RCT, which the primary authors confirmed |
Zhou 2016 | Quasi‐RCT |
Zhou F 2015 | Quasi‐RCT |
Zhou FB 2014 | Quasi‐RCT |
Zhou JH 2012 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Zhou LL 2012 | No outcomes of interest |
Zhou M 2015 | Quasi‐RCT |
Zhou MS 2018 | No outcomes of interest |
Zhou WQ 2018 | PCOS with and without infertility |
Zhou XL 2012 | No outcomes of interest |
Zhou XY 2012 | PCOS with or without infertility |
Zhou YX 2014 | Quasi‐RCT |
Zhou Z 2014 | Quasi‐RCT |
Zhu 2009 | Concurrent control study |
Zhu 2014 | Quasi‐RCT |
Zhu 2019 | Diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Zhu 2020 | Diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Zhuang 2008 | PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Zhu JQ 2012 | PCOS with or without infertility; no outcomes of interest |
Zhu M 2012 | No outcomes of interest |
Zhu TC 2013 | Participants had no wish to conceive |
Zhu Y 2013 | Participants had no wish to conceive |
Zou 2012 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility; PCOS diagnosis is inconsistent with Rotterdam criteria |
Zou L 2014 | Participants had no wish to conceive |
Zou Y 2014 | Quasi‐RCT |
Zuo 2011 | No outcomes of interest; PCOS with or without infertility |
Abbreviations: RCT: randomised controlled trial, CHM: Chinese herbal medicine, PCOS: polycystic ovarian syndrome, SR: systematic review.