Table 2.
Different terminologies associated with phenotypic AMR.
Term | Original definition | Redefinition | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Meaning (year) | Meaning (year) | |||
Phenotypic resistance | Synonym for phenotypic AMR (1944) | (67) | ||
Bacterial persistence/persisters | Consequence of phenotypic AMR (1944) | (67) | Slow killing of a subpopulation of bacteria in a larger population that is killed rapidly (2019) | (6) |
Phenotypic tolerance | Synonym for phenotypic AMR (1986) | (72) | Genetically determined delay in onset of replication after transfer to a new culture medium (2014) | (64) |
Slower killing of an entire population for any reason (2019) | (6) | |||
Type 1 persistence | Persistence displayed by bacterial cells that remain nonreplicating after transfer from the stationary growth phase (2004) | (10) | Triggered persistence: Persistence in response to a stress stimulus (2019) | (6) |
Type 2 persistence | Persistence of a slow- growing subpopulation of bacteria whose slow growth is not attributable to having been in stationary growth phase (2004) | (10) | Spontaneous persistence (2019) | (6) |
Class 1 phenotypic tolerance | Phenotypic AMR of a minority of bacterial cells in a replicating population (2012) | (9) | ||
Class 2 phenotypic tolerance | Phenotypic AMR of most bacterial cells in a nonreplicating population (2012) | (9) | ||
Responsive diversification | Phenotypic AMR in response to a stress stimulus (2014) | (8) | ||
Stochastic switching | Phenotypic AMR manifest before a stress stimulus (2014) | (8) | ||
Tolerance due to slow growth | Slow killing due to slow growth resulting from genetic impairment or stress, including exposure to antibiotics (2016) | (11) | ||
Tolerance due to growth lag | Slow killing due to delayed onset of growth resulting from a change in culture conditions (2016) | (11) |