Skip to main content
. 2021 Jun 9;16(6):e0252651. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0252651

Table 1. Characteristics of included studies.

Study Study location Migrant workers Non-migrant workers Study period Occupation or industrial sector Type of study Number of participants or events Female Age (in years) Outcomes
Al-Thani 2015 [17] One site, Qatar Nationals of Bangladesh, Egypt, India, Nepal, Philippines and Sri Lanka Nationals of Qatar 4 years (2010–13) Labourers Cohort study 2,015 participants 0·02 32 (mean) Has died from an occupational injury, Has had any occupational injury (major injury only), measured with the Abbreviated Injury Score
Biering 2017 [18, 19] One site, Denmark Nationals of old EU, new EU and other countries Nationals of Denmark 11 years (2003–13) All workers Cohort study 63,601 participants 0·47 Unclear Has had any occupational injury, measured with physician or employer report
Byler 2018 [20] United States of America (USA) Workers born in Africa, Americas (other than the USA), Asia, Europe and other regions Workers born in the United States of America 8 years (2003–10) All workers Cohort study Unclear number of participants (39,048 observations) 0·08 16–67 (range) Has died from an occupational injury, measured with administrative records
Cha 2014 [21] Republic of Korea Nationals of Bangladesh, Egypt, India, Nepal, Philippines and Sri Lanka Nationals of the Republic of Korea 3 years (2005–07) All workers Cohort study 341,359 + 1,252,8879 participants 0·17 Any age (range) Has died from an occupational injury, Has had any occupational injury (non-fatal only)
Dias 2017 [22] Unclear number of sites, Portugal Nationals of countries in the Africa, Americas, and Europe (other than Portugal) Nationals of Portugal Sex workers Cross-sectional study 853 participants 1·0 35·9 (mean) Has used any health service; measured with self-reported lifetime use of HIV testing
Giraudo 2017 [23] Italy Nationals of countries in Africa, Asia (except Japan and Republic of Korea), Latin America, and Central and Eastern Europe Nationals of Italy 6 years (2000–05) Manufacturing, Construction, and Services (industrial sectors) Cohort study 397,986 workers with 6,629 events 0·00 16–55 (range) Has had any occupational injury (serious occupational injury resulting in four or more days of absence)
Goldenberg 2014 [24] Vancouver, Canada Born outside of Canada Born in Canada 3 years (2010–12) Sex workers Cross-sectional study 650 participants 1·00 34 (median) Has human immune virus, measured with laboratory tests
Ismayilova 2014 [25] Almaty, Kazakhstan Nationals of Azerbaijan, China, Kyrgyzstan, Russia, Tajikistan, Turkey and Uzbekistan Nationals of Khazakhstan (internal migrants only) 4 months (2007) Market workers Cross-sectional study 450 participants 0·50 27·7 (mean) Has had clinical depression in last week, measured with the Depression Subscale of the Brief Symptom Inventory
López-Arquillos 2016 [26] Spain Nationals of a country other than Spain Nationals of Spain 6 years (2003–08) Automotive repair workshop workers Cohort study 89,954 events 0·03 Unclear Has had any occupational injury (bone fracture only)
Mc Grath-Lone 2014 [27] England, United Kingdom Born outside of the United Kingdom Born in United Kingdom 1 year (2011) Sex workers Cohort study 2,704 participants 1·00 28 (migrant), 29 (non-migrant) (mean) Has human immunodeficiency virus, measured with a medical test
Rakprasit 2017 [28] Thailand Nationals of countries other than Thailand Nationals of Thailand 1 year (2011) All workers Cohort study 803,817 participants 0·59 18–59 (range) Has used any health services (for diarrhoea only), measured with administrative records
Reid 2016 [29] Australia Born in a country other than Australia Born in Australian 12 years (1991–2002) All workers Cohort study 5,156 events 0·50 15–64 (range) Has died from an occupational injury
Ricco 2019 [30] Autonomous Province of Trento, Italy Born in a country in the Eastern Mediterranean Born in Italy 14 years (2000–13) All workers Cohort study Unclear Unclear Unclear Has had any occupational injury, measured with administrative records
Richter 2014 [31] Three cities, South Africa Nationals of Botswana, Democratic Republic of the Congo, Eswatini, Malawi, Mozambique, Namibia, Nigeria, Zambia, and Zimbabwe Nationals of South Africa 1 year (2010) Sex workers Cross-sectional study 1,653 participants 1·00 29.7 (mean) Has used any health service in last month
Rubiales-Gutierrez 2010 [32] Spain Nationals of countries with a low Human Development Index score in Asia, Europe, Latin America and Oceania Nationals of Spain 1 year (2008) All workers Cross-sectional study 10,927 participants 0·42 (migrant), 0·41 (non-migrant) Unclear Has had any occupational injury
Salvatore 2013 [33] Italy Nationals of high migration pressure countriesa Nationals of Italy 1 year (2007) All workers Cohort study 60,528 participants 0·62 (migrant), 0·62 (non-migrant) Unclear Has had any occupational injury
Sieberer 2012 [34] Germany Nationals of Kazakhstan, Poland, Russia, Turkey and other countries Nationals of Germany 2 months (2008) Health workers Cross-sectional study 2,796 participants 0·74 ≥18 (range) Is clinically depressed (CESD score ≥ 23), measured with the Center of Epidemiological Studies Depression Scale
Steege 2014 [35] USA Born outside the USA and USA territories Born in the USA 5 years (2005–09) All workers Cohort study 27,000 events Unclear ≥15 (range) Died from an occupational injury,
Straiton 2014 [36] Norway Born in countries outside of Norway, including Germany, Iraq, Pakistan, Poland and Sweden Born in Norway 1 year (2008) All workers Cross-sectional study 2,962,408 individuals 0·44 38.5 (mean) Has used any health service (psychological diagnosis from general practitioner only)
Wong 2011 [37] One site, Hong Kong, China Country of origin other than China Country of origin China 3 years (2005–07) Sex workers Cohort study 503 participants 1·00 Unclear Has human immune virus, measured with laboratory test
Zhou 2013 [38] 35 sites, Guangxi, China Nationals of Viet Nam National of China 1 year (2010) Sex workers Cross-sectional study 12,622 participants 1·00 Mainly 20–39 (range) Has human immune virus, measured with laboratory test

a High migration pressure countries do not include in Europe, Austria, Belgium, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Ireland, Luxemburg, Netherlands, Portugal, United Kingdom, Spain, Sweden, Andorra, Cyprus, Iceland, Liechtenstein, Malta, Monaco, Norway, San Marino, Switzerland, and Vatican City; in North America, Canada and the United States; in Asia, Israel and Japan; and all of Oceania.