Skip to main content
. 2021 Aug 25;784:147058. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2021.147058

Table 1.

Overview of input hydroclimatic variables used to understand flood risk and numerical models used to simulate the efficiency and performance of NBS against flood risk.

Purpose Type of NBS (place) Models to simulate NBS efficiency Input hydroclimatic parameters References
To study the potentials of wetlands using the SWAT module of a GIS platform. Wetlands (Bojiang Haizi River, Erdos Larus relictus) SWAT Daily rainfall, wind speed, RH, solar energy and air temperature Li et al. (2019a)
To study the effects of vegetation on flood wave attenuation on the basis of a combination of field observation and numerical modelling. Salt marshes and coastal wetlands (Western Scheldt estuary, the Netherlands) SWAN numerical wave model Field measurement, bathymetry, ocean current, ocean water level, bottom fraction, and wind speed. Vuik et al. (2016)
To assess the functions of estuarial and tidal wetlands in reducing storm surge and flood damages. Estuarine wetlands (mudflats and channels) (USA) ArcGIS, ADCIRC numerical model Wind velocity and atmospheric pressure Highfield et al. (2018)
To simulate the role of wetland and vegetation roughness in reducing storm surge effects. Wetland and vegetation roughness (Southeast Louisiana) ADCIRC simulation/regression analysis Wind velocity, atmospheric pressure, topo bathymetric, manning coefficient Barbier et al. (2013)
To develop methods to delineate wetland inundation extent at basins. Wetlands (Prairie Pothole, central North Dakota) LiDAR, ArcGIS Multi-temporal NAIP imagery, national wetlands inventory dataset, NDVI Wu et al. (2019)
To study the effects of wetland regions their depth and positioning on river flows and peak flow control at basin scale. Wetlands/ponds (Shiawassee River watershed, Saginaw Bay) SWAT Land use, soils, wetland field data, precipitation, RH, potential evapotranspiration Martinez-Martinez et al. (2014)
To simulate hydrological processes with and without geographically isolated wetlands. Contracted wetland (Greensboro Watershed, Mid- Atlantic Region of USA) SWAT-WET DEM, wetland drainage zones, daily precipitation temperature, and streamflow. Yeo et al. (2019)
To analyse the role of weir and dredging of the channel in reducing upstream flood risks. Wetland conservation, pond, lake (upper Lunan basin Scotland) HEC-RAS Maximum elevation, river water levels, discharge, lake water levels, precipitation Vinten et al. (2019)
To simulate the potential of wetlands in attenuating peak water levels during storm tides. Hybrid (Western Scheldt estuary, the Netherlands) 2D hydrodynamic model (TELEMAC 2D) DEM, hourly averaged wind speeds, water level. Stark et al. (2016)
To apply a novel framework of hydrodynamic and geospatial modelling to simulate the optimal flood risk reduction measures by wetland. Wetland (Lower Tisza River, Hungary) 1D HEC-RAS model, ArcGIS, HEC-GeoRAS DEM, daily discharge, maximum annual discharges, levees height Guida et al. (2015)
To present a method that can describe the failure likelihood of a hybrid flood water protection system by integrating numerical models with stochastic models. Hybrid flood (Netherlands) 1D wave energy balance Mean wave period, water level, significant wave height, and wind speed Vuik et al. (2018)
Using the hybrid (blue-green) approach to retain and purify stormwater runoff from the street. Hybrid (blue green) (Łódź, Poland) Field survey Precipitation, discharge Jurczak et al. (2018)
Effectiveness of several NBS in the reduction of runoff. Bio-retention, grass swale, and porous pavement (Tianjin University, China) Storm Water Management Model (SWMM) Precipitation, Temperature, Evaporation, Wind speed, Basin elevation Niu et al. (2016)
Investigating whether an increase in the number of nature-based features can reduce surface runoff in hillslope areas. Low earth bunds and debris dams (Brompton catchment, UK) TOPMODEL and 1-dimensional hydraulic channel routing scheme Precipitation, digital elevation model Metcalfe et al. (2017)
Effect of applying NBS on several hydrological variables related to floods. Tree woodland (River Cary, UK) HEC-RAS and 2-dimensional River2D hydraulic model Precipitation, River channel, river cross section Thomas and Nisbet (2007)
Simulating changes in flow of water along channels and across surfaces due to application of NBS. Storage pond (Tarland Burn catchment, UK; Spercheios River Basin, Greece) TUFLOW Precipitation, Basin boundary, Initial water level, Land use, Soil infiltration, Elevation Ghimire et al. (2014)
Spyrou et al. (2021)
Potential of green infrastructure in regulating surface runoff under climate change scenarios. Trees and green roofs (Munich, Germany) MIKE-SHE Precipitation, Basin boundary, Manning's number, Wind speed, Evaporation, Temperature Zölch et al. (2017)
Reduction of flood damages during coastal flooding Coastal wetlands (New Jersey, USA) MIKE-21 Precipitation, Basin boundary, Manning's number, Wind speed, Evaporation, Temperature Narayan et al. (2017)
Investigating the synergic effects of floodplain restoration on flood risk reduction Forest and wetland revegetation (Vermont, USA) HEC-RAS and economic flood damage cost model Precipitation, River channel, river cross section Gourevitch et al. (2020)
A hydrodynamic approach is combined with an optimisation function to assess various green, blue and grey solutions in an integrated way. Green-blue-grey approach (Sint Maarten Island, Saint Martin) Hydrodynamic model EPA SWMM coupled with optimisation algorithm, Questionnaire, multi-criteria analysis Model simulated precipitation data and evaporation Alves et al. (2020)
To evaluate the efficiency of isolated wetland subsurface and surface hydrologic connections to rivers. Wetland soils (Prairie Pothole, North America) (Prairie Pothole Region of North America) HydroGeoSphere model DEM, water level, rainfall Ameli and Creed (2017)
To evaluate the performance of dune structure reconstruction as a DRR solution in the face of current and future sea level conditions at a quickly eroding coastal area. Dune system rehabilitation (reconstruction and revegetation), Bellocchio, Italy Hydro-morpho dynamic model Temporal analogue extreme storm event from 5 to 6 February 2015, used to test the NBS Fernández-Montblanc et al. (2020)
A societal scale model was built to estimate the efficiency of green NBS on reducing the magnitude and quick flow of urban surface runoff. Green infrastructure, Beijing, China Community scale simulation model Urban flooding Liu et al. (2014)
To estimate overall benefits of flood storage capacity which was implemented as part of the restoration of wetlands in this area. Wetland and ponds (Cambridgeshire, UK). TESSA toolkit Peh et al. (2013)
To estimate the impact of shore area wetlands in the northeastern USA against hurricane induced flood risk. Coastal wetland cover (Atlantic coast USA), MIKE-21 flood model The model was simulated by the wind which was based on observed data
Bathymetry data was part of the MIKE model C-MAP.
Narayan et al. (2017)
To offer a worldwide study of the socio-economic value of mangroves for flood risk management. Mangrove forests, global analysis. Delft3D Historical cyclones and normal waves and sea level astronomical, storm surge, tide and mean sea level to generate the regression model Menendez et al. (2020)
To present a methodology for the choice and placing of NBS to accomplish urban flood risk management. Green wall/roofs, bio-retentions, rain gardens and previous pavements, Sukhumvit area, Bangkok, Thailand A macro scale approach for urban flood modelling, using the Mike Urban hydrodynamic model. Rainfall return periods (1-in-2 year, and 1-in-20 year) Majidi et al. (2019)