Table 1.
Purpose | Type of NBS (place) | Models to simulate NBS efficiency | Input hydroclimatic parameters | References |
---|---|---|---|---|
To study the potentials of wetlands using the SWAT module of a GIS platform. | Wetlands (Bojiang Haizi River, Erdos Larus relictus) | SWAT | Daily rainfall, wind speed, RH, solar energy and air temperature | Li et al. (2019a) |
To study the effects of vegetation on flood wave attenuation on the basis of a combination of field observation and numerical modelling. | Salt marshes and coastal wetlands (Western Scheldt estuary, the Netherlands) | SWAN numerical wave model | Field measurement, bathymetry, ocean current, ocean water level, bottom fraction, and wind speed. | Vuik et al. (2016) |
To assess the functions of estuarial and tidal wetlands in reducing storm surge and flood damages. | Estuarine wetlands (mudflats and channels) (USA) | ArcGIS, ADCIRC numerical model | Wind velocity and atmospheric pressure | Highfield et al. (2018) |
To simulate the role of wetland and vegetation roughness in reducing storm surge effects. | Wetland and vegetation roughness (Southeast Louisiana) | ADCIRC simulation/regression analysis | Wind velocity, atmospheric pressure, topo bathymetric, manning coefficient | Barbier et al. (2013) |
To develop methods to delineate wetland inundation extent at basins. | Wetlands (Prairie Pothole, central North Dakota) | LiDAR, ArcGIS | Multi-temporal NAIP imagery, national wetlands inventory dataset, NDVI | Wu et al. (2019) |
To study the effects of wetland regions their depth and positioning on river flows and peak flow control at basin scale. | Wetlands/ponds (Shiawassee River watershed, Saginaw Bay) | SWAT | Land use, soils, wetland field data, precipitation, RH, potential evapotranspiration | Martinez-Martinez et al. (2014) |
To simulate hydrological processes with and without geographically isolated wetlands. | Contracted wetland (Greensboro Watershed, Mid- Atlantic Region of USA) | SWAT-WET | DEM, wetland drainage zones, daily precipitation temperature, and streamflow. | Yeo et al. (2019) |
To analyse the role of weir and dredging of the channel in reducing upstream flood risks. | Wetland conservation, pond, lake (upper Lunan basin Scotland) | HEC-RAS | Maximum elevation, river water levels, discharge, lake water levels, precipitation | Vinten et al. (2019) |
To simulate the potential of wetlands in attenuating peak water levels during storm tides. | Hybrid (Western Scheldt estuary, the Netherlands) | 2D hydrodynamic model (TELEMAC 2D) | DEM, hourly averaged wind speeds, water level. | Stark et al. (2016) |
To apply a novel framework of hydrodynamic and geospatial modelling to simulate the optimal flood risk reduction measures by wetland. | Wetland (Lower Tisza River, Hungary) | 1D HEC-RAS model, ArcGIS, HEC-GeoRAS | DEM, daily discharge, maximum annual discharges, levees height | Guida et al. (2015) |
To present a method that can describe the failure likelihood of a hybrid flood water protection system by integrating numerical models with stochastic models. | Hybrid flood (Netherlands) | 1D wave energy balance | Mean wave period, water level, significant wave height, and wind speed | Vuik et al. (2018) |
Using the hybrid (blue-green) approach to retain and purify stormwater runoff from the street. | Hybrid (blue green) (Łódź, Poland) | Field survey | Precipitation, discharge | Jurczak et al. (2018) |
Effectiveness of several NBS in the reduction of runoff. | Bio-retention, grass swale, and porous pavement (Tianjin University, China) | Storm Water Management Model (SWMM) | Precipitation, Temperature, Evaporation, Wind speed, Basin elevation | Niu et al. (2016) |
Investigating whether an increase in the number of nature-based features can reduce surface runoff in hillslope areas. | Low earth bunds and debris dams (Brompton catchment, UK) | TOPMODEL and 1-dimensional hydraulic channel routing scheme | Precipitation, digital elevation model | Metcalfe et al. (2017) |
Effect of applying NBS on several hydrological variables related to floods. | Tree woodland (River Cary, UK) | HEC-RAS and 2-dimensional River2D hydraulic model | Precipitation, River channel, river cross section | Thomas and Nisbet (2007) |
Simulating changes in flow of water along channels and across surfaces due to application of NBS. | Storage pond (Tarland Burn catchment, UK; Spercheios River Basin, Greece) | TUFLOW | Precipitation, Basin boundary, Initial water level, Land use, Soil infiltration, Elevation |
Ghimire et al. (2014) Spyrou et al. (2021) |
Potential of green infrastructure in regulating surface runoff under climate change scenarios. | Trees and green roofs (Munich, Germany) | MIKE-SHE | Precipitation, Basin boundary, Manning's number, Wind speed, Evaporation, Temperature | Zölch et al. (2017) |
Reduction of flood damages during coastal flooding | Coastal wetlands (New Jersey, USA) | MIKE-21 | Precipitation, Basin boundary, Manning's number, Wind speed, Evaporation, Temperature | Narayan et al. (2017) |
Investigating the synergic effects of floodplain restoration on flood risk reduction | Forest and wetland revegetation (Vermont, USA) | HEC-RAS and economic flood damage cost model | Precipitation, River channel, river cross section | Gourevitch et al. (2020) |
A hydrodynamic approach is combined with an optimisation function to assess various green, blue and grey solutions in an integrated way. | Green-blue-grey approach (Sint Maarten Island, Saint Martin) | Hydrodynamic model EPA SWMM coupled with optimisation algorithm, Questionnaire, multi-criteria analysis | Model simulated precipitation data and evaporation | Alves et al. (2020) |
To evaluate the efficiency of isolated wetland subsurface and surface hydrologic connections to rivers. | Wetland soils (Prairie Pothole, North America) (Prairie Pothole Region of North America) | HydroGeoSphere model | DEM, water level, rainfall | Ameli and Creed (2017) |
To evaluate the performance of dune structure reconstruction as a DRR solution in the face of current and future sea level conditions at a quickly eroding coastal area. | Dune system rehabilitation (reconstruction and revegetation), Bellocchio, Italy | Hydro-morpho dynamic model | Temporal analogue extreme storm event from 5 to 6 February 2015, used to test the NBS | Fernández-Montblanc et al. (2020) |
A societal scale model was built to estimate the efficiency of green NBS on reducing the magnitude and quick flow of urban surface runoff. | Green infrastructure, Beijing, China | Community scale simulation model | Urban flooding | Liu et al. (2014) |
To estimate overall benefits of flood storage capacity which was implemented as part of the restoration of wetlands in this area. | Wetland and ponds (Cambridgeshire, UK). | TESSA toolkit | Peh et al. (2013) | |
To estimate the impact of shore area wetlands in the northeastern USA against hurricane induced flood risk. | Coastal wetland cover (Atlantic coast USA), | MIKE-21 flood model | The model was simulated by the wind which was based on observed data Bathymetry data was part of the MIKE model C-MAP. |
Narayan et al. (2017) |
To offer a worldwide study of the socio-economic value of mangroves for flood risk management. | Mangrove forests, global analysis. | Delft3D | Historical cyclones and normal waves and sea level astronomical, storm surge, tide and mean sea level to generate the regression model | Menendez et al. (2020) |
To present a methodology for the choice and placing of NBS to accomplish urban flood risk management. | Green wall/roofs, bio-retentions, rain gardens and previous pavements, Sukhumvit area, Bangkok, Thailand | A macro scale approach for urban flood modelling, using the Mike Urban hydrodynamic model. | Rainfall return periods (1-in-2 year, and 1-in-20 year) | Majidi et al. (2019) |