Table 3. Comparison of 4 different dynamic ECG monitoring devices.
Name of device | H3-ECG | Apple Watch with KardiaBand | Multi-lead Holter | Implantable loop recorder |
H3-ECG and Apple Watch with KardiaBand are remote multi-lead and single-lead wearable ECG monitoring devices, Holter is a traditional multi-lead ECG monitoring device, and implantable loop recorder is an invasive single-lead ECG monitoring device. Their respective features, pros and cons of are compared in the figure. AF: atrial fibrillation; CFDA: China Food and Drug Administration; FDA: Food and Drug Administration; ESUS: embolic stroke of undetermined source. | ||||
ECG lead | Six extremity leads (Ⅰ, Ⅱ, Ⅲ, aVR, aVL, aVF) | Lead Ⅰ | Three precordial leads (V1,V3,V5) or simulate 12 leads | Single lead |
Recording method | Four short lead wires and a built-in recording ECG box. | Place thumb on the sensor to record rhythm. | 7–10 long lead wires with an external recording device | Subcutaneous implantation |
Advantage | Long-time (72 hours) and cardiac events recording. Remote and real-time.
Close to the heart, large signal amplitude, strong anti-interference ability. |
Single cardiac events recording. Far from the heart, small signal amplitude, weak anti-interference ability. | 24-hour recording. Technically simple procedure and accurate detection. | Long-time recording (months or years).
Remote monitoring. |
Certification | CFDA | FDA | FDA | FDA |
Disadvantage | Not easy to wear.
Lack of clinical application research evidence. |
Wave amplitude affected by pressing pressure, unable to detect continuously, large interference only detected lead Ⅰ. | Cumbersome, inconvenient.
No remote real-time data. More than one day recording requires replacement of electrodes and batteries. |
High costs.
Invasive examination, increase the risk of infection and bleeding. |
Applicable people and accuracy | Paroxysmal palpitations and asymptomatic AF.
The detection of AF has a sensitivity of 94% and specificity of 98%. |
Real-time monitoring of patients with paroxysmal palpitations.
The detection of AF has a sensitivity of 93% and specificity of 84%. |
Non-real-time 24-hour monitoring of patients with paroxysmal palpitations.
The detection of AF has a sensitivity of 91% and specificity of 99%. |
Unexplained syncope, asymptomatic AF.
AF can be documented in approximately 25% of patients with the diagnosis of ESUS. |