Skip to main content
. 2021 Jun 6;18(11):6117. doi: 10.3390/ijerph18116117

Table 4.

Table of items in IYCD prototype removed and reasons why.

Domain Item Number from Prototype 1 * Item Wording Reason for Removal
Motor FIN1 Does your child look at your face with interest and attention? Same age attainment as adjoining items and slightly confusing when translating and back translating.
FIN24A Does your child write the first letter of his/her name? (This item was added in phase I/II.)
Item age attainment too advanced for 0- to 36-month children.
GRO2 When you hold your child in a sitting position, does he/she hold his head steady? Same age attainment as adjoining items, therefore no need for this item
GRO3 When pulling your child from lying down on his or her back to sitting, does your child hold his/her head steady? Same age attainment as adjoining items, therefore no need for this item.
GRO20N Does your child walk backwards, two or more steps WITHOUT any support? Same age attainment to adjoining item; “stands on one foot with support”, which was more understandable on cognitive testing. Reliability not high.
GRO23 While standing, does your child CATCH a ball and hold on to it, for at least a few seconds? Same age attainment to GRO21 (Does your child stand on one foot without any support for at least a few seconds?), which requires fewer props.
Language REC1 Does your child respond or startle when a loud sound is made? Not related to age (poor developmental trajectory).
REC2 Does your child respond to your voice or someone else’s voice even if you are not talking to the child directly? Same age attainment to REC3 (Does your child turn his/her head toward your voice or some noise?) but less consistent across different countries
REC7 When you say “no”, does your child stop what they are doing? Same age attainment as adjoining items. Confusing item; not easy to ask on cognitive testing.
REC18N If you ask your child “Where is the boy/girl/baby/cow/chicken/etc.?” can your child POINT TO or look at the right picture?) Same age attainment as REC10 (When you ask “where is the ball/ spoon/ cup/ cloth/ door/ plate/ bucket etc.” does your child look at or point to (or even name) the object? How many objects can your child identify?) but more variability between countries. Very variable direct vs. parent report
EXP17 When looking at pictures or watching others, can your child tell you what ACTION is taking place (for example running, playing, sleeping etc.) Same age attainment as adjoining items, and some countries not happy that this item was culturally acceptable.
EXP18 How many objects can your child name? Same age attainment as adjoining items, therefore no need for this item.
EXP22 Can your child explain correctly what the following are used for? Cup (eating/drinking), spoon (eating), knife (cutting), matches (lighting fire, burning things), torch (light), broom Same age attainment as adjoining items and some cultural differences across countries, making the item less consistent
EXP25A Does your child count three objects? Same age attainment as adjoining items, therefore no need for this item.
EXP28 Does your child know a song or rhyme from memory? Attained at a later age, and confusing item for assessors
Socio-emotional SE3 When your child is upset and you try to comfort him/ her does he/she calm down? Not related to age (poor developmental trajectory).
SE7 When you leave your child with a family member, does your child go with that person easily? Not related to age (poor developmental trajectory).
SE14 Does child pretend to drink from a cup, or eat with a spoon? Not related to age (poor developmental trajectory).
SE16 Does your child care for a doll or stuffed animal as if it were a person (for example by feeding and bathing it)? Not related to age (poor developmental trajectory).
SE24 Is your child easily distracted, that is has trouble sticking to any activity? Not related to age (poor developmental trajectory).
SE29 When child is very upset, can he/she calm self quickly? Not related to age (poor developmental trajectory).
SE30 Would you say that your child bullies or is mean to others at times? Not related to age (poor developmental trajectory).
SE32 When you send your child to get something, does he/she forget what he/she was supposed to get? Not related to age (poor developmental trajectory).

* Please note the item numbers shown here are the item codes from the previous version of the tool.