Table 1.
Table summarizing the goals of neoadjuvant chemotherapy (ChT) and chemoradiation (ChT-RT) alongside supporting evidence. A, adriamycin; C, cetuximab; CR, complete response; E, etoposide; F, 5-fluorouracile; I, ifosfamide; N.A., not available; P, cisplatin; T, taxane. * Concurrent to RT; ** Hirawaka et al. [58] used different evaluation criteria to measure response to treatment, other authors used RECIST (Response Evaluation Criteria In Solid Tumors).
| Rationale | Supporting Evidence | Type of Neoadjuvant Treatment (Objective Response Rate) | ChT Regimens | Description | References |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Orbit preservation | Yes | ChT (61.9–100%) | TPF | Neoadjuvant ChT is associated with a considerable chance of orbit preservation (range: 60.0–78.8%) in patients for whom orbital ablation would be indicated in case of upfront surgery. | Ock et al. [63] Hanna et al. [62] Chen et al. [64] Turri-Zanoni et al. [65] Ferrari et al. [49] Fernström et al. [66] |
| TPI | |||||
| TP | |||||
| TF | |||||
| PF | |||||
| ChT-RT (57.1%; CR rate: 35.7–48.1%) | P * | Neoadjuvant ChT-RT reduces the rate of orbital ablation in patients with orbit-abutting SNSCC (range: 93–100%). | Amsbaugh et al. [67] Fernström et al. [66] |
||
| Stratification of prognosis | Yes | ChT (67.4–93.0% **) | TPF | A good response to neoadjuvant ChT is associated with a relatively favorable prognosis in terms of recurrence and survival. | Hanna et al. [62] Hirakawa et al. [68] |
| TPI | |||||
| TF | |||||
| PF | |||||
| Improvement of margin status | Yes | ChT-RT (N.A.) | N.A. | Neoadjuvant ChT-RT reduces the rate of involved margins in patients with orbit-abutting SNSCC. | Robin et al. [69] |
| Chemoselection | No | ChT (56.9%) | TPF | Effectiveness of locoregional treatment (surgery vs. (ChT)-RT) does not relate to response to neoadjuvant ChT. | Abdelmeguid et al. [70] |
| TPI | |||||
| TP | |||||
| TP-C | |||||
| Improvement of distant metastasis-free survival | No | ChT (56.9%) | TPF | Neoadjuvant ChT could reduce the risk of distant metastases; however, comparative evidence is lacking. | Bossi et al. [71] Abdelmeguid et al. [70] |
| TPI | |||||
| TP | |||||
| TP-C |