Table 1.
Summary of selected studies (n=56)
No of studies (%) | |||
Publication date | Study setting* | ||
Before 2010 | 4 (7%) | Africa | 48 (86%) |
After 2010 | 52 (93%) | Asia | 6 (11%) |
South America | 3 (5%) | ||
Type of publication | Pacific Islands | 1 (2%) | |
Peer-reviewed articles | 45 (80%) | ||
Grey literature | 11 (20%) | ||
Methodology | |||
Study design | Quantitative study | 30 (54%) | |
Quasi-experimental studies | 22 (39%) | Qualitative study | 7 (13%) |
(Pre–postintervention) | Mixed-methods study | 19 (34%) | |
Case studies | 11 (20%) | ||
Cross-sectional studies | 8 (14%) | RHIS factors addressed by the interventions | |
Process evaluations | 5 (9%) | All factors addressed | 43 (77%) |
Randomised controlled trials | 5 (9%) | Technical factors addressed | 49 (88%) |
Retrospective studies/non-experimental design | 5 (9%) | Organisational/ Behavioural factors addressed | 51 (91%) |
Study period | RHIS processes addressed by the interventions | ||
<1 year | 24 (43%) | Multiple processes addressed | 48 (86%) |
Between 1 and 3 years | 19 (34%) | Most addressed process | Data collection (52;93%) |
More than 3 years | 10 (18%) | Least addressed process | Data display (8;14%) |
Unknown | 3 (5%) |
*Includes two multi-country study: one with multiple African countries and one with countries in both Africa and Asia
RHIS, routine health information system.