Table 2.
Clinical | Preclinical (Small Laboratory Animals) | |
---|---|---|
Commercial device | Available | Available |
Current level of use | Research, clinical practice | Routine research |
Guidelines/practical recommendations | Available | Available |
Reference values | Available | Available |
Subject’s state of consciousness | Unaltered | Anesthetized |
Subject’s position | Seated, supine, upright | Supine |
Subject’s connection to the device | Mouthpiece | Tracheotomy or oral intubation |
Subject’s breathing pattern | Spontaneous: usually breathing at tidal volume | Mechanical ventilation |
Subject’s lung volume at the time of assessment | Variable: spontaneous volume adopted by the subject | Standardized transpulmonary pressure |
Subject’s airway tree | Intact, mouth to lung | Partial: lower airways only |
Measurement type | Finite perturbations | Finite perturbations |
Measurement duration | 20 s to 1 min | 1 to 16 s |
Signal generator | Loudspeaker Moving mesh |
Computer-controlled piston ventilator |
Type of input signal | Single frequency Multifrequency |
Single frequency Multifrequency Optimized ventilator waveform |
Nature of input signal | Impulse Predefined sine waves |
Predefined sine waves |
Frequency range | Variable: typically 5 to ∼40 Hz | Variable: typically 0.5 to 20 Hz |
Delivery of input signal | Superimposed on subject’s breathing | During a brief apneic period |
Aerosol administration | Via the mouth | Intratracheal |
Output | Input impedance | Input or transfer impedance |
Interpretation of impedance | Response at set frequencies Shape analysis of the frequency-response curves Area-under-the-curve |
Mathematical models and derived parameters |
Strengths | Structure-function link Access to lung periphery Absolute values Sensitivity Measurement during regular quiet breathing |
Structure-function link Access to lung periphery Absolute values Sensitivity Precision: measurements made under fully controlled conditions |
Limitations | Assessment over a limited span of the respiratory pressure, volume, and flow ranges Chest wall contribution Standardization of lung volumes |
Anesthesia Invasive measurements Variable chest wall contributions across species |