Table 1.
Origin/item | Spiking (No of oocysts) No of positive/tested | Amount (g) | Pre-treatment | DNA isolation | Detection method | Recovery or LOD (oocyst) | Reference |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Raspberry wash sediment extract | YES (50) | 250 g | 6 × 2 min in N2/98 °C | DNA released by F-T | nested PCR | 25 | Jinneman et al. (1998) |
Raspberries | YES (N/A) | 100 g | NO | 6 mm FTA filters | nested PCR | 10–30/100 g | Orlandi and Lampel (2000) |
Basil leaves | YES (101–103) | 30 g | 8 × 1 min in N2/98 °C | QIAamp DNA microkit or DNeasy blood and tissue kit | PCR | 10 in 9/15; 1 in 2/15 sampl | Lalonde and Gajadhar (2008) |
Raspberries, basil, mesclun lettuce | YES (10–4000) | 100 g | NO | QIAamp DNA Stool Mini Kit | nested PCR | LOD: tens of unita; Recovery: 5/50 g | Steele et al. (2003) |
Washes from raspberry, basil, pesto | YES (50 or 500, 5000) | 25 g basil; 50 g raspberries | NO | FastDNA SPIN Kit for soil, UltraClean™ Soil DNA Isolation Kit, QIAamp DNA Mini Stool Kit, UNEX method | nested PCR; qPCR | LOD: 1 copy of gene | Shields et al. (2013) |
Leafy greens | NO (9/544) | 25 g | 5 × 2 min in N2/90 °C | Qiagen DNeasy Blood and Tissue Kit | nested PCR | N/A | Dixon et al. (2013) |
Basil | YES (100 or 1000) | 25 g | NO | FastDNA Spin for Soil Kit | nested PCR | N/A | Chandra et al. (2014) |
Cucumber, lettuce, fennel, celery, tomato, melon, chicory | NO (6/49) | 100 g external leaves of vegetableb; 1000 g melon or tomato | NO | Nucleospin tissue/stool kit | qPCR | N/Ac | Giangaspero et al. (2015) |
Leafy greens (herbs, green onions), berry fruits | YES (5000 E. pappilata) | 35 ± 0.5 g | 8 × 1 min in N2/98 °C | QIAamp DNA Mini Kit | qPCR | 5 of E. papillata/g | Lalonde and Gajadhar (2016b) |
Leafy greensd | NO (6/1171) | 35 ± 0.5 g | 8 × 1 min in N2/98 °C | QIAamp DNA microkit/DNeasy blood and tissue kit | qPCR | Recovery: 3%–18% | Lalonde and Gajadhar (2016a) |
Packaged saladse | NO (1.3%/64) | 100 g | 15 × 1 min N2/65 °C | QiAmp Plant Mini Kit | qPCR | 46–1580/g | Caradonna et al. (2017) |
Perilla leaves, winter-grown cabbages, chives, sprouts, blueberries, cherry tomatoes | NO (5/44) | 20 g perilla; 30 g sprouts; 50 g rest | NO | QIAquick stool mini kit | qPCR, nested | 13–348/g | Sim et al. (2017) |
cilantro, raspberries | YES (0, 5, 10, 200) | 25 g cilantro; 50 g raspberries | BB | FastDNA SPIN Kit for Soil | nested PCR, qPCR | N/A | Murphy et al. (2017) |
Cilantro, raspberries | YES-interlaboratory (0, 5, 10, 200) | 25 g cilantro; 50 g raspberries | BB | FastDNA SPIN Kit for Soil | nested PCR, qPCR | LOD: 0.2/g | Murphy et al. (2018) |
Carrot, cabbage, basil, parsley, Coleslaw with dressing | YES (5 or 10, 200); 141 | 25 g | BB | FastDNA SPIN Kit for Soil with a FastPrep-24 Instrument | qPCR | 5/25 g | Almeria et al. (2018) |
Strawberries, blueberries, raspberries | YES (10, 50) | 30 g | 2 × BB 4 m/s for 60 s | DNeasy PowerSoil Kit | qPCR/multiplex | LOD: 10/30 g | Temesgen et al., 2019a, Temesgen et al., 2019b |
Vegetables, fruitsf | NO (2/1099) (0,2%) | 25 g | NO | E.Z.N.A.R® Stool DNA Kit | nested PCR | N/A | Li et al. (2019) |
Spinach | YES (101–104) | 10 g | 1 × 4 min N2/100 °C | DNeasy Blood and Tissue Kit | nested multiple, qPCR, RFLP | 1–10/g | Shapiro et al. (2019) |
Berry fruit | YES (20,200) | 30 g | BB | DNeasy PowerSoil kit/UNEX-based DNA extraction | qPCR | 10/30 g | Temesgen et al. (2020) |
Fresh and frozen berriesg | YES (1,20) | 50 g | BB | FastDNA SPIN Kit for Soil | qPCR | 5/50 g | Assurian et al. (2020a) |
Fresh berries, berry farm soil | YES (0−103) | 50 g | NO | ZymoBIOMICS DNA Kit | nested PCR | 1/g | Resendiz-Nava et al. (2020) |
Cilantro | YES (5, 10, 200) | 25 g | BB | FastDNA SPIN Kit for Soil with a FastPrep-24h | qPCR | Assurian et al. (2020b) | |
Strawberries | NO (1/120) | 30 g | BB | DNeasy PowerSoil kit | multiplex PCR | Pineda et al. (2020) |
LOD = limit of detection.
BB = bead beating.
40 oocysts/100 g raspberries, 10 oocysts/100 g basil, 1000 oocysts/100 g mesclun lettuce.
Lettuce, fennel, celery or the external part of cucumber.
The number of DNA copies per μl was calculated by correlating the Ct mean value, with the number of oocysts calculated assuming that an oocyst contains 15 copies of rDNA, depending on the stage of sporulation.
Spinach, spring mix, leaf lettuce, romaine, kale, arugula, chard, collards, dandelion greens, rapini.
Mixed salad (curly and escarole lettuce, red radish, rocket salad and carrots).
Lettuce, coriander, celery, baby bok choy, leaf lettuce, water spinach, crown daisy, fennel plant, endive, spinach, schizonepeta, cabbage, leaf mustard, Chinese chive, chive and the stripped epidermis of cucumber, watermelon, potato, bean, green chili.
Blackberries, strawberries, blueberries and mixed berries.
Five DNA cleanup commercial kits: QIAquick® Purification kit, One step™ PCR inhibitor removal, Nucleospin® Genomic DNA clean up, DNA IQ™ system and DNeasy® Power Plant® Pro kit.