Skip to main content
. 2021 Jun 18;16(6):e0253521. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0253521

Table 4. Characteristics of studies that compared muscle damage between eccentric and concentric actions of low-load resistance exercise with blood flow restriction.

Reference Sujects (Age) Variables Training protocol Intensity Traininig volume Interval Pressure CW (cm) Results
EX MT TS Sets Repetitions CON+BFR (Time effect) ECC+BFR (Time effect) Condition effect
Umbel et al. (2009) [29] (Experiment 2) 8 men and 7 women (23±6 years) MVC, DOMS, PPT, Edema. KE
KF
Uni 2s 35% of MVC 3 Muscle failure 90s 1.3 x bSBP 6 DOMS ↑ (24,48h post)
PPT ↔
MVC ↓ (24h post)
Edema ↑ (24h post)
DOMS ↑ (24,48h post)
PPT ↔
MVC ↔
Edema ↑ (24h post)
DOMS was greater 24 and 48 after CON + BFR; PPT and edema were not different between conditions; MVC was lower 24, 48h after CON + BFR.
Thiebaud et al. (2013) [34] 10 men (23±2 years) MVC, Edema, ROM, DOMS. AE
AF
Uni. 1.5
30% of 1RM 4 30x15x15x15 30s 120 mmHg 3 MVC ↓ (Post)
DOMS ↔
ROM ↓ (Post)
Edema ↑ (Post)
MVC ↓ (0h post)
DOMS ↑ (24, 48h post)
ROM ↓ (Post)
Edema ↑ (Post)
MVC was lower immediately after CON + BFR; DOMS was greater 24, 48, 72h after ECC + BFR; Edema was greater immediately after CON + BFR. ROM was no different between conditions.
Hill et al. (2019) [41] 25 women (21±1 years) DOMS, PPT, Edema, ROM, MVC AF
AE
Uni. 120° s-1 30% of MVC
4 30x15x15x15 30s 40% of AOP 3 DOMS ↔
PPT↔
ROM↔
MVC↔
Edema ↔
DOMS ↔
PPT↔
ROM↔
MVC↔
Edema ↔
There were no differences in any of the variables analyzed between the conditions.

EX = exercise; MT = mode of training; TS = training speed; CW = cuff width; BFR = blood flow restriction; ECC = eccentric; CON = concentric; MVC = maximum voluntary contraction; 1RM = 1 maximum repetition; KE = knee extension; KF = knee flexion; AF = arm flexion; AE = arm extension; bSBP = brachial systolic blood pressure; AOP = arterial occlusion pressure; mmHg = millimeters of mercury; DOMS = delayed onset muscle soreness; PPT = pain–pressure threshold; ROM = range of Motion.