Table 3.
Comparison of different tACS improvement methods.
Method | Purpose of improvement | Number of stimulation electrodes | Stimulus signal parameters | Stimulus focus | Stimulus intensity | Stimulation artifact | Stimulating effect | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Frequency | Amplitude | |||||||
HD-tACS | Increase targeting accuracy | 4 cathode and 1 anode or 4 anode and 1 cathode | Alpha band and theta band | 1–2 mA | Precision | Medium | Medium | Compared with that of traditional tACS, the stimulation intensity of the stimulation area is higher and the stimulation is more focused |
Phase-shifted tACS | Change the stimulus phase to affect the connectivity of the stimulated brain region | 3 | Alpha band and theta band | 1–2 mA | General | Medium | Medium | The magnitude of the electric field is different under different stimulation phases, and the electric field intensity under the reversed-phase condition is significantly higher than that under the same phase stimulation condition (2–2.3 times). |
AM-tACS | Reduce stimulus artifacts | 3 | Modulated signal: Alpha band and theta band. Carrier: hundreds of Hz | 1–2 mA | General (existing diffuse stimulation) | Medium | Low | Stimulation artifacts can be reduced to the extent that tACS is not applied |
Temporally interfering stimulation | Reduce stimulus diffusion and stimulate directly into deep brain areas. | 4 | Thousands of Hz | 100–400 μA (mice) | Precision | Low | Low | Through interference, stimulation can be directly applied to the region of interest to reduce the effect on the cortex, and the focus of the stimulation can be changed by changing the stimulation current rather than the position of the electrode. |
Intersectional Short Pulse Stimulation | Enhance focus and increase the amplitude of the stimulus | Multiple pairs of electrodes | 1–1,000 Hz | 1–7.5 mA | General (existing diffuse stimulation) | High | Medium | The current intensity can be much higher than that of the above stimulation methods while keeping the charge density and sensation on the scalp surface relatively low. |