Skip to main content
. 2021 Jun 18;59(7):e02304-20. doi: 10.1128/JCM.02304-20

TABLE 1.

Characteristics of studies included in the systematic reviewa

Author (yr) Location Pathogen No. of results Setting Age range Self-swab site HCW swab site Test QUADAS score
Altamirano (2020) California, USA SARS-CoV-2 30 Clinic ≥18 yrs Nasal and pharyngeal Nasal and pharyngeal RT-PCR 12
Kojima (2020) California, USA SARS-CoV-2 45 Home ≥18 yrs Nasal and oral fluid (supervised, unsupervised) NP RT-qPCR 12
Wehrhahn (2020) Australia SARS-CoV-2 236 Testing facility 7–81 yrs Nasal and pharyngeal Nasal, pharyngeal and NP RT-PCR 12
Yuan-Po Tu (2020) Washington, USA SARS-CoV-2 530 Outpatient clinic Not stated Tongue, nasal, midturbinate NP RT-PCR 11
Fragoso (1989) New Jersey, USA Group A Streptococcus 98 Clinic 4–17 yrs Pharyngeal Pharyngeal Culture 8
Katz (1974) Maryland, USA Group A Streptococcus 137 Clinic “Children” Pharyngeal Pharyngeal Culture 8
Murray (2015) Minnesota, USA Group A Streptococcus 402 Clinic ≥3 yrs Pharyngeal Pharyngeal RT-PCR 12
Dhiman (2012) Minnesota, USA Influenza A and B 72 Emergency room 18–92 yrs Nasal (midturbinate) Nasal (midturbinate) RT-PCR 12
Esposito (2010) Italy Influenza A and B 203 Emergency room 6 mo to 5 yrs Nasal (midturbinate) Nasal (midturbinate) RT-PCR 11
Granados (2017) Ontario, Canada Influenza A and B 459 Home Children and adults Nasal (midturbinate) Nasal (midturbinate) RT-PCR 11
Goyal (2017) Thailand Influenza A and B 127 Clinic ≥65 yrs Nasal NP and nasal RT-PCR 11
Ip (2012) Hong Kong Influenza A and B 196 Home and clinic Children and adults Nasal and pharyngeal Nasal and pharyngeal RT-PCR 10
Barbee (2020) Washington, USA C. trachomatis and N. gonorrhoeae 258 Clinic Not stated Pharyngeal Pharyngeal Culture 12
Dangerfield (2019) Maryland, USA C. trachomatis and N. gonorrhoeae 79 Clinic ≥18 yrs Pharyngeal Pharyngeal NAAT 12
Freeman (2011) California, USA C. trachomatis and N. gonorrhoeae 480 Clinic Adults Pharyngeal Pharyngeal NAAT 10
Akmatov (2012) Germany Respiratory pathogens 82 Research institute 18–69 yrs Nasal (anterior nares) Nasal Multiplex PCR 10
Larios (2011) Ontario, Canada Respiratory pathogens 60 Not stated 23–59 yrs Nasal (midturbinate) NP RT-PCR 10
Vargas (2016) New York, USA Respiratory pathogens 30 Home Children and adults Nasal Nasal Multiplex RT-PCR 12
Lautenbach (2009) Pennsylvania, USA Staphylococcus aureus 56 Hospital (inpatients) Children and adults Nasal and pharyngeal Nasal and pharyngeal Culture 10
van Cleef (2012) Netherlands Staphylococcus aureus 105 Hospital (staff) Adults Nasal and pharyngeal Nasal and pharyngeal Culture 11
a

HCW, health care worker; NAAT, nucleic acid amplification test; NP, nasopharyngeal; RT-PCR, reverse transcription PCR; qPCR, quantitative PCR; SARS-CoV-2, severe acute respiratory coronavirus 2; QUADAS, evidence-based tool for Quality Assessment of Diagnostic Accuracy Studies.