Table 1:
Extracted criteria of studies
| Criteria | Reference | |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Societal and political context | (42), (43), (44), (38), (15), (27), (11), (10), (45) |
| 2 | Commitment | (17), (46), (11), (47),(27),(48),(49),(16), |
| 3 | Boundary spanner leadership/direction | (11), (10), (45), (50), (51), (37),(27),(52), |
| (44),(4),(53),(42),(48),(49),(54) | ||
| 4 | Task management(balance between rols and activities) | (11), (10), (50), (37),(55),(15),(42),(49) |
| 5 | Structure of communication(formal and informal,…) | (11), (56), (45), (50), (47), (23),(27),(52),(44),(35),(48),(49),(57) |
| 6 | Education and capacity building | (11), (58), (50), (59), (47),(60), (61),(4),(7), (55) |
| 7 | Shared mission | (10), (37),(27),(44),(35),(15),(18) |
| 8 | Engaging various participants | (10), (62), (47), (20),(63), (64), (61), (37), (27),(65),(36),(44),(4),(42),(49),(66),(67) |
| 9 | Monitoring communication and result of participation | (68), (59), (52), (37), (10), (11), (27), (53), (4), |
| 10 | Trust building | (10), (11),(45), (62), (50),(63), (51), (27),(36),(57), |
| 11 | Shared vision | (50), (47), (69), (37), (27),(12),(44),(43),(35),(57) |
| 12 | Shared goals | (10), (45), (50), (37),(52),(36),(12),(44),(4),(26),(42),(49),(18),(70) |
| 13 | Considering common interest for contributor | (45), (62),(23), (37), (27),(4) |
| 14 | Considering value of actors | (20), (37),(67) |
| 15 | Responsiveness | (45), (47), (37), (27),(57) |
| 16 | Comprehensive support (political, organisational, motivational) | (11), (50), (59), (47), (24),(20), (64), (14),(27),(65),(71),(4),(32),(70),(66),(57),,(35) |
| 17 | Formal and legal agreement on collaboration | (50),(14), (60), (37),(71),(12) |
| 18 | Defenition of indicator | (45), (61), (37),(35) |
| 19 | Power | (10), (44),(43),(54) |
| 20 | Transparency and clarity in collaboration | (72), (37),(38),(54) |
| 21 | Time allocation | (59), (46),(52),(21) |
| 22 | Conflict resolution | (62), (50),(23), (37),(52),(21) |
| 23 | Planning and clear dicision making mechanism | (62), (50), (60), (37),(44),(53),(15),(67),(21) |
| 24 | Considering culture of actors | (20),(65),(38),(44),(48) |
| 25 | Efficiency | (69), (51),(54) |
| 26 | Apportunity for dialouge/create common language | (56),(61), (27),(36),(7), (70),(66) |
| 27 | Official committee in collaboration | (50),(60) |
| 28 | Financial and non-financial resources | (25), (24), (64),(46), (37), (27),(36),(4),(73),(7),(15),(49),(66),(65) |
| 29 | Use of local structure/media | (64), (27),(65),(4) |
| 30 | Sustainability, willngness to continue/positive experience | (50), (14), (23), (27),(44),(55),(49) |
| 31 | Sharing knowledge and information | (10), (62), (16), (24),(19), (61), (37), (27),(36),(44),(49),(59),(60) |
| 32 | Research | (64),(71) |