Table 1:
Summary of the included studies in the systematic review.
Study | Number | Study design | Primary malignancy | Pleurodesis agent | Percent success | HR of poor survival (95% CI) | Median survival (success vs. failure) | Factors controlled for in multi-variate analysis |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Viallat 1996 | 360 | Retrospective | Miscellaneous | Talc | 93 | UA | 7.6 vs. 2.6 months, p=0.001 | N/A |
Love 2003 | 60 | Retrospective | Miscellaneous | Talc | 47.6 | UA | 346 vs. 133 days, p=0.03 | N/A |
Kolschmann 2005 | 85 | Retrospective | Miscellaneous | Talc | 89.4 | UA | No difference in 180 days survival, p=0.44 | N/A |
Trotter 2005 | 202 | Retrospective | Miscellaneous | Talc | 88.1 | UA | 107 vs. 45 days, p=0.26 | N/A |
Stefani 2006 | 109 | Prospective | Miscellaneous | Talc | 83 | UA | 9.4, vs. 5.8 m, p=0.048 | N/A |
AK 2009 | 42 | Retrospective | Mesothelioma | Talc | 61.9 | 2.59 (1.20–5.61) | UA | Chemotherapy |
Nikbakhsh 2011 | 50 | Prospective | Miscellaneous | Bleomycin | 88 | UA | No difference in 180 days survival, p=0.57 | N/A |
Rena 2015 | 172 | Retrospective | Mesothelioma | Talc | 76 | 2.54 (1.73–4.40) | UA | Mesothelioma subtype, cancer stage, performance status, elevated serum CRP, elevated platelet count |
Hsu 2016 | 26 | Prospective | Lung & breast | Minocycline | 64 | UA | 220 vs. 112 days, p=0.015 | N/A |
Santos 2017 | 202 | Retrospective | Miscellaneous | Talc | 70.7 | UA | 400 vs. 170 days, p=0.01 | N/A |
Leemans 2018 | 155 | Retrospective | Miscellaneous | Talc | 78 | 1.92 (1.09–3.33) | 169 vs. 66 days, p=0.02 | N/A |
Hsu 2019a | 205 | Retrospective | Miscellaneous | Minocycline | 69 | 3.70 (2.43–5.55) | 414 vs. 100 days, p<0.001 | Performance status, extrapleural metastasis |
Hsu 2019b | 109 | Retrospective | Miscellaneous | Minocycline | 70.5 | 2.67 (1.66–4.34) | 259 vs. 102 days, p<0.001 | Performance status, extrapleural metastasis |
Hassan 2019a | 266 | RCT | Miscellaneous | Talc | 78 | 1.62 (1.09–2.34) | 12 vs. 7.3 months, p=0.004 | Primary malignancy, unexpandable lung |
Hassan 2019b | 60 | Retrospective | Miscellaneous | Talc | 48 | 2.85 (1.08–7.50) | 16 vs. 5 months, p=0.007 | Primary malignancy, systemic therapy, LDH level, unexpandable lung |
HR, hazard ratio; CI, confidence interval; UA, unavailable; N/A, not applicable; RCT, randomised controlled trial.