Table 1.
Reference number/criteria | 11 | 12 | 10 |
---|---|---|---|
1 Title | Yes | Yes | Yes |
2 Abstract | Yes | Yes | Yes |
3 Background and objectives | Yes | Yes | Yes |
4 Target population and subgroups | Yes | Yes | Yes |
5 Setting and location | Yes | Yes | Yes |
6 Study perspective | Yes | Yes | Yes |
7 Comparators | Yes | Yes | Yes |
8 Time horizon | No | Yes | Yes |
9 Discount rate | No | No | Yes |
10 Choice of health outcomes | Yes | No | Yes |
11a Measurement of effectiveness | Yes | Yes | Yes |
11b Measurement of effectiveness | NA | NA | NA |
12 Measurement and valuation of preference based outcomes | No | NA | NA |
13a Estimating resources and costs | Yes | Yes | Yes |
13b Estimating resources and costs | NA | NA | NA |
14 Currency, price date, and conversion | No | No | Yes |
15 Choice of model | No | No | Yes |
16 Assumptions | No | No | Yes |
17 Analytical methods | No | No | Yes |
18 Study parameters | Yes | Yes | Yes |
19 Incremental costs and outcomes | Yes | No | No |
20a Characterizing uncertainty | No | Yes | Yes |
20b Characterizing uncertainty | No | No | No |
21 Characterizing heterogeneity | No | No | NA |
22 Study findings, limitations, generalizability, and current knowledge | Yes | Yes | Yes |
23 Source of funding | No | Yes | Yes |
24 Conflicts of interest | No | Yes | Yes |
NA=Not available