Skip to main content
. 2021 Jun 24;16(6):e0253053. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0253053

Table 2. Adolescent and adult musical engagement and memory decline.

Outcome: Episodic Memory MODEL 1: HSME*TIME MODEL 2: MEA*TIME MODEL 3: Music*TIME
Effect Estimate STE p—Value Estimate STE p—Value Estimate STE p—Value
Intercept 9.950 0.058 < .0001 10.118 0.060 < .0001 9.924 0.069 <0.001
Time -1.240 0.070 < .0001 -1.273 0.072 < .0001 -1.183 0.084 <0.001
HSME (None) Reference Reference
HSME (Moderate) 0.583 0.102 < .0001 0.498 0.113 <0.001
HSME (High) 1.112 0.164 < .0001 0.958 0.183 <0.001
HSME (Moderate * Time) -0.203 0.123 0.100 -0.235 0.138 0.088
HSME (High *Time) -0.358 0.196 0.068 -0.414 0.219 0.058
MEA (None) Reference Reference
MEA (Intermittently) 0.682 0.134 < .0001 0.551 0.135 <0.001
MEA (Continuously) 1.139 0.171 < .0001 0.921 0.175 <0.001
MEA * Time (Intermittently) -0.167 0.161 0.299 -0.109 0.163 0.502
MEA * Time (Continuous) -0.249 0.206 0.225 -0.153 0.210 0.468
Covariance Parameters Estimate STE p Estimate STE p Estimate STE p
Between Subjects 0.008 0.182 < .0001 3.808 0.195 < .0001 3.749 0.194 <0.001
Residual 6.927 0.155 < .0001 6.818 0.168 < .0001 6.815 0.168 <0.001

Results from 3 simple linear mixed models are presented, including HSME * Time (Model 1), MEA * Time (Model 2), and all music variables by time (Model 3).

STE = Standard error; HSME = High School Music Engagement; MEA = Music Engagement as an Adult. Bolded model parameters indicate significance.