Table 1.
Study ID | Intervention & Comparator | Duration of Intervention | Description of Participants | Trial Period | Country, Place | Setting | Ethnic Groups (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Prakash 2016 [38] |
I: T. arjuna | 12 weeks | Age < 20 years, total cholesterol ≥ 200 mg/dL, LDL-C ≥ 130 mg/dL | - | India | Outpatient clinic of university hospital | - |
C: Rosuvastatin | - | ||||||
Farzaneh 2014 [39] |
I: N. sativa | 8 weeks | Adult overweight females with sedentary lifestyle and total cholesterol > 200 mg/dL | - | Iran | University clinic | - |
C: Placebo | - | ||||||
Rathi 2013 [40] |
I: Rasonadi leha + Hridroghar churna + Usual care | 3 months | Patients of post MI attending private hospital of Betul, Madhya Pradesh, India | - | India | Hospital | - |
C: Usual care | - | ||||||
Devra 2012 [41] |
I: Tulsi extract | 3 months | Patients of metabolic syndrome | - | India | Hospital | |
C: Placebo | |||||||
Huseini 2012 [42] |
I: Aloe | 2 months | Patients with type 2 diabetes and hyperlipidemia | - | Iran | Outpatient clinic | - |
C: Placebo | - | ||||||
Joseph 2012 [43] |
I: Amla + Fenugreek | 12 weeks | Patients of hypercholesterolemia with total cholesterol > 220 mg/dL | - | - | Outpatient department of tertiary teaching hospital | - |
C: Atorvastatin | - | ||||||
Sabzghabaee 2012 [44] | I. N. sativa | 4 weeks | Patients with toral cholesterol > 200 mg/dL | July 2010–June 2011 | Iran | Outpatient clinics of University hospital | - |
C: Placebp | - | ||||||
Sharma 2012 [45] |
I: Lashunadi guggulu | 45 days | Clinically diagnosed and confirmed patients of stable angina from out and in-patient departments of two hospitals of Jaipur, India | 2002–2004 | India | University hospital | - |
C: Placebo | - | ||||||
Sobenin 2010 [46] |
I: Allicor | 12 months | Patients with documented CHD, 40–65 years age and s. cholesterol level > 200 mg/dL | - | Russia | Probably research center | - |
C: Placebo | - | ||||||
Nohr 2009 [47] |
I: Guggulu formula | 12 (weeks) | Patients from Norwegian general practice who are not taking any prescriptions for hypercholesterolemia, CHD, DM | Feb–May 2003 | Oppland and Hedemark counties of Norway | General practice | Native Norwegians |
C: Placebo | Native Norwegians | ||||||
Qidwai 2009 [48] |
I: N. sativa | 6 weeks | Patients with total cholesterol level > 180 to 250 mg/dL | Feb 2006–Jan 2007 | Pakistan | Outpatient clinics at university hospital | Pakistani |
C: Placebo | Pakistani | ||||||
Alizadeh-Navaei 2008 [49] | I: Ginger | 45 days | Patients of hyperlipidemia with cholesterol > 200 mg/dL or Triglyceride > 200 mg/dL | April 2004–May 2005 | Babol, Iran | Cardiac clinic | - |
C: Placebo | - | ||||||
Sobenin 2008 [50] |
I: Allicor | 12 weeks | Men with mild hypercholesterolemia | - | Moscow, Russia | Research center | - |
C: Placebo | - | ||||||
Gardner 2007 a [51] |
I: Raw Garlic | 6 months | Adults with LDL-C 130–190 mg/dL | Nov 2002–June 2005 | USA | University hospital clinic | White (73) Black (4) Asian (18) Hispanic (2) |
C: Placebo | White (64) Asian (14) Hispanic (4) |
||||||
Gardner 2007 b [51] |
I: Garlic in tablets | 6 months | Adults with LDL-C 130–190 mg/dL | Nov 2002–June 2005 | USA | University hospital clinic | White (66) Black (4) Asian (21) Hispanic (6) |
C: Placebo | White (64) Asian (14) Hispanic (4) |
||||||
Ashraf 2005 [52] |
I: Garlic | 12 weeks | Type 2 diabetes mellitus patients with newly diagnosed hyperlipidaemia | - | Karachi, Pakistan | University hospital | - |
C: Placebo | - | ||||||
Tanamai 2004 [53] |
I: Garlic | 9 months | Hypercholesterolemia | - | Bangkok, Thailand | Hospital | Thai |
C: Placebo | Thai | ||||||
Satitvipawee 2003 [54] | I: Garlic | 12 weeks | Hypercholesterolemia | - | Thailand | Study center | - |
C: Placebo | - | ||||||
Szapary 2003 [21] | I: Guggulipid | 8 (weeks) | Ambulatory, community-dwelling, healthy adults with hypercholesterolaemia | March 2000–August 2001 | Philadelphia, Pa, metropolitan area | University hospital | White (85) |
C: Placebo | White (75) | ||||||
Venkataramaiah 2002 [55] | I: Abana | 8 weeks | Patients with total cholesterol > 200 mg/dL or triglycerides > 200 mg/dL | - | - | - | - |
C: Simvastatin | - | ||||||
Kannar 2001 [56] |
I: Garlic | 12 weeks | Volunteers who failed to comply with previous lipid-lowering therapies | - | Victoria, Australia | University clinic | - |
C: Placebo | - | ||||||
Gardner 2001 [57] |
I: Garlic | 12 weeks | General public and employees of Stanford University | June–October, 1997 | Stanford University, Palo Alto, CA | University hospital | - |
C: Placebo | - | ||||||
- | |||||||
Adler 1997 [58] |
I: Garlic | 12 weeks | Men with elevated T. cholesterol level > 5.2 mmol/L (200 mg/dL) | - | Guelph, Ontario, Canada | University hospital/clinic | - |
C: Placebo | - | ||||||
Awasthi 1997 [59] | I: Lashunadi guggulu | 2 months | Patients of chronic stbale angina from two hospitals in Jaipur | - | Jaipur, India | University hospital | - |
C: Placebo | - | ||||||
Gaur 1997 [60] | I: Gugulipid and usual care | 4/4 (weeks) | Patients of ischaemic stroke | - | India | - | - |
C: Usual care | - | ||||||
Singh 1994 [61] | I: Gugguluipid | 24 weeks | Patients with hypercholesterolaemia with s. cholesterol level > 200 mg/dL | - | India | - | White (70) Black (30) |
C: Placebo | White (68) Black (32) |
||||||
Jain 1993 [62] | I: Garlic | 12 weeks | Patients with s. total cholesterol level > 220 mg/dL | - | USA | Outptient clinic | - |
C: Placebo | - | ||||||
Tiwari 1991 [63] |
I: Abana | 6 months | Diagnosed cases of hypertension and Angina pectoris | - | India | University hospital | - |
C: Propanlol | - | ||||||
Mader 1990 [64] |
I: Garlic | 4 months | Patients of hyperlipidaemia from 30 different practices in Germany | - | Germany | General practice | - |
C: Placebo | |||||||
Nityanand 1989 [65] |
I: Gugguluipid | 12 weeks | Patients with s. cholesterol levels > 220 mg/dL | - | India | - | |
C: Clofibrate | - | ||||||
Verma 1988 [66] |
I: Guggulu | 16 weeks | Patients of hyperlipidaemia between age 40–60 years Type IIa or IIb of Frederichsons classification of hyperlipidemia |
- | India | University hospital | - |
C: Placebo | - | ||||||
Kotiyal 1984 [67] |
I: Guggulu | 12 weeks | Patients with features of obesity, 10% overweight for one’s height, age, and sex | - | India | Medical OPD of a hospital | - |
C: Placebo | - | ||||||
Kuppurajan 1978 [68] | I: Guggulu | 3 weeks | Patients with s. cholesterol > 300 mg/dL or total lipids > 750 mg/dL | - | India | - | - |
C: Placebo | - |