Table 2.
Factor | Compounds Used in the Study | Effect on Hormone Levels | Number of Participants | Reference | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Chemicals | Polychlorinated biphenyls and polybrominated biphenyls | PBB | TSH, ↓fT4, ↑fT3, ↑tT3, ↑fT3/fT4 | 715 | [349] | |
PCB | TSH, ↑fT4, fT3, ↑fT3/fT4 | |||||
PCBs and hydroxylated PCBs | TSH, fT4, tT4, fT3, tT3 | 79 | [348] | |||
PCB | TSH, ↑fT4, ↑tT4, ↑fT3, ↑tT3 | 551 | [347] | |||
PCB | TSH, ↓fT4, ↓fT3 | 122 | [346] | |||
PCB | TSH, ↓fT4, ↑tT4, tT3 | 87 | [345] | |||
PCB | ↓TSH, ↑fT4, ↑tT4, ↑fT3, ↑tT3 | 67 | [353] | |||
PCB | ↓tT3 | 114 | [435] | |||
PCB x BDE | ↑tT3 | |||||
PCB | TSH, fT4, ↓tT3 | 623 | [344] | |||
PCB | ↑TSH, ↓T4, ↓T3 | 211 | [351] | |||
PCB | ↑TSH, ↓fT4, tT4, tT3 | 232 | [423] | |||
PCB | TSH, ↑fT4, ↑tT3 | 2042 | [484] | |||
PCB | TSH, fT4, ↓tT3 | 341 | [343] | |||
PCB | TSH, ↑fT4 | 2045 | [422] | |||
PCB | ↓tT4 | 2445 | [356] | |||
Dioxin-like toxic equivalents | ↑TSH, ↓tT4 | |||||
PCB | ↓TSH | 454 | [418] | |||
PCB | TSH, fT4 | 196 | [341] | |||
PCB | ↓TSH, ↓tT4, ↓tT3 | 66 | [352] | |||
Dioxin-like toxic equivalents | ↓TSH | |||||
PCB | TSH, fT4, tT4, fT3, tT3 | 110 | [354] | |||
PCB | TSH, fT4, tT4, fT3, ↓tT3 | 182 | [339] | |||
PCB | ↓T4 | 229 | [355] | |||
PCB | TSH, fT4, tT4 | 192 | [421] | |||
PCB | TSH, fT4, tT4, fT3 | 173 | [340] | |||
PCB | tT4 | 111 | [350] | |||
Polybrominated diphenyl ethers | PBDE | ↑TSH, fT4, tT4, ↑fT3, ↓tT3 | 85 | [362] | ||
PBDE | TSH, fT4, ↑tT4, fT3, ↑tT3 | 79 | [348] | |||
PBDE | TSH, fT4, ↓tT4, tT3 | 52 | [361] | |||
PBDE | TSH, fT4, ↑tT3 | 623 | [344] | |||
PBDE | ↑TSH | 49 | [363] | |||
PBDE | TSH, fT4, tT4, tT3 | 36 | [360] | |||
PBDE | ↓TSH, ↑tT4, ↓tT3, ↑rT3 | 308 | [364] | |||
PBDE (BDE-47) | ↓TSH, tT4, fT4, tT3, fT3 | 110 | [354] | |||
Bisphenol A | BPA | TSH, tT4, ↑tT3 | 90 | [368] | ||
BPA | ↓TSH, tT4, tT3 | 6003 | [372] | |||
BPA | ↑TSH, fT4 | 194 | [370] | |||
BPA | TSH, ↓fT4 | 2340 | [367] | |||
BPA | ↓TSH, fT4, ↑fT3 | 3394 | [371] | |||
BPA | TSH, fT4, tT4, tT3, Tg | 1346 | [369] | |||
BPA | ↓TSH, fT4, tT3 | 167 | [373] | |||
Phthalates | DEHP metabolites and MEHHP | ↓tT4 | Meta-analysis (included studies on pregnant women and children) | [382] | ||
MEOHP | ↓fT4 | |||||
MEHHP, DEHP metabolite | TSH, fT4, ↓T4, T3 | 279 | [379] | |||
MEHP, MEOHP | TSH, ↓fT4, T4, T3 | |||||
Monoethyl phthalate | TSH, ↑fT4, T4, T3 | |||||
MEOHP | ↑TSH, tT4, tT3 | 6003 | [372] | |||
DEHP metabolites | TSH, ↓tT4, tT3 | |||||
MnBP | TSH, tT4, ↓tT3 | |||||
MnBP | ↑TSH, fT4 | 43 (all subjects) | [380] | |||
MnBP, 5Cx-MEP, 5Oxo-MEHP, MBzP | ↑TSH, fT4 | 30 (women) | ||||
MEHHP | ↓tT4 | 1877 (all subjects) | [381] | |||
MEOHP | ↑tT4 | 907 (women) | ||||
DEHP | ↑TSH, ↓fT4, ↓tT4, ↓tT3, ↓Tg | 1346 | [369] | |||
MEHP | TSH, ↓fT4, ↓tT3 | 408 | [378] | |||
Perchlorate | Perchlorate | TSH, ↓fT4 | 2702 | [388] | ||
↓fT4 | 564 | [387] | ||||
TSH, ↓fT4, ↓tT4 | 4023 | [386] | ||||
↓fT4, ↓tT4, ↓fT3, tT3 | 1877 | [381] | ||||
↑TSH, ↓tT4 | 1111 | [385] | ||||
Perfluoroalkyl substances | PFAS | TSH, fT4, fT3 | 3297 | [399] | ||
PFOS, PFNA, PFAS, PFHxS | TSH, ↑fT4, tT4, fT3, tT3 | 1325 | [400] | |||
PFOA | TSH, ↓tT4, ↓fT4, tT3 | 3070 | [398] | |||
PFOS | TSH, ↓tT4, fT4, tT3 | |||||
PFNA, PFDeA | ↓TSH, tT4, fT4, tT3 | |||||
PFOA, PFNA | ↑TSH, tT4, fT4, tT3, fT3 | 85 | [406] | |||
PFNA | ↑tT3, ↑fT3 | 47 (women) | ||||
PFNA | ↓tT3, ↓fT3 | 38 (men) | ||||
PFOS | ↑fT3 | 47 (women) | ||||
PFOS | ↓fT3 | 38 (men) | ||||
PFOS | ↑TSH, ↓tT4, ↑fT4, ↓tT3 | Meta-analysis (including pregnant women) | [401] | |||
PFOA | TSH, ↓tT4, tT3 | |||||
PFNA | TSH, T4, ↑fT4, ↑T3 | 99 | [397] | |||
PFOA | TSH, T4, fT4, ↑T3 | |||||
PFOA | TSH, fT4, tT4, tT3, ↑fT3 | 1012 | [396] | |||
PFOS | TSH, ↑fT4, ↑tT4, tT3 | 87 | [345] | |||
PFOS, PFNA | ↓TSH, tT4, fT4, tT3, fT3 | 158 (male adolescents) | [402] | |||
PFOA | ↓TSH, tT4, fT4, tT3, fT3 | 145 (female adolescents) | ||||
PFOA, PFOS, PFNA | TSH, tT4, ↑fT4, tT3, fT3 | 257 (women 20-40 years old) | ||||
PFOA | TSH, tT4, fT4, ↑tT3, ↑fT3 | 199 (women 60-80 years old) | ||||
PFNA | TSH, ↑fT4 | 567 | [403] | |||
PFOA | ↑TSH, tT4, fT4, ↑tT3, fT3, Tg | 1540 | [254] | |||
PFHxS | TSH, ↑tT4, fT4, tT3, fT3, Tg | |||||
PFOA | TSH, tT4, fT4, ↑tT3, fT3 | 509 (women) | [395] | |||
PFHxS | TSH, ↑tT4, fT4, ↑tT3, fT3 | 509 (women) | ||||
TSH, tT4, ↓fT4, tT3, fT3 | 672 (men) | |||||
PFTrDA | ↑TSH, ↓tT4 | 633 | [405] | |||
PFOS, PFOA | TSH, ↑tT4 | 50,113 | [394] | |||
PFC | TSH, fT4 | 31 | [393] | |||
PFOS | ↓TSH, ↑fT4, ↓tT3 | 623 | [344] | |||
PFOA | TSH, ↓fT4, T4, ↑T3 | 506 | [392] | |||
PFOA | TSH | 371 | [391] | |||
PFOS | TSH, fT4, T4, ↑T3 | 255 | [404] | |||
Pesticides | Conventional farmers that use insecticides, herbicides and fungicides in comparison to organic farmers | ↑TSH, ↓fT4, ↑T4, ↑fT3, ↑T3 | 438 | [410] | ||
Organophosphate insecticides | TSH, fT4, tT4, fT3, tT3 | 41 | [432] | |||
Rural workers exposed to pesticides in comparison to controls | ↓TSH, ↑fT4, ↑tT3 | 73 | [420] | |||
3-PBA (metabolite of pyrethroid insecticide) | TSH, ↓tT4, ↓tT3 | 6208 | [429] | |||
Insecticides and pyrethroids for >20 years | ↓fT4, ↓tT3 | 106 | [436] | |||
TCPY (a metabolite of chlorpyrifos) | TSH, ↓tT4, fT4, tT3, fT3, ↓Tg | 2015 | [427] | |||
Mancozeb (fungicide) | TSH, fT4, ↓T4, ↑fT3, T3, ↓Tg | 63 | [428] | |||
3-PBA | TSH, fT4, tT4, fT3, tT3, Tg | 2015 | [430] | |||
p,p′-DDE (a stable metabolite of DDT) | TSH, ↑tT4, ↑tT3 | 136 | [434] | |||
Pesticide sprayers exposed to organophosphate and organochlorine pesticides | ↑TSH, T4, ↓T3 | 60 | [417] | |||
DDT+DDE | ↑tT4, ↑tT3 | 48 (women) | [435] | |||
DDT+DDE + PCB | ↑tT4 | |||||
DDT+DDE + PCB | ↓tT3 | 66 (men) | ||||
Exposure to organophosphate and carbamate pesticides | TSH, fT4 | 99 | [425] | |||
High exposure pesticide season | TSH, ↓fT4, tT3 | 91 | [426] | |||
HCH | ↑TSH, ↓fT4 | 303 (men) | [416] | |||
HCB, heptachlor, o,p′-DDT and p,p′-DDT | ↑fT4 | 305 (women) | ||||
Endosulphan 2 | ↓tT3 | 303 (men) | ||||
Alpha-chlordane, p,p′- DDT, endosulphan 2 and methoxychlor | ↑tT3 | 305 (women) | ||||
TCPY (a metabolite of chlorpyrifos) | ↓TSH, ↑tT4 | 1589 (men) | [415] | |||
↑TSH | 218 (women) | |||||
Insecticide fipronil sulfone metabolite | ↓TSH, fT4, tT4 | 155 | [419] | |||
DAP | ↑TSH, ↑tT4 | 215 | [414] | |||
DMP | ↑TSH, ↑tT4, ↓tT3 | |||||
Organochlorine pesticides | ↓tT3 | 623 | [344] | |||
Hexachlorobenzene | ↓fT4 | |||||
cis-DCCA (pyrethroid metabolite) | TSH, fT4, tT3 | 161 | [424] | |||
3-PBA and trans-DCCA (pyrethroid metabolites) | TSH, fT4, tT3 | |||||
HCB | TSH, fT4, ↓tT4, tT3 | 232 | [423] | |||
DDE | TSH, ↓fT4, ↑tT3 | 2045 | [422] | |||
HCB | ↑TSH, ↓fT4, tT3 | |||||
p,p′-DDE | ↓TSH, ↑fT4, ↑tT3 | 341 | [343] | |||
HCB | ↓tT3 | |||||
p,p′-DDE | TSH, tT4 | 2445 | [356] | |||
PCB + DDE + HCB | ↓TSH | 454 | [418] | |||
DDE | TSH, tT4, tT3 | 66 | [352] | |||
p,p′-DDE | ↑TSH, fT4 | 196 | [341] | |||
High exposure pesticide season | TSH, ↓fT4, fT3, tT3 | 122 | [433] | |||
In the fall in comparison to the spring season (people are exposed to higher levels of pesticides in fall) | ↓TSH, ↑fT4, ↑fT3, ↑tT3 | |||||
TCPY (a metabolite of chlorpyrifos) | ↑TSH, fT4, tT3 | 322 | [413] | |||
1N (a metabolite of carbaryl and naphthalene) | TSH, fT4, tT3 | |||||
EBDC fungicides | TSH | 131 | [431] | |||
HCB | T4 | 66 | [485] | |||
High exposure pesticide season | ↑TSH, ↑fT4, ↑tT4 | 193 | [412] | |||
DDT, HCB | ↓T3 | 16 | [438] | |||
DDE | TSH, T4, T3 | 51 | [355] | |||
HCB | TSH, fT4, ↓tT4 | 192 | [421] | |||
Exposure to organophosphates and organochlorine pesticides | TSH, T4, ↓T3 | 50 | [437] | |||
EBDC fungicides | ↑TSH, T4 | 94 | [411] | |||
Nitrate | Nitrate | T4, T3 | 30 | [445] | ||
↑TSH, fT4 | 41 | [443] | ||||
↓fT4 | 307 | [387] | ||||
TSH, ↓tT4 | 1111 | [385] | ||||
TSH, T4, T3 | 20 | [444] | ||||
↓TSH, ↑T4 | 60 | [442] | ||||
Heavy metals | Studies determining multiple metals | Pb, Cd, As | TSH | 102 | [454] | |
Pb | ↑TSH, fT4, fT3 | 100 | [460] | |||
Cd | TSH, fT4, fT3 | |||||
Pb | ↑TSH, tT4, tT3 | 5628 | [461] | |||
Cd | TSH, tT4, tT3 | |||||
Cd | TSH, fT4, tT4, fT3, tT3, Tg | 1391 | [459] | |||
Pb | TSH, fT4, tT4, fT3, tT3, Tg | |||||
Cd | TSH, ↑fT4, tT4, fT3, tT3, ↑Tg | 6231 (all subjects) | [458] | |||
TSH, fT4, tT4, fT3, ↑tT3, ↑Tg | 3231 (men) | |||||
Pb | TSH, fT4, tT4, ↑fT3, tT3, Tg | 6231 (all subjects) | ||||
TSH, fT4, ↓tT4, fT3, tT3, Tg | 3231 (men) | |||||
TSH, ↑fT4, tT4, fT3, tT3, Tg | 3000 (women) | |||||
Hg | TSH, fT4, ↓tT4, ↓fT3, ↓tT3, Tg | 4409 | [457] | |||
Cd | TSH, fT4, ↑tT4, ↑fT3, ↑tT3, ↑Tg | |||||
Pb | TSH, fT4, tT4, fT3, tT3, Tg | |||||
Hg | TSH, fT4, ↓T4, ↓fT3, ↓T3 | 1587 | [456] | |||
Cd | ↓TSH, ↑fT4, ↑T4, ↑fT3, ↑T3 | |||||
Pb | ↓TSH | 219 | [318] | |||
As | ↑TSH | |||||
Hg, Cd | TSH | |||||
Pb | ↓TSH, T4, ↑T3 | 211 | [351] | |||
Hg | ↑TSH, T4, T3 | |||||
Pb | TSH, fT4, tT4, ↑T3 | 232 | [423] | |||
Hg | TSH, fT4, tT4, T3 | |||||
Studies determining single metal | Arsenic | UDMA | ↑TSH, ↓fT4, ↓tT4, fT3, tT3, Tg | 4126 | [453] | |
UAAS | TSH, fT4, ↓tT4, fT3, tT3, Tg | |||||
UAS, UAB | ↓TSH, fT4, tT4, fT3, tT3, ↓Tg | |||||
↑TSH, fT4, fT3 | 38 | [452] | ||||
↑TSH, ↓fT4, ↓fT3, ↑Tg | 185 | [451] | ||||
Cadmium | TSH, ↓fT4 | 1972 | [463] | |||
TSH, ↑fT4, ↑fT3 | 1724 | [462] | ||||
↑TSH, ↓fT4, ↓fT3 | 277 | [455] | ||||
↓fT4, ↑tT3 | 105 | [464] | ||||
Mercury | ↑TSH, ↑fT4, ↓T4, fT3, T3 | Meta-analysis | [480] | |||
↑TSH, fT4, fT3, tT3 | 110 | [479] | ||||
TSH, ↓T4, ↓T3 | 137 | [482] | ||||
TSH, ↑fT4, ↓fT3, ↑fT4/fT3 | 82 | [481] | ||||
↑rT3, ↑fT4/fT3 | 94 | [483] | ||||
Lead | ↓TSH, ↑fT4, ↑fT3 | 87 | [468] | |||
TSH, fT4, T4, fT3, T3 | Meta-analysis | [475] | ||||
TSH, T4, T3 | 195 | [474] | ||||
T4, ↓fT4 | 220 | [478] | ||||
↑T3, ↑T4 | 76 | [477] | ||||
↑TSH | 125 | [467] | ||||
TSH, ↓fT4, fT3 | 97 | [473] | ||||
TSH, fT4, T4, ↓fT3, ↓T3 | 157 | [472] | ||||
TSH, fT4, fT3 | 103 | [471] | ||||
↑TSH, fT4, ↓T4, ↓T3 | 75 | [465] | ||||
↑TSH, fT4, fT3 | 93 | [466] | ||||
TSH, ↑fT4, ↑tT4, ↑fT3, tT3 | 57 | [476] | ||||
TSH, T4 | 151 | [469] | ||||
TSH, ↓fT4, ↓tT4, tT3 | 176 | [470] |
Studies in pregnant women, infants, kids and individuals with a history of thyroid diseases were not included in this table. 1N, 1-naphthol; 3-PBA, phenoxybenzoic acid; 5Cx-MEP, mono-ethyl phthalate; 5Oxo-MEHP, mono-(2-ethylhexyl) phthalate; As, arsenic; BPA, bisphenol-A; Cd, cadmium; DAP, dialkylphosphate; cis and trans-DCCA, cis and trans-3-2,2-dichlorovinyl-2,2-dimethylcyclopropane carboxylic acid; DDE, p,p′-diphenyldichloroethene; DDT, p,p′-dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethane; DEHP, di-(2-ethylhexyl) phthalate; DMP, dimethyl metabolites; EBDC, ethylene bisdithiocarbamates; fT3, free triiodothyronine; fT4, free thyroxine; HCB, hexachlorobenzene; HCH, beta-hexachlorocyclohexane; Hg, mercury; MBzP, mono-benzyl phthalate; MEHP, mono(2-ethylhexyl) phthalate; MEHHP, mono (2-ethyl-5-hydroxyhexyl) phthalate; MEOHP, mono-(2-ethyl-5-oxohexyl) phthalate; MnBP, mono-n-butyl phthalate; PBB, polybrominated biphenyls; PBDE, polybrominated diphenyl ethers; PCB, polychlorinated biphenyls; PFAS, perfluoroalkyl substances; PFC, perfluorinated compounds; PFDeA, perfluorodecanoate; PFHxS, perfluorohexane sulfonate; PFNA, perfluorononanoic acid; PFOA, perfluorooctanoic acid; PFOS, perfluorooctane sulfonic acid; PFTrDA; perfluorotridecanoic acid; rT3, reverse triiodothyronine; T3, triiodothyronine; T4, thyroxine; tT3, total T3; tT4, total T4; TCPY, trichloro-2-pyridinol; Tg, thyroglobulin; TSH, thyroid-stimulating hormone; UAAS, arsenic adjusted for arsenobetaine; UAB, arsenobetaine; UAS, total arsenic; UDMA, dimethylarsinic acid.