4. Measurement of symptomatic urinary tract infection.
TrialID | Outcome as defined by trial authors | Trial definition | Relevant definition outlined by International Guideline Panel |
Ahmed 2014 | Symptomatic UTI | Significant bacteriuria with at least one of the following symptoms: dysuria, frequency of micturition, urgency, suprapubic pain ir burning sensation at micturition |
CDC |
Alessandri 2006 | UTI | Significant bacteria which is determined by: urine culture and defined as at least 105 cfu/mL | EAU: symptomatic bacteriuria |
Allen 2016 | UTI | Not reported | N/A |
Alonzo‐Sosa 1997 | UTI | Defined as a positive urine sample associated with: dysuria, polyuria, incomplete emptying, pain, fever or sepsis. A positive urine sample was defined as the presence of > 105 cfu/mL if MSU and 104 cfu/mL in a catheter sample. |
CDC |
Aref 2020 | Symptomatic UTI | “The diagnosis of symptomatic urinary tract infection was based on the following criteria: significant bacteriuria with at least one of the following symptoms; dysuria, frequency of micturition, urgency, supra pubic pain, or burning sensation at micturition.” | CDC |
Aslam 2019 | UTI | Not reported | N/A |
Azarkish 2003 | UTI | Not reported | N/A |
Azarkish 2005 | Not reported | Not reported | N/A |
Barone 2015 | UTI | Not reported | N/A |
Basbug 2020 | Significant bacteruria | Significant microscopic bacteriuria was defined as ≥ 100,000 bacteria/ mL MSU | EAU: asymptomatic bacteriuria |
Benoist 1999 | UTI | Culture yield of > 105 cfu/mL with or without symptoms | With symptoms: CDC Without symptoms: EAU definition for "Asymptomatic bacteriuria" |
Bristoll 1989 | Not reported | Not reported | N/A |
Carpiniello 1988 | UTI | Culture yield of 105 cfu/mL | EAU: asymptomatic bacteriuria |
Carter‐Brooks 2018 | UTI | Defined as a positive culture or symptoms and antibiotic treatment | N/A |
Chai 2011 | Symptomatic UTI | Positive urine culture: > 105 cfu/mL of an identified single uropathogen/mL of urine Symptomatic UTI: fever (> 38 °C) and dysuria with a positive urine culture |
CDC |
Chen 2013 | CAUTI | CDC criteria used to define symptomatic UTI and asymptomatic bacteriuria | CDC |
Chia 2009 | CAUTI | Not reported | N/A |
Chillington 1992 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Cornia 2003 | CAUTI | Growth from a urine specimen aseptically aspirated from the catheter of ≥ 100 cfu of a predominant pathogen OR ≥ 10 leukocytes per high‐power field on urinalysis in a patient with a clinical diagnosis of UTI | N/A |
Coyle 2015 | Bacteriuria | Symptomatic or asymptomatic bacteriuria used. No definition given | N/A |
Crowe 1993 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Dunn 1999 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Dunn 2000b | UTI | Not reported | N/A |
Dunn 2003 | UTI | Determined by either microscopic abnormality or any patient symptoms | N/A |
Durrani 2014 | UTI | Not reported | N/A |
El‐Mazny 2014 | Significant bacteriuria | Significant bacteriuria: > 105 cfu/mL of urine in a MSU sample collected 24 h post‐op | EAU: asymptomatic bacteriuria |
Ganta 2005 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Glavind 2007 | Positive urine culture | Defined as the presence of ≥ 105 cfu/mL | EAU: asymptomatic bacteriuria |
Gong 2017 | Symptomatic UTI | Defined as bacteriuria with fever, frequent or painful urination or burning on urination | CDC |
Gross 2007 | UTI | Used CDC criteria | CDC |
Gungor 2014 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Guzman 1994 | UTI | Urine culture of > 105 cfu/mL reported as outcome. Definition is not provided | EAU: asymptomatic bacteriuria |
Hakvoort 2004 | UTI | Signs of UTI: having > 10 WBC/high‐powered field and significant microscopic bacteriuria (1/high‐powered field) in the urine sediment UTI: presence of > 105 cfu/mL in urine culture |
EAU: asymptomatic bacteriuria |
Hall 1998 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Han 1997 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Hewitt 2001 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Huang 2011 | UTI | Not reported | N/A |
Ind 1993 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Irani 1995 | UTI | Not reported | N/A |
Iversen Hansen 1984 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Jang 2012 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Jeong 2014 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Joshi 2014 | Symptomatic UTI | Symptomatic UTI: based on the presence of significant bacteriuria accompanied by at least 1 of the following symptoms: fever, dysuria, increased frequency of micturition, urinary urgency, suprapubic pain and dysuria | CDC |
Jun 2011 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Kamilya 2010 | Symptomatic UTI | Symptomatic UTI: positive urine culture of > 105 cfu/mL plus 1 of the following symptoms: dysuria, fever (> 38 °C) or rigors | CDC |
Kelleher 2002 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Kim 2012 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Koh 1994 | UTI | Not reported | N/A |
Kokabi 2009 | UTI | Not reported | N/A |
Lang 2020 | UTI | Not reported | N/A |
Lau 2004 | Positive urine culture | Not reported | N/A |
Li 2014 | Infection | Not reported | N/A |
Liang 2009 | UTI | UTI: positive urine culture of > 105 cfu/mL. However, treatment was only given for positive urine cultures if participant had adverse urinary symptoms or post‐op pyrexia (> 38 °C) | CDC |
Lista 2020 | UTI | Not reported | N/A |
Liu 2015 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Lyth 1997 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Mao 1994 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Matsushima 2015 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
McDonald 1999 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Naguimbing‐Cuaresma 2007 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Nathan 2001 | Positive catheter specimen urine (CSU) | Not reported | N/A |
Nguyen 2012 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Nielson 1985 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Noble 1990 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Nyman 2010 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Oberst 1981 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Onile 2008 | Significant bacteriuria | Significant bacteriuria: positive urine culture of > 105 cfu/mL in a sample of MSU collected 72 h post‐op with signs of a fever ( a temperature of > 38 °C on 2 occasions within 10 days of the procedure, excluding the first 24 h) | CDC |
Ouladsahebmadarek 2012 | Symptomatic UTI | Not reported | N/A |
Pervaiz 2019 | UTI | Urine sample was obtained to assess UTI (bacterial colony count > 105 cfu/mL on urine culture after removal of catheter assessed on day 7) | EAU: catheter‐associated asymptomatic bacteriuria |
Popiel 2017 | UTI | Not reported | N/A |
Rajan 2017 | UTI | Urinary infections defined as when microscopic examination of the urine revealed pus cells or when urine culture showed growth of pathogenic organisms | N/A |
Ruminjo 2015 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Sahin 2011 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Sandberg 2019 | UTI | Standard urine test for nitrite and leucocytes in combination with clinical symptoms | Not clear whether test is dipstick only or whether it involves microscopy/culture |
Schiotz 1995 | UTI | Positive cultures: culture of > 105 cfu/mL in a sample of MSU or CSU culture of > 104 cfu/mL UTI: positive urine culture in the absence of symptoms. Patients were defined as having UTI if there was any doubt |
EAU: asymptomatic bacteriuria |
Schiotz 1996 | UTI | Positive cultures: culture of > 105 cfu/mL in a sample of MSU or CSU culture of > 104 cfu/mL UTI: positive urine culture in the absence of symptoms. Participants were defined as having UTI if there was any doubt |
EAU: asymptomatic bacteriuria |
Sekhavat 2008 | Positive urine culture | Positive urine culture: prevalence of symptomatic UTI was confirmed through a positive urine culture OR through signs of UTI such as: frequency, urgency, dysuria, suprapubic pain or fever | Does not fully meet the criteria for CDC. Must be positive cultures AND clinical features |
Shahnaz 2016 | Positive urine culture | The presence of positive urinary culture or > 100,000 colony counts in each mL of urine or > 10 pieces of leukocyte in each microscopy field was considered as a urinary infection. | EAU: asymptomatic bacteriuria |
Shrestha 2013 | Asymptomatic bacteriuria | Asymptomatic bacteriuria: pus cells of > 5 per high‐power field in routine examination of urine and bacterial culture positive | EAU: asymptomatic bacteriuria |
Souto 2004 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Sun 2004 | UTI | UTI: positive urine culture of > 105 cfu/mL or WBC > 5/high‐power field in urine analysis | EAU: asymptomatic bacteriuria |
Tahmin 2011 | UTI | UTI: positive urine culture of > 105 cfu/mL | EAU: asymptomatic bacteriuria |
Talreja 2016 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Taube 1989 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Toscano 2001 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Valero Puerta 1998 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Vallabh‐Patel 2020 | UTI | For the purpose of this trial, participants were considered positive for a UTI if they had (1) positive urine cultures per CDC guidelines or (2) treated empirically over the phone for symptoms of UTI, even in the absence of a urine culture | CDC |
Webster 2006 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Weemhoff 2011 | UTI | UTI: > 25 WBC/high‐power field, nitrate production, > 20 bacteria/high‐power field, positive urine culture of > 105 cfu/mL | EAU: asymptomatic bacteriuria |
Williamson 1982 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Wilson 2000 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Wu 2015 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Wyman 1987 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Yaghmaei 2017 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Yee 2015 | Not reported | N/A | N/A |
Zaouter 2009 | UTI | UTI: pyrexia of > 38 °C, clinical features of UTI (dysuria, frequency, urgency, suprapubic pain, urinary incontinence) and a positive urine culture (107 bacterial colonies of micro‐organism‐forming units/L within 2 weeks after the removal of bladder catheter) | CDC EAU: complicated UTI |
Zhou 2012 | Not reported | Defined as post‐catheter removal MSU clean catch culture of ≥ 104 cfu/mL for Gram positive organisms or ≥ 105 cfu/mL for Gram negative organisms | EUA: asymptomatic bacteriuria |
Zmora 2010 | UTI Asymptomatic bacteriuria |
UTI: positive urine culture and symptoms suggestive of UTI | CDC |
Zomorrodi 2018 | UTI | Not reported | N/A |
CAUTI: catheter‐associated urinary tract infection; CDC: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention; cfu: colony forming unit; CSU: catheter specimen urine; EAU: European Association of Urology; MSU: midstream urine; N/A: not applicable; UTI: urinary tract infection; WBC: white blood count