Skip to main content
. 2020 Aug 18;2020(8):CD013699. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013699

1. Summary of ROBINS‐I signalling questions for included cohort studies.

Author Confounding Selection of participants Classification of interventions Deviations from intended interventions Missing data Measurement of outcomes Selection of reported result Overall risk of bias
Danquah 2019 No No No No Probably Yesa Probably Yesb No Moderate
Helmich 2017 No Yesc No No Probably Yesa No No Moderate
Ha 2016 No No No No Probably Yesa Probably Yesb No Moderate
Leecaster 2016 No Yesd No Yese Probably Yesa Probably Yesb No Serious
Mastrandrea 2015 No Yesd No Yese Probably Yesa Probably Yesb No Serious
Smieszek 2014 No Yesd No Yese Probably Yesa Probably Yesb No Serious

aMissing data risk will always be a serious threat in contact tracing as the true number of close contacts is rarely known.
bParticipants knew they would have to report the number of close contacts throughout the study. As a result, they could possibly report differently than they would have had they not known.
cStudy of successive patients over only two months, very few cases.
dAs students were volunteers, their desire to participate may have biased their results.
eNot all participants reported close contacts on a daily basis, and not all of those wearing devices self‐reported contacts.