Table 2.
Summary of international guidelines or national multi-cancer recommendation for brachytherapy prioritization during COVID-19 pandemic.
| Cancer type | Hold BT and choose another treatment option | Delay BT until the end of the pandemic | Continue BT during the pandemic | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CNS | Brain (For primary or metastases/adjuvant cases): | |||
| - Avoid BT until pandemic solves | ||||
| - SRS/SRT for glioma or metastatic cases (Mohindra et al., 2020) | ||||
| Head and neck | Oral tongue (pT1-T2, N0) high risk of local recurrence: | |||
| - Adjuvant BT (39 Gy /fr in 7 days, twice daily instead of 60 Gy /30 frs by EBRT) (Aghili et al., 0) | ||||
| Definitive/boost oral cavity/oropharynx, boost nasopharynx or any re-irradiation: | ||||
| - Avoid BT until pandemic solves | ||||
| - For COVID-19+ patients, continue EBRT rather than BT boost (Mohindra et al., 2020) | ||||
| SSC of lip, oral mucosa, or nasal region cases: - Continue (Cyrus et al., 2020) | ||||
| Switch interstitial BT to EBRT | If BT can be employed as a sole modality for cases such as the lip and oral mucosa (Barthwal et al., 2020) | |||
| Recurrent nasopharyngeal carcinoma: time-sparing interstitial or intracavitary brachytherapy (if feasible) | ||||
| - 198Au grains: 60 Gy | ||||
| - 125I grains: 130 Gy; 120 Gy | ||||
| - HDR intracavitary: 24 Gy / 3 frs (Svajdova et al., 2020) | ||||
| Breast | Early-stage cases: | |||
| - Use balloon- or multicatheter-based BT instead of EBRT () | ||||
| Low-risk cases: | ||||
| Postpone interstitial BT for up to 16–20 weeks for ER + invasive cases or 12 weeks for DCIS (Mohindra et al., 2020) | ||||
| Patients prescribed for definitive or adjuvant therapy: | Early-stage: | |||
| - Shorten BT fractionation schedules | - Neoadjuvant endocrine therapy due to delay of surgeries during the crisis; | |||
| - Adjuvant therapy after BCS | ||||
| - Deem BT as an equivalent option to EBRT | ||||
| - BT for APBI with a single-entry intra-cavitary or multi-catheter interstitial technique after surgery | ||||
| Invasive cases: | ||||
| - Induction of therapy for within 12 weeks after surgery, not more than 20 weeks (BT after BCS) (Williams et al., 2020) | ||||
| Accelerated partial breast irradiation (Exclusive): | Accelerated partial breast irradiation (Exclusive): | |||
| - Opt for EBRT according to local facilities (Chargari et al., 2020) | - Postpone (8–12 weeks) | |||
| Apply EBRT instead of BT (Barthwal et al., 2020) | ||||
| Very Low-, Low- and Intermediate Risk: | ||||
| -HDR-ISBT 27 Gy/2frs Monotherapy | ||||
| - 125I LDR-ISBT | ||||
| Intermediate Risk High - Very High Risk: | ||||
| - HDR-ISBT boost 15 Gy/1 fr (Murakami et al., 2020) | ||||
| Lung | For palliative and post-transplant stenosis: | |||
| - Avoid BT until the pandemic solves (Mohindra et al., 2020) | ||||
| Gastrointestinal | Esophageal | Palliation with symptoms: | ||
| - Continue BT () | ||||
| -Palliative and re-irradiation: | ||||
| - Avoid BT until the pandemic solves (Mohindra et al., 2020) | ||||
| BT with Endoscopic procedures (esophagus or bronchus): | ||||
| - Omit and consider EBRT options (Chargari et al., 2020) | ||||
| Hepato-biliary | Avoid delaying the treatment using BT () | |||
| Hilar Cholangiocarcinoma cases with COVID-19+ during RT: | ||||
| - Continue EBRT rather than BT boost | ||||
| Palliative unresectable malignant biliary obstruction or hepatocellular carcinoma cases (not for the transplant) and metastatic lesions: | ||||
| - Avert BT until pandemic solves (Mohindra et al., 2020) | ||||
| Rectal | For COVID-19+ patients: | Preoperative or definitive postpone brachytherapy until pandemic solves (Hypo-F RT) (Mohindra et al., 2020) | ||
| - Hypo-F-EBRT rather than BT boost | ||||
| After SCRT: | ||||
| - For Unresectable, Medically inoperable, or Frail elderly cases: 10-20 Gy in 2-4 frs (Siavashpour et al., 2020) | ||||
| Anal | - Switch interstitial BT to EBRT | |||
| - Switch to IORT if facilities are available (Barthwal et al., 2020) | ||||
| Genitourinary | Prostate | Continue (Chargari et al., 2020) | ||
| If BT can be employed as a sole modality for penile region cases (Barthwal et al., 2020) | ||||
| Low-risk patient: | High-risk patients: | |||
| - Delay BT up to 3–6 months | - BT as a boost, avoiding any deferent: | |||
| 13·5 Gy /2 frs of BT alone or 15 Gy/1 fr as EBRT boost () | ||||
| For COVID-19+ patients during EBRT: | High-risk cases: | High-risk cases: | ||
| - Interrupt treatment to let recovery up to 10–14 days before restarting/plan for BT | - Delay all monotherapy BT | - Defer starting EBRT and keep on hormone therapy-- Consider EBRT boost instead of BT (Mohindra et al., 2020) | ||
| For COVID-19+ patients after 1 st session of HDR, defer 2nd fraction to allow recovery up to10–14 days | ||||
| Low and intermediate-risk cases: | For anxious patients, minimize the time of treatment (definitive) | |||
| - Delay BT for at least 3–6 months | Definitive or adjuvant therapy (using endocrine): | |||
| - Shorten BT fractionation schedules (Williams et al., 2020) | ||||
| Low-risk prostate cancer (Exclusive): | Low-risk prostate cancer (Exclusive): | |||
| - Postpone (8–12 weeks) | - Opt for surveillance | |||
| Intermediate and high-risk prostate: | Intermediate and high-risk prostate: | |||
| - Postpone (8–12 weeks) | - Opt for EBRT according to local facilities (Chargari et al., 2020) | |||
| Brachytherapy should be avoided as far as possible | In centers where prostate BT is common: | |||
| – all (HDR) monotherapy cases (2 implants) should be converted to HDR boost (single implant 15 Gy in 1 fr) or switching to EBRT or starting of ADT | ||||
| – EBRT that are due for HDR boosts (15 Gy in 1 fr) can be converted to 37.5 Gy/15 fractions, | ||||
| – For experienced centers, BT can be delivered using LDR (Barthwal et al., 2020) | ||||
| Temporarily defer certain specialized procedures (HDR-BT) (Kwek et al., 2021) | ||||
| Gynecological | Cervix | locally advanced cases (excluding verified or doubtful patients with COVID-19 infection) () | ||
| Positive COVID-19 patients: | Negative COVID-19 patients: | |||
| - Postpone up to 10–14 days | - Finalize treatment within 7–8 weeks (Mohindra et al., 2020) | |||
| - Increase dose by 5 Gy / week deferent (consider OAR constraints) | ||||
| - Keep on BT boost with PPE precautions | ||||
| Chemotherapy/RT + BT ≤ 8 weeks (Williams et al., 2020) | ||||
| Boost: Continue for locally advanced case (Chargari et al., 2020) | ||||
| When that is not feasible EBRT boost should be considered. | Adding approx. 5 Gy per week for each week of BT delay | |||
| beyond seven weeks, respecting (OARs) tolerance doses (Barthwal et al., 2020) | ||||
| - Reducing the number of applications by delivering multiple fractions with each application | ||||
| - Using higher dose/fr (fewer fraction number) considering the indications (e.g., 3 × 8 Gy or 4 × 7 Gy) (Miriyala and Mahantshetty, 2020; ElMajjaoui et al., 2020; Kumar and Dey, 2020; Ismaili and Elmajjaoui, 2020) | ||||
| Adjuvant treatment: 9 Gy / 2 frs over 2 weeks, over conventional 7 Gy / 3–4 frs or 6 Gy / 5 frs (Upadhyay and Shankar, 2020) | ||||
| 9 Gy × 2 frs weekly (in patients with low volume disease post-RT and in whom inferior local control) (Kumar and Dey, 2020) | ||||
| Stages IB3, IIA2-IIIC2, and early IVA: Intracavitary HDR brachytherapy 3 frs | ||||
| Stages IA1, IA2, IB1, IB2, IIA1: Vault brachytherapy 12 Gy/2 frs (Hinduja et al., 2020) | ||||
| For centers with single brachytherapy operating: | Reduced number of fractions: 24 Gy/3 frs or 28 Gy/4 frs | |||
| postpone at least 24 days or until the infection is resolved | HDR ICBT: 7 Gy/4 frs at 1 week apart or 2 frs per day separated by a 6 h interval | |||
| For patients >70 yrs, significant comorbidities, small tumors, or responding well to RT: | ||||
| -Shortened schedule (9 Gy /2 frs at 1 week apart) | ||||
| -Brachytherapy for cervical cancer (stage IB1, IIIB) (ElMajjaoui et al., 2020) | ||||
| Advanced cervical cancer: temporarily defer interstitial brachytherapy (Kwek et al., 2021) | ||||
| Uterine | - Postpone BT but no more than 12 weeks after surgery (Williams et al., 2020) | |||
| Endometrial | - Standard treatment (preferably three frs) () | |||
| Inoperable definitive positive COVID-19 symptomatic patients: | ||||
| - Hold on RT for 10–14 days | ||||
| - Start BT after recovery (Mohindra et al., 2020) | ||||
| High-risk cases: | ||||
| - Postpone boost (8–12 weeks) | ||||
| - Opt EBRT according to local facilities (Chargari et al., 2020) | ||||
| Interstitial BT for definitive COVID-19+ cases: | ||||
| - Delay treatment up to 10–14 days after recovery | ||||
| - Increase BT dose by 5 Gy / week deferent (Mohindra et al., 2020) | ||||
| Intermediate risk endometrial cancer (Exclusive): Postpone (8–12 weeks) or opt for surveillance (Chargari et al., 2020) | ||||
| Postop vaginal cuff cases: | - Postpone BT up to 8–9 weeks after surgery | |||
| - Avert BT boost after RT if no adverse factor exists | - Postpone BT boost by 2–3 weeks after RT (Mohindra et al., 2020) | |||
| - COVID-19+ patients: postpone BT until pandemic solves | ||||
| Early-stage high risk | Early-stage intermediate risk: | |||
| - Postpone BT up to 12 weeks to 6 months based on patient comorbidities | ||||
| −7 Gy (to 0.5 cm depth) in 3 frs allowing 14 days inter-fraction interval | ||||
| Stage II: | ||||
| - Postpone by 1–2 months | ||||
| - Postpone at least 24 days for COVID-19 positive cases (ElMajjaoui et al., 2020) | ||||
| Stages IA Gr I-Gr III and IB Gr I-II: Vault brachytherapy if positive margins, suboptimal surgery | Stages IB Gr 3, stage II G1 and G2 with no high-risk features, stage IIIA-IIIC: Vault brachytherapy (Hinduja et al., 2020) | |||
| High-risk patients (received adjuvant RT): Omitting VVB | For patients with significant comorbidities: for 6 months | Patients who should start VVB: 7 Gy/3 frs (depth of 0.5 cm) with an interval spacing of 14 days between the fractions | ||
| Intermediate-risk endometrial cancer: | Stage II endometrial cancer with poor prognostic factors (if invasion > 50 % of the myometrium, G3), and for stage I high-risk endometrial cancer: Adjuvant RT and brachytherapy (ElMajjaoui et al., 2020) | |||
| Delaying VVB up to 12 weeks | ||||
| Stage II endometrial cancers: | ||||
| Adjuvant VVB (exclusively: if invasion < 50 % of the myometrium, G1 and 2 or after RT: if invasion > 50 % of the myometrium, G3): postpone brachytherapy by 1–2 months | ||||
| COVID-19 positive patient: postpone treatment (at least 24 days) | ||||
| Vaginal | Stage I: | Advanced stage (ElMajjaoui et al., 2020) | ||
| - Postpone BT up to 1–6 months for patients with significant comorbidities | ||||
| Upper and lower vagina (Hinduja et al., 2020) | ||||
| Early vaginal cancer (stage I, < 5 mm of invasion) with significant comorbidities: | For advanced stage: | |||
| postpone brachytherapy by 1–2 months | CRT followed by vaginal brachytherapy (7 Gy/3frs) | |||
| Brachytherapy without any delay (curative treatment): | ||||
| stage I, < 5 mm of invasion, locally advanced stage (ElMajjaoui et al., 2020) | ||||
| Vulvar | low priority and only be carried out when operation theatre capacity allows it (Barthwal et al., 2020) | |||
| Vulva: radical, adjuvant and palliative (Hinduja et al., 2020) | ||||
| Sarcoma | Postpone BT boost until pandemic solves. | |||
| For COVID-19+ patients during RT, continue EBRT rather than brachytherapy boost (Mohindra et al., 2020) | ||||
| Soft-tissue sarcoma: | ||||
| - BT alone (HDR instead of LDR with iridium-192 wires) rather than 60−66 Gy / 1·8−2 Gy/ fr adjuvant EBRT () | ||||
| Pediatrics | BT can be employed in specialized centers, especially for rhabdomyosarcoma (Barthwal et al., 2020) | |||
| Pediatrics indication: To be discussed on an individual basis (Chargari et al., 2020) | ||||
| Skin | Non-melanoma skin cancers: | |||
| - Use BT with fewer fractions, especially in inoperable patients () | ||||
| Definitive cases: | ||||
| - Avoid BT until the pandemic solves (Mohindra et al., 2020) | ||||
| Basal cell carcinoma (Exclusive): | Basal cell carcinoma: | |||
| - Postpone according to functional risk | - Do not postpone (Chargari et al., 2020) | |||
| Hypo-F RT can be delivered in a twice-daily frs | Until it is suitable for the institute (Barthwal et al., 2020) | |||
| - Switch interstitial BT to EBRT | ||||
| - Switch to IORT if facilities are available (Barthwal et al., 2020) | ||||
| Keloids (Exclusive) | Omit BT and consider options (Chargari et al., 2020) | |||
| Uveal Melanoma | Continue (Mohindra et al., 2020;) | |||
| Palliative | BT should be avoided and replaced by Hypo-F EBRT (Barthwal et al., 2020) | |||
RT: radiotherapy, BT: brachytherapy, EBRT: external beam radiotherapy, HDR: high-dose-rate, LDR: low-dose-rate, SCC: squamous cell carcinoma, PPE: personal protective equipment, IORT, intra-operative radiotherapy, Hypo-F RT: hypo-fractionated RT, ISBT: interstitial brachytherapy, VVB: Vaginal vault brachytherapy.