TABLE 1.
Major groups (Classic or Next generation) | Vaccine platform | Advantages | Disadvantages | Vaccines currently approved and claimed efficacy | Vaccines in late developmental phases |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Classic |
Live‐Attenuated Virus |
Relatively easy and quick to manufacture due to proven technology; safe; provides multivalent antigens and hence may protect against current or future viral variants; no adjuvants required; induce strong immune responses | Requires facilities for live virus handling; inappropriate for immunosuppressed individuals; Rare possibility of reversion and risk for infection; complicated to scale up manufacturing | Nil in the market thus far | Covi‐Vac intranasal vaccine(Codagenix/Serum Institute of India) |
Classic | Inactivated virus | Relatively easy and rapid manufacture due to proven technology; provides multivalent antigens and hence may protect against current or future viral variants; no adjuvants required | Complex manufacturing process and hence difficulty to scale up; less reactive (reactogenic) than the live virus vaccines and produces a weaker immune response | Sinovac Vaccine(Sinovac Research and Development Co., Ltd./Butantan Institute) (Efficacy: 52 percent) | QazCovid (Research Institute for Biological Safety Problems, India) |
Sinopharm vaccine(Sinopharm Group, China)(Efficacy: 79 percent) | |||||
Classic | Protein/Subunit | Relatively safe as live virus is not used in the actual vaccine manufacture; induces strong cellular and humoral immune responses | High cost; lower immunogenicity to specific proteins/antigens; adjuvants required to increase potency may cause allergic reactions in vaccinees; complicated to scale up the manufacturing process | Novavax, Inc. (Nasdaq: NVAX) NVX‐CoV2373 COVID−19 vaccine(Efficacy: 89.3% in the United Kingdom and 49.4% in South Africa—including HIV‐positive and HIV‐negative subjects) | NVX‐CoV2373 (Novavax, USA).SCB−2019 vaccine (Clover Biopharmaceuticals AUS Pty Ltd.), Covax−19 (GeneCure Biotechnologies; Vaxine Pty Ltd.), |
Next generation | Viral Vector‐Based | High degree of safety due to years of proven experience in the gene therapy field; induces strong cellular and humoral responses as they imitate the natural infection; can be stored at 40C (home fridge temperature) | Theoretical risk of infection and/or chromosomal integration and oncogenesis; ineffective in immunocompromised subjects (as most have been pre‐exposed to multiple adenoviruses) | Oxford–AstraZeneca COVID−19 vaccine (AZD1222); AstraZeneca and University of Oxford, UK (Efficacy: 72 percent) | CanSino Biologics. |
Gamaleya (Sputnik V) Research Institute of Epidemiology and Microbiology, Health Ministry of the Russian Federation.(Efficacy: 92 percent) | |||||
Johnson & Johnson; USA(Efficacy: 66–85 percent) | |||||
Next generation | mRNA | Safe as no live virus handling during development, rapid development, and production; flexibility to produce multivalent vaccines (in the event of virus variants arising); no risk of genetic integration; induces a very strong immune response | RNA being very fragile require ultra‐cold chain requirements (−700C for Moderna and −20 0 C for Pfizer/Biotec) for storage and transport; currently, high cost; long term adverse effects, if any, unknown |
Moderna, Moderna, USA (Efficacy: 95 percent) |
CureVac (Bayer and Imperial College London) |
Pfizer‐BioNTec :Europe (synonym: Cominarty) In adults (Efficacy: approx. 95 percent) In children, aged 12–15‐years (Efficacy: 100 percent) | |||||
Next generation | DNA | Safe as no live virus handling during development; possibility of multivalency; both humoral and cell‐mediated immune response, good long‐term stability with no cold chain requirements; possibility of freeze drying and storage and transportation at ambient temperatures; oral formulations are feasible | Repeated doses thought to cause toxicity; potential risk of genetic integration unknown | Nil in the market thus far |
INO−4800 (International Vaccine Institute; Inovio Pharmaceuticals), Symvivo, Canada ‐COVID19 (AnGes, Inc.); GX−19 (Genexine, Inc.) |