TABLE 1.
Category | Method | Pros | Cons | Application |
---|---|---|---|---|
Short‐T R/T E | SSFP |
‐ highest SNR/t gain ‐ moderate acceleration |
‐ T 1/T 2‐weighting ‐ low spectral resolution ‐ poor water and lipid suppression in 1H‐MRSI ‐ banding artifacts/B 0 sensitive |
‐ metabolites with long T 2 and short T 1 ‐ hyperpol. 13C MRSI/MRI ‐ 1H‐MRSI possible but restricted to major singlets ‐ preferably <7 T |
Turbo‐spin‐echo | ‐ low acceleration |
‐ low spectral resolution ‐ T 2‐weighting (in k‐space) ‐ ΔB 1 + sensitive |
‐ metabolites with long T 2 ‐ singlets in 1H MRSI ‐ preferably <3 T |
|
FID‐MRSI |
‐ SNR/t gain ‐ moderate acceleration ‐ high SNR ‐ J‐coupled metabolites in phase ‐ ΔB 1 + insensitive ‐ low SAR ‐ low CSDE |
‐ T 1‐weighting ‐ trade‐off between speed (T R) and spectral resolution ‐ moderate lipid suppression in 1H‐MRSI |
‐ short T 2/J‐coupled metabolites ‐ ultra‐high field ‐ 13C/31P/1H‐MRSI ‐ preferably >1.5 T |
|
Cartesian SSE | EPSI |
‐ high acceleration ‐ inherently constant k‐space weighting |
‐ some SNR/t loss ‐ limited SBW/spatial resolution ‐ gradient demanding |
‐ 13C/31P/1H‐MRSI ‐ preferably <7 T |
Non‐Cartesian SSE | Spirals |
‐ highest acceleration ‐ any k‐space weighting possible |
‐ some SNR/t loss ‐ limited SBW/spatial resolution ‐ gradient demanding |
‐ 13C/31P/1H‐MRSI ‐ preferably <7 T |
CRTs |
‐ high acceleration ‐ inherent k‐space weighting (optimization possible) |
‐ some SNR/t loss ‐ limited SBW/spatial resolution ‐ gradient demanding |
‐ 13C/31P/1H‐MRSI ‐ preferably ≥3 T |
|
Rosettes |
‐ can be tailored for either high speed or low gradient stress ‐ inherently weighted k‐space (optimization possible) |
‐ some SNR/t loss ‐ moderate SBW/spatial resolution limitation |
‐ 13C/31P/1H‐MRSI ‐ preferably ≥7 T |
|
Radial EPSI |
‐ high acceleration ‐ inherent k‐space weighting (fixed) |
‐ some SNR/t loss ‐ limited SBW/spatial resolution ‐ gradient demanding |
‐ 13C/31P/1H‐MRSI ‐ preferably <7 T |
|
Coherent k‐space undersampling | SENSE |
‐ no gradient demands ‐ low acceleration |
‐ some SNR/t loss ‐ needs multi‐channel receive coils ‐ needs explicit sensitivity maps ‐ spatial aliasing ‐ motion sensitive |
‐ preferably 1H‐MRSI ‐ 13C/31P‐MRSI possible, but difficult to obtain reliable sensitivity maps ‐ preferably ≥3 T/better at UHF |
GRAPPA |
‐ no gradient demands ‐ interleaving to reduce motion sensitivity ‐ low acceleration |
‐ some SNR/t loss ‐ needs multi‐channel receive coils ‐ spatial aliasing |
‐ preferably 1H‐MRSI ‐ 13C/31P‐MRSI possible ‐ preferably ≥3 T/better at UHF |
|
CAIPIRINHA |
‐ no gradient demands ‐ better control of aliasing ‐ interleaving to reduce motion sensitivity ‐ low acceleration |
‐ some SNR/t loss ‐ needs multi‐channel receive coils ‐ spatial aliasing |
‐ preferably 1H‐MRSI ‐ 13C/31P‐MRSI possible ‐ preferably ≥3 T/better at UHF |
|
Multi‐slice excitation | Multi‐band/SMS |
‐ accelerate also in slice direction ‐ low acceleration |
‐ some SNR/t loss ‐ needs multi‐channel receive coils ‐ increased SAR/B 1 + ‐ spatial aliasing |
‐ preferably 1H‐MRSI, but 13C/31P‐MRSI possible ‐ better at UHF |
Incoherent k‐space undersampling | CS |
‐ SNR/t gain through regularization ‐ moderate acceleration |
‐ sparse data (representation) required ‐ minimum SNR required to work robustly |
‐ in spectral domain only for long‐T E 1H‐MRSI or 13C/31P‐MRSI |
Prior knowledge based | SLIM/SLOOP/SLAM |
‐ SNR/t gain through regularization and spatial averaging ‐ high acceleration |
‐ sensitive to bias fields such as B 0 inhomogeneity |
‐ 31P‐MRS(I) ‐ potentially hyperpol. 13C‐MRS(I) ‐ spectra from multiple arbitrarily shaped compartments instead of metabolite maps (except for GSLIM) |
SPICE |
‐ SNR/t gain through regularization ‐ high acceleration |
‐ requires assumptions about spatial and spectral priors; nuisance removal challenging ‐ may lead to spatial averaging ‐ may lead to spectral information loss |
‐ preferably sparse well resolved spectra (13C, 31P), but 1H‐MRSI possible | |
Super‐resolution reconstruction | ‐ resolution increase via pure post‐processing |
‐ requires assumptions about spatial priors ‐ no true spatial resolution gain—only smoother appearance of metabolite maps |
all | |
Spectral‐spatial excitation & IDEAL | ‐ replaces time‐consuming spectral encoding by conventional MRI readout | ‐ requires good spectral separation and ΔB 0 homogeneity | ‐ 13C/31P‐MRSI; good spectral separation required |
Abbreviation: ΔB 1 +—transmit field inhomogeneity.