Skip to main content
. 2021 Jun 17;6(25):16612–16622. doi: 10.1021/acsomega.1c02016

Table 1. Free Energy Differences between ENDO and SURFACE Structures (ΔGS-E) and ENDO and Transition State Structures (ΔGTS), in kcal/mol, for 5Ti, 7Cr, 3Ni, and 1Zn Doped (ZnS)1 Nanoclustersa.

  5Ti
7Cr
3Ni
1Zn
  ΔES-E ΔETS ΔES-E ΔETS ΔES-E ΔETS ΔES-E ΔETS
MP2 5.58 5.38 19.80 16.57 8.74 –2.10 27.14 37.18
B3LYPa –18.08 3.93 –2.89 11.73 –15.38 –0.89 –1.66 27.48
CAM-B3LYP –16.60 5.00 –2.95 11.56 –13.00 –0.80 –0.51 31.33
M06-2X 8.20 5.72 12.72 11.85 5.62 5.21 8.20 35.41
M06 6.53 2.64 31.24 16.56 17.94 1.44 19.73 33.87
wB97XD –6.87 –5.19 8.18 14.80 –0.46 1.55 10.80 35.74
PBE-D3BJ 5.78 4.13 22.80 16.66 9.65 –1.84 19.69 32.07
B2PLYP –7.86 4.17 5.74 12.94 0.56 –1.92 8.63 31.20
B2PLYPD –1.77 6.31 16.80 20.03 9.08 2.34 20.57 37.53
B2PLYPD3 3.15 6.12 18.02 17.84 11.32 2.18 19.31 35.38
wPW2PLYP –8.64 4.53 5.05 13.29 –1.13 –1.20 7.69 31.72
wPW2PLYPD –4.21 6.08 13.09 18.45 5.07 1.87 16.37 36.32
DSDPBEP86 6.82 4.95 21.30 17.53 18.52 0.71 22.65 36.56
PBE0DH 2.32 5.45 15.97 16.78 3.05 0.09 14.23 35.30
PBEQIDH 5.09 5.39 18.22 16.96 12.06 –0.47 18.75 36.71
a

Data taken from ref (29).