Skip to main content
. 2021 Jan 19;60(21):11628–11686. doi: 10.1002/anie.202006988

Table 6.

Catalytic systems, major products, maximum FEs, and mechanisms of Co complexes in electrochemical CO2 reduction (n.a.=not available, prop.=proposal, comp.=computational investigation, exp.=experimental evidence).

Entry

Cat. system

Substitution

Major product

Max. FE (%)

Mechanism

Basis

Method

Ref.

1a

graphic file with name ANIE-60-11628-g104.jpg

n=1, 2

R= –, H, Me

X= –, MeCN, NCS, Cl, Br

CO/H2O

H2

45±7 [235]

30±8 [235]

ETM

exp.[236

comp. [237]

IL, IR

DFT

[ 235 , 236 , 237 , 238 ]

1b

graphic file with name ANIE-60-11628-g186.jpg

CO/H2O

82

ETM

comp.

DFT

[59]

1c

graphic file with name ANIE-60-11628-g153.jpg

HCO2H

80

ETM (CO)

ETH (HCO2H)

exp.

comp.

IR‐SEC

DFT

[239]

1d

graphic file with name ANIE-60-11628-g041.jpg

HCO2H

60

n.a.

n.a.

n.a.

[240]

2a

graphic file with name ANIE-60-11628-g009.jpg

R=H, Me

CO/H2O

H2

93

(CO+H2)

ETH

prop.

n.a.

[241]

3a

graphic file with name ANIE-60-11628-g200.jpg

Ar=Ph, C6H4CF3, C6H4NH2, C6H4NMe3 +, C6H3(OH)2, C6H4OMe, C6H3(OMe)2, C6H4Cl, C6H4Br, C6H4F, C6F5

n=0, 1

X= –, Cl

CO/H2O

97 [242]

ETM

prop. [242]

n.a.

[ 242 , 243 ]

3b

graphic file with name ANIE-60-11628-g141.jpg

CO/H2O

89

ETM

prop.

n.a.

[244]

3c

graphic file with name ANIE-60-11628-g120.jpg

R1=H, tBu, OC8H17, O‐py

R2=H, tBu, OC8H17, O‐py

R3=H, NMe3 +

CO/H2O

H2

MeOH

100 [120]

72 [120]

20 [231]

ETM

exp. [230]

comp. [245]

PSCAS

DFT

[120, 230,

231, 243e,

245, 246]

3d

graphic file with name ANIE-60-11628-g074.jpg

CO

97

n.a.

n.a.

n.a.

[247]

4

graphic file with name ANIE-60-11628-g135.jpg

L=PPh3

R=S‐(PEG7)‐OCH3

HCO2

CH3OH H2CO CH3CH2OH

CH3CO2

H2

12

59

10

48

13

36

ETM

exp.

EPR, GC‐MS, IL, IR‐SEC, NMR

[234]

5a

graphic file with name ANIE-60-11628-g048.jpg

CO/H2O

77

n.a.

n.a.

n.a.

[248]

5b

graphic file with name ANIE-60-11628-g142.jpg

R=CH3

R∩R=CH2, (CH2)2

CO/H2O

98

ETM

comp.

DFT

[249]

5c

graphic file with name ANIE-60-11628-g202.jpg

n=0, 1

X= –, Cl

CO/H2O

16

ETM

exp.

comp.

IR, UV/Vis

DFT

[250]

6

graphic file with name ANIE-60-11628-g103.jpg

R=H, Me, allyl

CO/H2O

98

ETM

comp.

DFT

[ 226 , 251 ]

7

graphic file with name ANIE-60-11628-g084.jpg

L=py, qui

(+ dimer)

CO/H2O

84

ETM

comp.

DFT

[252]

8

graphic file with name ANIE-60-11628-g158.jpg

R1=H, tBu, OMe,

p‐Me‐C6H4, p‐Cl‐C6H4

R2=H, tBu

CO/H2O

H2

37 [253]

23 [253]

ETM

prop. [253]

n.a.

[ 253 , 254 ]

9

[Co(PPh3)2L]n+

L=4,4′‐di‐Me‐bpy, 4‐Me‐1,10‐phen, 2‐Me‐8‐hydroxyqui

n=1, 2

CO/CO3 2− HCO2

83

44

ETM

prop.

n.a.

[255]

10a

[CoCp(L)I]+

graphic file with name ANIE-60-11628-g189.jpg

R1=Cy, Ph

R2=Ph, Bn

HCO2

H2

99±8

67±5

ETH

comp.

DFT

[256]

10b

graphic file with name ANIE-60-11628-g123.jpg

n=1, 2

R=H, Me

X=MeCN, I

CO/H2O

70

ETM

prop.

n.a.

[257]

11a

graphic file with name ANIE-60-11628-g014.jpg

CO/H2O

94 [184]

ETM

prop. [184]

n.a.

[184, 229,

258]

11b

graphic file with name ANIE-60-11628-g147.jpg

Y=CH2, (CH2)2, (CH2)3

CO/H2O

HCO2H

104±6 [259]

23 [260]

ETM

prop.

n.a.

[259]

12

graphic file with name ANIE-60-11628-g193.jpg

CO/H2O

96

ETM

comp.

DFT

[261]

13a

graphic file with name ANIE-60-11628-g119.jpg

CO/H2O

95±2

ETM

comp.

DFT

[262]

13b

graphic file with name ANIE-60-11628-g072.jpg

L∩L=dppe, bpy,

4,4'‐(OMe)2bpy,

2‐pyridinethiolato

n=0, 1

CO/H2O

HCO2H

H2

92±4 [263]

(CO+H2)

64 [264]

19 [264]

ETM (CO)

ETH (HCO2H/H2)

comp.

DFT

[ 263 , 264 ]

14

graphic file with name ANIE-60-11628-g070.jpg

n.a.

n.a.

ETM

exp.

comp.

XRD

coupled cluster

[228]

15

[Co(L)2]2+

graphic file with name ANIE-60-11628-g051.jpg

CO/H2O

H2

23

42

ETM (CO)

ETH (H2)

prop.

n.a.

[265]

16

graphic file with name ANIE-60-11628-g017.jpg

R=MeCp

C2O4 2−

80

n.a.

n.a.

n.a.

[266]