Table 6.
Surveys on culling day-old male layer chicks.
Reference by recent publication date | Date of survey and country where survey was conducted | Type of survey | Type of respondents, sample size, incentive to participate | Percentage of respondents' being aware of the practice of culling day old male layer chicks (CMC) | Percentage of respondents' not accepting/need for an alternative to CMC | Percentage of respondents' first preference for alternatives to CMC focusing on keeping dual purpose (DP) chicken; rearing layer males and in-ovo sex determination |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Current study | July-Aug 2020 | Online survey 34 questions | 259*, (in)directly within personal network of authors | 52% | 67.3–78.8% | 6–10% rearing male layers 23–29% DP chicken 51–57% in-ovo sex determination |
Reithmayer et al. (39) | Dec-March 2019 Germany | 26 min Online survey 26 questions | 482, given a small financial incentive | N.S. | 89% | N.D. rearing male layers N.D. DP chicken Different in-ovo sex determination techniques: 48% |
Reithmayer and MuBhoff (38) | 2018 Germany | Online survey, 4 parts, DCEd, information part, questions | 400, given a financial incentive | N.D. | N.D. | 27% DP chicken 0% rearing male layers 75% in-ovo sex determination |
Busse et al. (10) | 2016 Germany | 20-min telephone interviews, 43 questions | 1,000 consumers of an organic farming initiative | 70% | 67% | N.D. Rearing male layers 50% DP chicken N.D. in-ovo sex determination |
Gremmen et al. (36) | Oct-Dec 2015 The Netherlands | Online surveya, 10 questions, 2 blocks of informative text, | 1,022b | 55% | 47% | 41.3% DP chicken 41.3% rearing layer males 37.5–43.2%c pref. in-ovo sex |
Gangnat et al. (40) | Jan-Feb 2016 Switzerland | 10-min survey on DP, at 8 supermarkets, 18 questions, text, photos, ruler for WTP | 402e, small gift | 25% | N.D. % but preference for in-ovo sex determination over CMC | N.D. % alternatives N.D. Rearing male layers No preference for DP over CMC Preference for in-ovo sex determination over CMC |
Leenstra et al. (9) | N.S. The Netherlands | Online surveyf, film, 10 alternatives | 1,199 | 42% | 58% | 24% DP chicken N.D. rearing male layers 25% in-ovo sex determination |
Dataset divided in Highly Educated Women (n = 143) and REST (n = 85). N.S., Not specified; N.D., not determined;
Survey made with use of a valorization panel: stakeholders (farmer representatives), consumers; retail and animal protection organizations, n = 10;
overrepresentation of highly educated people and 50–69 age group;
different types of in ovo sex determination were examined (genetic modification, invasive and non-invasive methods);
DCE: discrete choice experiment; choose between 2 or more alternatives,
Respondents were either given questions focussed on eggs or on chicken;
Survey made with use of 6 focus groups with 6–7 people, tested on 44 students.