Skip to main content
. 2021 Jun 18;9(2):E681–E692. doi: 10.9778/cmajo.20200109

Table 3:

Summary of findings

Framework level Key findings GRADE-CERQual assessment
Confidence in the evidence Explanation
Discrimination Systemic racism: Refugees experienced individual and systemic racism, which exacerbated housing instability. Many refugees felt they were turned away from housing and emergency shelters because of their ethnicity, use of welfare cheques, history of trauma, language of origin, temporary resident status and the presence of children. Low Moderate concerns for methodological limitations and adequacy, and no-to-minor concerns for coherence and relevance.
Mental health Mental health concerns: Lived experience of trauma and housing insecurity resulted in persistent psychological distress and mental health concerns. Moderate Very minor concerns for methodological limitations, no-to-very minor concerns for coherence, relevance and adequacy.
Social networks and support Finding an advocate: Refugees who sought a culturally familiar community advocate were able to increase their social capital. Advocates included settlement counsellors and cultural brokers. These advocates were able to help refugees transition out of homelessness by providing social support, a place to stay and other resources. High Minor concerns for methodological limitations, no-to-very minor concerns for coherence, relevance and adequacy.
Services: health and housing Poor access to services: Refugees and other migrants, particularly undocumented migrants, failed asylum seekers and those with humanitarian protection, are often unaware of support services and find them difficult to access and navigate. Moderate Minor concerns for methodological limitations, no-to-very minor concerns for coherence, relevance and adequacy.
Unsafe housing: Refugees and other migrants perceived the housing options available to them as unsafe, poorly managed and unaffordable. High Minor concerns for methodological limitations, very minor-to-minor concerns for relevance and no-to-very minor concerns for coherence and adequacy.
Family structure Facing a family separation: Several vulnerably housed refugees expressed difficulties learning a new culture, and parents struggled with the ability of their children to balance a new culture and the culture of their country of origin. This family conflict led to a loss of family support, which is a protective factor against homelessness. Low Moderate concerns for methodological limitations and relevance, no-to-very minor concerns for coherence and adequacy.
Income Insufficient income assistance: Refugees and other migrants reported strained finances and inadequate financial support that led to difficulty meeting basic needs, housing insecurity and food instability. Low Moderate concerns for methodological limitations and relevance, no-to-very minor concerns for coherence and adequacy.
Immigration status Impact of immigration status: Compared with status migrants, nonstatus migrants faced substantial barriers, such as limited rights to welfare, prohibition from taking up paid employment and rejection from shelter access. Low Serious concerns for methodological limitations, moderate concerns for relevance and no-to-very minor concerns for coherence and adequacy.
Language Lack of language skills impeding access: Limited language skills among refugees impeded their ability to access most services, including housing services, and limited their social capital and connections beyond their original community. Moderate Moderate concerns for methodological limitations, no-to-minor concerns for coherence, adequacy and relevance.
Outlier Adopting survival and coping strategies: Refugees and other migrants who faced insecure housing instability adopted survival and coping strategies that helped them to advocate for resources and develop a sense of belonging in their new community. Moderate Moderate concerns for relevance, no-to-minor concerns for coherence, relevance and adequacy.

Note: GRADE-CERQual = Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation Confidence in the Evidence from Reviews of Qualitative.