Skip to main content
. 2021 Mar 15;47(4):525–561. doi: 10.1111/cch.12830

TABLE 4.

Risk of bias assessment (QUIPS)

Study participation Study attrition Prognostic factor measurement Outcome measurement Study confounding Statistical analysis and reporting Overall RoB
Child factors
GA
Preterm
Yaari et al., 2018 ? + + ? + + H
Term

Espel et al., 2014

+ ? ? + + + H
Post‐term

Field et al., 1978

? N/A + H

Birthweight

Low birthweight

Datar & Jacknowitz, 2009 + + + + + + L

Grantham‐McGregor et al., 1998

+ + + + + + L
Normal birthweight
Lung et al., 2009a + + + ? + + H
Twin

Nan et al., 2013

+ + ? + + H

Brouwer et al., 2006

? N/A + ? ? H

Goetghebuer et al., 2003

? + ? + + H
Wilson & Harpring, 1972 + H
Weight, length and head circumference
Scharf et al., 2016 ? ? + + + ? H
Overweight

Slining et al., 2010

+ + + + + + L
Proportionately larger head
Bartlett, 1998 + + + H
Afro‐American background

Capute et al., 1985

? ? H
Motivation to move

Atun‐Einy et al., 2013

N/A + ? H
Environmental factors
Sleep position
Prone sleeping

Majnemer and Barr, 2006

? ? + + + H

Davis et al., 1998

+ ? + ? ? + H
Supine sleeping

Lung and Shu, 2011

? ? + ? + + H

Ratliff‐Schaub et al., 2001

? ? + + H
Breastfeeding
Jardí et al., 2018 + N/A + + + + L

Michels et al., 2017

+ N/A + ? + + H

Morris et al., 1999

+ + + + + + L

Oddy et al., 2011

? ? ? ? + + H
Maternal depression
Smith‐Nielsen et al., 2019 ? + + + ? + H

Sutter‐Dallay et al., 2011

+ ? ? + + + H
Maternal mental health

Lung and Shu, 2011

+ ? + ? + + H
Adolescent mother

de Borba and Valentini, 2015

N/A + ? H
Parental mental health
Lung et al., 2009b + + + ? + + H
Parental neonatal perception
Hernández‐Martínez et al., 2011 + N/A + + + ? H
Babywalker
Siegel and Burton, 1999 ? + ? + ? ? H
Daycare attendance

Souza et al., 2010

N/A ? + H
Season of birth winter
Tsuchiya et al., 2012 ? + + ? + + H
Cameroonian versus German culture
Vierhaus et al., 2011 ? ? + ? + + H
Multiple factors
Bjarnadóttir et al., 2019 + + + ? + + H
Flensborg‐Madsen & Mortensen, 2017 + + ? + ? H
Pereira et al., 2016 ? + + + H

Note. L = low risk of bias (RoB), H = high RoB; ‐ = not reported, + = reported, ? = not sure; N/A = not applicable.