Skip to main content
. 2021 Jul 7;2021(7):CD013321. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013321.pub2
Study Reason for exclusion
Abdollahi 2020 Not our population of interest. Participants’ mean W‐DEQ A score prior to intervention was 56; therefore, ineligible for our review
Ahmadi 2017 Population of interest did not have high or severe FOC. After discussion, ruled out since 28 was considered high fear on the Childbirth Attitudes Questionnaire (CAQ). The CAQ has a range from 14 to 56.
Andaroon 2017 Not our population of interest. Women scored 34 to 84 on W‐DEQ A.
Bergstrom 2009 Not our population of interest. Participants did not have fear of childbirth.
Bittner 2014 Not our population of interest. Participants had anxiety, stress and depression. Fear of childbirth was not assessed.
Boryri 2019 Quasi‐randomised design
Cankaya 2020 Not our population of interest. Participants did not have fear of childbirth.
ChiCTR1900025309 Quasi‐experimental design
CTRI/2019/11/021950 Quasi‐experimental design
Downe 2015 Not our population of interest. Participants did not have fear of childbirth.
Duncan 2017 Not our population of interest. Participants did not have fear of childbirth.
Ghazaie 2016 Not our population of interest. Participants did not have fear of childbirth.
Gonenc 2020 Not our population of interest. Participants did not have fear of childbirth.
Haapio 2017 Not our population of interest. Participants did not have fear of childbirth.
IRCT20110228005931N5 Not our population of interest. Participants did not have fear of childbirth.
IRCT20120215009014N317 Not our population of interest. Participants did not have fear of childbirth.
IRCT201312073034N13 Not our population of interest. Participants did not have fear of childbirth.
IRCT20150608022609N6 Not our population of interest. Participants were fathers.
IRCT2015120625399N1 Not our population of interest. Participants did not have fear of childbirth. Results not published, only registration. CAQ > 28 for inclusion in study.
IRCT2016060828352N1 Quasi‐experimental design
IRCT20160625028630N2 Quasi‐experimental design
IRCT2016082429506N1 Ineligible population: inclusion criteria do not specifiy FOC. 
IRCT2017030627557N3 Not our population of interest. Participants did not have high or severe fear of childbirth. Inclusion: W‐DEQ A < 66
IRCT20171026037015N3 Participants with moderate FOC: W‐DEQ A > 55
IRCT20171129037676N2 Not our population of interest. Participants did not have fear of childbirth.
IRCT20171230038133N1 Quasi‐randomised design
IRCT20180131038579N1 Not our population of interest. Participants did not have fear of childbirth. Ruled out since 28 was considered high fear on the CAQ. The CAQ has a range from 14 to 56.
IRCT20180427039436N3 Non‐randomised trial according to protocol registration.
IRCT20180520039729N1 Not our population of interest. Participants did not have fear of childbirth.
IRCT20180721040544N1 Not our population of interest. Participants did not have fear of childbirth. Ruled out since 28 was considered high fear on the CAQ. The CAQ has a range from 14 to 56.
IRCT20190210042672N1 Non‐randomised trial according to protocol registration
IRCT20200122046227N1 Not our population of interest. Participants did not have fear of childbirth. Inclusion: W‐DEQ A > 38
Irmak 2019 Not our population of interest. Participants did not have fear of childbirth.
Jamali 2018 Not our population of interest. Participants did not have fear of childbirth. Participants were women "referred for delivery preparation", not women with fear of childbirth.
Klabbers 2019 After data extraction, we realised that it was a cross‐over trial. After discussion between review authors, we excluded it.
Lonnberg 2020 Ineligible population
Masoumi 2016 Not our population of interest. Participants did not have fear of childbirth.
Mehrabadi 2020 Not our population of interest. Participants did not have fear of childbirth.
Navaee 2015 Not our population of interest. Participants did not have fear of childbirth.
Nosratabadi 2018 Not our population of interest. Participants did not have fear of childbirth.
NTR4661 Quasi‐experimental design
Sharifzadeh 2018 Upon translation of this publication, we realised the women had low FOC, and were thus ineligible.
Soltani 2017 Ineligible population: defines FOC as 28 on CAQ, we did not consider this to be high fear as per our protocol.
TCTR20190501001 2019 Not population of interest
Vakilian 2018 Not our population of interest. 
Veringa 2016 Quasi‐experimental design
Werner 2013 Not our population of interest.
Zarenejad 2020 Not our population of interest. Participants did not have fear of childbirth.

CAQ: Childbirth Attitudes Questionnaire