Skip to main content
. 2021 Feb 12;19(4):501–520. doi: 10.1007/s40258-020-00624-2

Table 1.

Characteristics of included studies

Author (year) Geographical setting(s) Design Data source(s) Type of data Study period Patient population
Ali et al. (2019) [17] UK Retrospective, observational cohort study Royal Stoke University Hospital Paper notes and electronic clinical records 2017–9 11 patients with SMA type I (45% male; median age: 2 years) treated with nusinersen
Armstrong et al. (2016) [19] USA Retrospective, observational cohort study Military Health System Data Repository (MDR) Defense Health Agency corporate healthcare data 2003–12 239 patients with SMA (45% male; mean age NR) [phenotype NR]
Chambers et al. (2020) [25] Australia Cross-sectional, observational study; and retrospective, observational cohort study Survey administrated to caregivers via two neuromuscular clinics and a patient support organization; the Sydney Children’s Hospital SMA clinic; and local unit costs Self-reported data; and health service use and insurance data 2016–17 40 patients with SMA (48% male; mean age: 9 years) [10% with SMA type I, 65% with SMA type II, and 25% with SMA type III]
Cardenas et al. (2019) [16] USA Retrospective, observational cohort study Kids’ Inpatient Database (KID) part of the HCUP Claims data 2012 237 patients with SMA type I (43% male; mean age NR)
Darbà ‍et al. (2019) [15] Spain Retrospective, observational cohort study Spanish claims database Minimum Basic Data Set (Conjunto Mínimo Básico de Datos [CMBD]) Claims data 1997–2015 705 patients with SMA type I, SMA type III, progressive SMA, other SMA, or unspecified SMA (62% male; mean age: 37 years) [distribution of phenotypes NR]
Darbà (2020) [24] Spain Retrospective, observational cohort study Public Data Analysis for Health Research and Innovation Program (PADRIS) database Electronic clinical records 2014–17 396 patients with SMA (53% male; mean age: 57 years) (6% with SMA type I, 29% with SMA type III, 43% with progressive SMA, 10% with other SMA, and 13% with unspecified SMA)
Droege et al. (2019) [18] USA Retrospective, observational cohort study Symphony Health’s Integrated Dataverse (IDV) Claims data 2016–18 349 patients with SMA type I (44% male; mean age: 9 years) receiving conventional therapy; 45 patients with SMA type I (38% male; mean age: 12 years) receiving nusinersen; 5728 patients with SMA types II–IV (52% male; mean age: 31 years) receiving conventional therapy; and 404 patients with SMA types II–IV (49% male; mean age: 15 years) receiving nusinersen
Klug et al. (2016) [20] Germany Cross-sectional, observational study

Survey administrated to patients identified via the German

SMA patient registry; and local unit costs

Self-reported data 2013 189 patients with SMA (59% male; median age: 19 years) (6% with SMA type I, 39% with SMA type II, and 55% with SMA type III)
Lee et al. (2019) [14] USA Retrospective, observational cohort study HCUP; and the Center for Health Information and Analysis Claims data 2005–13 229 patients with severe SMA (distribution of sex and mean age NR) [phenotype NR]
López-Bastida et al. (2017) [13] Spain Cross-sectional, observational study Survey administrated to patients via national patient associations; and local unit costs Self-reported data 2015 81 patients with SMA (42% male; mean age: 7 years) [10% with SMA type I, 74% with SMA type II, and 16% with SMA type III]
Marcellusi et al. (2019) [22] Italy Cross-sectional, observational study Survey administrated to patients via a national patient association; and local unit costs Self-reported data 2018 118 patients with SMA (41% male; mean age: 18 years) (23% with SMA type I, 48% with SMA type II, and 29% with SMA type III)
Peña-Longobardo et al. (2020) [26] France; Germany; and UK Cross-sectional, observational study Survey administrated to caregivers via a patient organization/registry; and local unit costs Self-reported data 2015 27 French patients with SMA (41% male; mean age: 6 years) [19% with SMA type I, 48% with SMA type II, and 33% with SMA type III]; 25 German patients with SMA (28% male; mean age: 10 years) [44% with SMA type I, 48% with SMA type II, and 8% with SMA type III]; and 34 UK patients with SMA (50% male; mean age: 6 years) [21% with SMA type I, 59% with SMA type II, and 21% with SMA type III]
Tan et al. (2019) [21] USA Retrospective, observational cohort study HealthCore Integrated Research Database Claims data 2006–16 341 patients with SMA (55% male; mean age: 45 years) [7% with SMA type I, 6% with SMA type II/III, and 87% with SMA type IV]
Zuluaga‑Sanchez et al. (2019) [23] Sweden Modeling study (CEA) Clinical expert input; and local unit costs Clinical and economic model input data 2016 Patients with SMA type I (45% male; mean age: 6 months) and SMA types II–IV (47% male, mean age: 4 years) [number of patients NA]

CEA cost-effectiveness analysis, HCUP Healthcare Cost and Utilization Project, NA not applicable, NR not reported, SMA spinal muscular atrophy