Skip to main content
. 2021 Jul 3;21(13):4567. doi: 10.3390/s21134567

Table 4.

Optimization results of TOA and compared algorithms on high-dimensional test function.

MPA TSA WOA GWO TLBO GSA PSO GA TOA
F8 Ave −3594.16321 −5740.3388 −1663.9782 −5885.1172 −7408.6107 −2849.0724 −6908.6558 −8184.4142 −9631.41
std 811.32651 41.5 716.3492 467.5138 513.5784 264.3516 625.6248 833.2165 3.86 × 10−12
F9 Ave 140.1238 5.70 × 10−3 4.2011 8.5265 × 10−15 10.2485 16.2675 57.0613 62.4114 0
std 26.3124 1.46 × 10−3 4.3692 × 10−15 5.6446 × 10−30 5.5608 × 10−15 3.1776 × 10−15 6.3552 × 10−15 2.5421 × 10−14 0
F10 Ave 9.6987 × 10−12 9.80 × 10−14 0.3293 1.7053 × 10−14 0.2757 3.5673 × 10−9 2.1546 3.2218 8.88 × 10−16
std 6.1325 × 10−12 4.51 × 10−12 1.9860 × 10−16 2.7517 × 10−29 2.5641 × 10−15 3.6992 × 10−25 7.9441 × 10−16 5.1636 × 10−15 0
F11 Ave 0 1.00 × 10−7 0.1189 0.0037 0.6082 3.7375 0.0462 1.2302 0
std 0 7.46 × 10−7 8.9991 × 10−17 1.2606 × 10−18 1.9860 × 10−16 2.7804 × 10−15 3.1031 × 10−18 8.4406 × 10−16 0
F12 Ave 0.0851 0.0368 1.7414 0.0372 0.0203 0.0362 0.4806 0.047 0.2463
std 0.0052 1.5461 × 10−2 8.1347 × 10−12 4.3444 × 10−17 7.7579 × 10−19 6.2063 × 10−18 1.8619 × 10−16 4.6547 × 10−18 7.45 × 10−17
F13 Ave 0.4901 2.9575 0.3456 0.5763 0.3293 0.002 0.5084 1.2085 1.25
std 0.1932 1.5682 × 10−12 3.2539 × 10−12 2.4825 × 10−16 2.1101 × 10−16 4.2617 × 10−14 4.9650 × 10−17 3.2272 × 10−16 4.47 × 10−16