Skip to main content
. 2021 Jun 23;21(13):4302. doi: 10.3390/s21134302

Table 4.

Epoch by epoch sensitivity and specificity for wake, light, deep, and REM sleep and the four models compared in this paper.

Model Stage Accuracy Sensitivity Specificity
ACC Wake 94.53 (3.79) [94.18, 94.88] 72.07 (17.61) [70.44, 73.74] 96.85 (2.94) [96.58, 97.14]
ACC Light 61.27 (5.72) [60.74, 61.8] 67.74 (14.22) [66.45, 69.03] 53.11 (16.2) [51.63, 54.62]
ACC Deep 80.44 (6.01) [79.87, 81] 48.14 (28.42) [45.51, 50.77] 87.15 (7.88) [86.42, 87.9]
ACC REM 78.98 (5.2) [78.5, 79.47] 28.99 (19.37) [27.19, 30.81] 90.72 (5.89) [90.17, 91.27]
ACC+T Wake 94.79 (3.93) [94.43, 95.17] 73.71 (17.9) [72.07, 75.41] 97.05 (2.79) [96.79, 97.32]
ACC+T Light 63.09 (6.8) [62.46, 63.72] 70.86 (12) [69.76, 71.98] 53.77 (16.32) [52.27, 55.31]
ACC+T Deep 82.69 (5.91) [82.14, 83.25] 50.06 (28.88) [47.33, 52.71] 89.67 (6.66) [89.07, 90.29]
ACC+T REM 79.9 (5.35) [79.4, 80.4] 32.38 (19.33) [30.55, 34.18] 91.04 (5.44) [90.55, 91.57]
ACC+T+HRV Wake 95.58 (3.5) [95.25, 95.92] 77.18 (16.77) [75.65, 78.76] 97.61 (2.11) [97.42, 97.81]
ACC+T+HRV Light 77.48 (6.14) [76.91, 78.05] 79.13 (7.38) [78.45, 79.82] 75.73 (11.75) [74.62, 76.84]
ACC+T+HRV Deep 89.11 (4.25) [88.72, 89.51] 69.57 (23.84) [67.39, 71.8] 93.73 (4.16) [93.35, 94.12]
ACC+T+HRV REM 90.16 (4.18) [89.78, 90.57] 75.89 (18.09) [74.23, 77.56] 93.75 (3.4) [93.44, 94.06]
ACC+T+HRV+C Wake 96.38 (3.12) [96.1, 96.68] 80.74 (14.12) [79.43, 82.06] 98.15 (1.87) [97.98, 98.33]
ACC+T+HRV+C Light 80.2 (5.53) [79.68, 80.73] 81.7 (6.97) [81.06, 82.35] 78.67 (10.63) [77.7, 79.67]
ACC+T+HRV+C Deep 90.64 (3.75) [90.29, 90.99] 74.44 (20.28) [72.56, 76.34] 94.63 (3.77) [94.28, 94.99]
ACC+T+HRV+C REM 90.87 (4.12) [90.49, 91.26] 78.08 (17.39) [76.5, 79.71] 94.12 (3.41) [93.8, 94.44]