Table 7.
The experimental performance of the proposed model (DNE-RL) vs other competitive deep learning benchmarks for Kaggle dataset.
Metric | GA | DE | PSO | GSK | MobileNet | VGGNet19 | ResNet50 | DenseNet12 | DNE-RL | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
AVG | 0.933488 | 0.924888 | 0.942884 | 0.948021 | 0.949502 | 0.950001 | 0.972881 | 0.966913 | 0.991441 | |
STD | 0.027901 | 0.012288 | 0.011142 | 0.014252 | 0.017881 | 0.023315 | 0.020994 | 0.013637 | 0.011042 | |
ACC | Best | 0.947991 | 0.937786 | 0.948788 | 0.958893 | 0.958812 | 0.961152 | 0.982441 | 0.971189 | 0.993668 |
Worst | 0.912298 | 0.915658 | 0.931229 | 0.932285 | 0.937881 | 0.927748 | 0.955571 | 0.952449 | 0.980671 | |
AVG | 0.949893 | 0.940174 | 0.956618 | 0.957782 | 0.958838 | 0.968841 | 0.982441 | 0.973861 | 0.993568 | |
STD | 0.037716 | 0.020781 | 0.030083 | 0.025151 | 0.023878 | 0.022274 | 0.027313 | 0.019669 | 0.021339 | |
Precision | Best | 0.968668 | 0.962881 | 0.972335 | 0.973991 | 0.968816 | 0.975561 | 0.986004 | 0.983315 | 0.996812 |
Worst | 0.908915 | 0.921007 | 0.913806 | 0.931401 | 0.927175 | 0.944767 | 0.952721 | 0.955672 | 0.968814 | |
AVG | 0.925933 | 0.912829 | 0.935581 | 0.929181 | 0.935535 | 0.942552 | 0.960112 | 0.953443 | 0.981445 | |
STD | 0.014047 | 0.018626 | 0.007996 | 0.009158 | 0.014663 | 0.018596 | 0.010052 | 0.008492 | 0.011381 | |
Recall | Best | 0.940116 | 0.936682 | 0.941887 | 0.937736 | 0.948778 | 0.955778 | 0.968784 | 0.959928 | 0.987886 |
Worst | 0.913005 | 0.904334 | 0.929981 | 0.920704 | 0.923051 | 0.932994 | 0.953008 | 0.942217 | 0.970221 | |
AVG | 0.932717 | 0.921633 | 0.940081 | 0.945771 | 0.947006 | 0.948003 | 0.969951 | 0.964412 | 0.989666 | |
STD | 0.015542 | 0.008797 | 0.012252 | 0.002363 | 0.006666 | 0.011882 | 0.016672 | 0.012331 | 0.004881 | |
F-measure | Best | 0.938812 | 0.935542 | 0.948788 | 0.949772 | 0.951332 | 0.954481 | 0.976866 | 0.969982 | 0.990454 |
Worst | 0.920094 | 0.916652 | 0.931176 | 0.938182 | 0.942553 | 0.935991 | 0.951331 | 0.957871 | 0.983353 | |
AVG | 0.934451 | 0.926656 | 0.940092 | 0.949882 | 0.951666 | 0.947781 | 0.974554 | 0.963999 | 0.990337 | |
STD | 0.022444 | 0.011434 | 0.008892 | 0.006772 | 0.021033 | 0.014403 | 0.009037 | 0.014544 | 0.007881 | |
AUC | Best | 0.945333 | 0.929922 | 0.948871 | 0.951991 | 0.969912 | 0.952662 | 0.979988 | 0.970002 | 0.992008 |
Worst | 0.911329 | 0.915004 | 0.934505 | 0.943303 | 0.936766 | 0.932242 | 0.968998 | 0.949889 | 0.982662 |