Skip to main content
. 2021 Jul 12;16(7):e0249053. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0249053

Table 1. Descriptive information for the comparisons included in the dataset.

Author and Reference Year Design Breed Production system Unit of interest Number of replicates Study length (d) Seaweed category Dose of seaweed Initial body weight (kg)
Control Treatment Control Treatment
Allen et al. [7] 2001 RBD ANG, ANG×HF, BRAH Beef Pen 12 12 146.5 A. nodosum 3.4 kg/ha 330.0 ± 17.32 325.0 ± 17.32
Allen et al. [7] 2001 RBD ANG, ANG×HF, BRAH Beef Pen 12 12 146.5 A. nodosum 3.4 kg/ha 360.0 ± 17.32 355.0 ± 17.32
Anderson et al. [8] 2006 RBD English crossbred Beef Pen 4 4 24 A. nodosum 2.0% DM 381.5 ± 9.86 384.5 ± 9.86
Anderson et al. [8] 2006 RBD English crossbred Beef Pen 4 4 14 A. nodosum 2.0% DM 381.5 ± 9.86 388.2 ± 9.86
Anderson et al. [8] 2006 RBD English crossbred Beef Pen 4 4 38 A. nodosum 2.0% DM 381.5 ± 9.86 385.9 ± 9.86
Antaya et al. [9] 2019 RBD Jersey Dairy ANI 10 10 28 A. nodosum 113 g/hd/d 420.0 ± 44.00 400.0 ± 36.00
Carter et al. [10] 2000 RCT Predominately British crosses Beef Pen 4 4 56 A. nodosum 273 g/hd/d
Cvetkovic et al. [11] 2004 RCT Holstein Dairy ANI 12 12 21 A. nodosum 114 g/hd/d
Gravett [12] 2000 RBD ANG & ANG cross Beef Pen 10 10 14 A. nodosum 1.0% diet as fed
Kidane et al. [13] 2015 4x4 LS Norwegian Red Dairy ANI 6 6 28 A. nodosum 160 g/hd/d
Williams et al. [3] 2009 2x2 fact ANG crossbred Beef ANI 6 6 13 A. nodosum 1.0% DM 367.9 ± 20.58 367.0 ± 20.58
Williams et al. [3] 2009 2x2 fact ANG crossbred Beef ANI 6 6 13 A. nodosum 1.0% DM 343.4 ± 20.58 329.8 ± 20.58
Kinley et al. [2] 2020 RBD BRAH×ANG Beef ANI 5 5 90 A. taxiformis 0.05% OM
Kinley et al. [2] 2020 RBD BRAH×ANG Beef ANI 5 5 90 A. taxiformis 0.1% OM
Kinley et al. [2] 2020 RBD BRAH×ANG Beef ANI 5 5 90 A. taxiformis 0.2% OM
Roque et al. [1] 2020 RCT ANG×HF Beef ANI 7 7 147 A. taxiformis 0.25% OM 357.0 ± 24.37 348.0 ± 24.37
Roque et al. [1] 2020 RCT ANG×HF Beef ANI 7 6 147 A. taxiformis 0.5% OM 357.0 ± 24.37 350.0 ± 22.56
Stefenoni et al. [14] 2021 4x4 LS Holstein Dairy ANI 20 20 7 A. taxiformis 0.25% DM
Stefenoni et al. [14] 2021 4x4 LS Holstein Dairy ANI 20 20 7 A. taxiformis 0.5% DM
Bendary et al. [15] 2013 RCT Friesian Dairy ANI 6 6 150 Othera 50 g/hd/d 534.0 ± 13.04 534.0 ± 13.04
Sharma & Datt [16] 2020 RCT Karan fries Beef ANI 6 6 150 Otherb 1.5% DM 415.9 ± 13.10 403.4 ± 14.10
Sharma & Datt [16] 2020 RCT Karan fries Beef ANI 6 6 150 Otherb 3.0% DM 415.9 ± 13.10 406.6 ± 10.15
Singh et al. [17] 2015 RCT Sahiwal Dairy ANI 4 4 126 Otherc 10% diet as fed
Mean ± SD 388.1 ± 18.26 382.9 ± 17.35

RBD = randomized block design; RCT = randomized controlled trial; LS = latin square; ANG = Angus; HF = Hereford; BRAH = Brahman; ANI = animal; A. nodosum = Ascophyllum nodosum; A. taxiformis = Asparagopsis taxiformis; Other = seaweed that is not A. nodosum or A. taxiformis; DM = dry matter; OM = organic matter.

a Seaweed meal (Crossgates Bioenergetics-Seaweeds Company, Gargrave, North Yorkshire, United Kingdom).

b Kappaphycus alvarezii & Gracilaria Salicornia.

c Sargassum wightii.