Skip to main content
. 2021 Jul 12;11(7):e048801. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2021-048801

Table 5.

Cochrane risk of bias assessment tool

Authors (year, country) Random sequence generation Allocation concealment Blinding (participants and personnel) Blinding outcome assessors Incomplete outcome data Selective reporting
Allen et al36 (2019, USA) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg
Andereck et al37 (2019, USA) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg
Arora et al38 (2019, USA) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg
Bourdeaux et al39 (2014, UK) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg
Buntinx et al40 (1993, Belgium) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg
Chiu et al41 (2018, USA) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg
Delgado et al42 (2018, USA) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg
Hemkens et al43 (2017, Switzerland) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg
Hempel et al44 (2014, USA) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg
Hsiang et al45 (2019, USA) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg
Kim et al46 (2018, USA) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg
Kullgren et al47 (2018, USA) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg
Lewis et al48 (2019, UK) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg
Meeker et al49 (2014, USA) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg
Meeker et al50 (2016, USA) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg
Nguyen and Davis51 (2019, USA) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg
O’Reilly-Shah et al52 (2018, USA) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg
Olson et al53 (2015, USA) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg
Orloski et al54 (2019, USA) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg
Parrino55 (1989, USA) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg
Patel et al58 (2014, USA) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg
Patel et al73 (2016, USA) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg
Patel et al57 (2016, USA) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg
Patel et al56 (2017, USA) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg
Patel et al59 (2018, USA) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg
Persell et al60 (2016, USA) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg
Ryskina et al61 (2018, USA) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg
Sacarny et al20 (2018, USA) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg
Sedrak et al62 (2017, USA) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg
Sharma et al63 (2019, USA) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg
Shively et al64 (2020, USA) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg
Srinivasan et al65 (2020, USA) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg
Suffoletto and Landau66 (2019, USA) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg
Szilagyi et al67 (2014, USA) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg
Trent et al68 (2018, USA) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg
Wigder et al69 (1999, USA) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg
Winickoff et al70 (1984, USA) First two studies:Inline graphic
Third study:Inline graphic
First two studies:Inline graphic
Third study:Inline graphic
First two studies:Inline graphic
Third study:Inline graphic
graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg
Zivin et al71 (2019, USA) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg
Zwank et al72 (2017, USA) graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf01.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf03.jpg graphic file with name bmjopen-2021-048801ilf02.jpg

Inline graphicindicates low risk of bias, Inline graphic indicates high risk of bias, and Inline graphic indicates unclear risk of bias. See 34 for a full description of the Cochrane Risk of Bias tool.