Skip to main content
. 2021 Jul 13;111:107692. doi: 10.1016/j.asoc.2021.107692

Table 6.

Accuracy gain comparison when using no SSDL (No MM) vs. MixMatch with the proposed loss balancing correction (MM+PBC), and to using MixMatch with no balancing correction (MM) vs. MixMatch with the proposed loss balancing correction (MM+PBC). The accuracy gain is evaluated for the tested number of labelled observations (10, 15 and 20). Italic entries correspond to non statistically meaningful gains, after performing a Wilcoxon test, with p>0.1.

SSDL COVID-19 COVID-19+ Comparison nl=10
nl=15
nl=20
Acc. gain Acc. gain Acc. gain
Costa Rican dataset 70% 30% MM+PBC vs. No MM +0.07 +0.046 +0.018
MM+PBC vs. MM +0.048 +0.046 +0.036
80% 20% MM+PBC vs. No MM +0.081 +0.06 +0.038
MM+PBC vs. MM +0.034 +0.038 +0.041

Chinese paediatric dataset 70% 30% MM+PBC vs. No MM +0.113 +0.115 +0.06
MM+PBC vs. MM + 0.023 + 0.031 + 0.028
80% 20% MM+PBC vs. No MM +0.09 +0.058 +0.031
MM+PBC vs. MM +0.1 +0.099 +0.066

Chest X-ray8 dataset 70% 30% MM+PBC vs. No MM +0.083 +0.092 +0.087
MM+PBC vs. MM + 0.033 +0.055 +0.057
80% 20% MM+PBC vs. No MM +0.069 +0.096 +0.056
MM+PBC vs. MM +0.063 +0.0774 +0.072

Indiana dataset 70% 30% MM+PBC vs. No MM +0.048 +0.063 +0.027
MM+PBC vs. MM +0.045 +0.082 +0.067
80% 20% MM+PBC vs. No MM +0.014 +0.059 +0.029
MM+PBC vs. MM + 0.056 +0.141 +0.09